Discworld Game Thread

[Uselesstwit]

I don't know dp, you seem to be assuming that scum would deliberately gang up on someone on day one. The only way I can see that happening is if they are trying to save on of their own. The only other two bw's with any steam behind them were mine and yours. Both of them were at less than half of what mantis had so I wouldn't expect a huge scum influence in yesterdays lynch. Most scum teams try not to be associated with each other in the early game.

[Feck]

Irre's clearness depends on if Zig gives out the town win condition to the scum team ... as there wasn't much of one I don't know if he would , also since I at least knew what Irre was hinting at .
Zig may have given out more than one win condition phrase ..... that's the problem with playing by role PM hints and why i've argued against it before .
Gonzo also has a point ,if there is a difference between the Vanilla town PMs and town Role PMs then outing your PM details can help scum hunt seers blockers etc .

BUT if Irre is town and all town got a similar PM then suspicion falls on people who could not see why she pointed out the lack of a real win condition .
..................................
and scum would be fucking stupid to vote on the same town player on Day one , suspicion falls on people by their votes more than anything.

personally If I were scum wouldn't put a vote on a town player another scum player had ,on day one unless there was a Damned good reason to rescue an important team member from the lynch .Scum may be a team but they sure don't want to be seen to be acting in unison FFS .

[oblivion]

zigmen takes pride in handcrafting role pms. I expect our win conditions to be equivalent, but the words identical? not so much.

feck, you probably remember the win condition cluster fuck in zigmen's time bomb game.

[amok]

Irre's clearness depends on if Zig gives out the town win condition to the scum team ... as there wasn't much of one I don't know if he would , also since I at least knew what Irre was hinting at .
Zig may have given out more than one win condition phrase ..... that's the problem with playing by role PM hints and why i've argued against it before .
Gonzo also has a point ,if there is a difference between the Vanilla town PMs and town Role PMs then outing your PM details can help scum hunt seers blockers etc .

BUT if Irre is town and all town got a similar PM then suspicion falls on people who could not see why she pointed out the lack of a real win condition.

Except Mantis didn't see it, either. My suspicion of her was mostly based, in fact, on that I thought she was Scum jumping on the chance to say the same thing I did, knowing I'd flip Town if lynched. I thought I'd be lynched for that, and I was also thinking Scum would think I'd be lynched for that. I'm surprised I wasn't.

Of course, I was wrong about Mantis. But I really did see nothing weird about my PM. It's being to click a bit now, but that's hindsight.

[amok]

Of course, I was wrong about Mantis. But I really did see nothing weird about my PM. It's being to click a bit now, but that's hindsight.

Typo: It's beginning to click...

[Feck]

zigmen takes pride in handcrafting role pms. I expect our win conditions to be equivalent, but the words identical? not so much.

feck, you probably remember the win condition cluster fuck in zigmen's time bomb game.

I was trying to forget that game .

[oblivion]

dude, that's like forgetting the Alamo or something.

[Magicziggy]

On a break

I don't know dp, you seem to be assuming that scum would deliberately gang up on someone on day one. The only way I can see that happening is if they are trying to save on of their own. The only other two bw's with any steam behind them were mine and yours. Both of them were at less than half of what mantis had so I wouldn't expect a huge scum influence in yesterdays lynch. Most scum teams try not to be associated with each other in the early game.

I'm agreeing with this.

[Magicziggy]

Irre's clearness depends on if Zig gives out the town win condition to the scum team ... as there wasn't much of one I don't know if he would , also since I at least knew what Irre was hinting at .
Zig may have given out more than one win condition phrase ..... that's the problem with playing by role PM hints and why i've argued against it before .
Gonzo also has a point ,if there is a difference between the Vanilla town PMs and town Role PMs then outing your PM details can help scum hunt seers blockers etc .

BUT if Irre is town and all town got a similar PM then suspicion falls on people who could not see why she pointed out the lack of a real win condition .
..................................
and scum would be fucking stupid to vote on the same town player on Day one , suspicion falls on people by their votes more than anything.

personally If I were scum wouldn't put a vote on a town player another scum player had ,on day one unless there was a Damned good reason to rescue an important team member from the lynch .Scum may be a team but they sure don't want to be seen to be acting in unison FFS .

A lot of sense in this.

[Magicziggy]

Note: I didn't see much in the clumping of votes stuff. Again, I guess you had to be there. There was no obvious rescue that I could see. A "Mantis is scum" meme spread quickly. I think an opportunist scum would have planted a vote though.

[Magicziggy]

If shizzle shows up, someone lasso him and tie him to a tree.
Then be very nice.

[oblivion]

He probably saw the thread size and bailed again.

[Feck]

Note: I didn't see much in the clumping of votes stuff. Again, I guess you had to be there. There was no obvious rescue that I could see. A "Mantis is scum" meme spread quickly. I think an opportunist scum would have planted a vote though.

Oh I think it is likely that scum placed one vote only if another scum member had votes on them ,think why add your vote if you know they BW is on a player you know will flip town ?

[oblivion]

Note: I didn't see much in the clumping of votes stuff. Again, I guess you had to be there. There was no obvious rescue that I could see. A "Mantis is scum" meme spread quickly. I think an opportunist scum would have planted a vote though.

Oh I think it is likely that scum placed one vote only if another scum member had votes on them ,think why add your vote if you know they BW is on a player you know will flip town ?

yeah...should see if I can dig up people who FoSed mantis earlier in the game, but went other directions as that final flurry of votes came in.

hmm.

[amok]

Note: I didn't see much in the clumping of votes stuff. Again, I guess you had to be there. There was no obvious rescue that I could see. A "Mantis is scum" meme spread quickly. I think an opportunist scum would have planted a vote though.

Oh I think it is likely that scum placed one vote only if another scum member had votes on them ,think why add your vote if you know they BW is on a player you know will flip town ?

OK, I've read this a couple of times, and either I'm have a stupid moment or there's a typo I can't decipher. I don't understand what you're saying here, Feck.