MGS3: Snake Eater Mafia - Tactical Espionage Action (GAME)

[charlou]

Anyone think Zigmen might have been the traitor, hence no info given on his death? Would be typically Gonzoesque to try to balance his posted PM error with something like that.

[Magicziggy]

Anyone think Zigmen might have been the traitor, hence no info given on his death? Would be typically Gonzoesque to try to balance his posted PM error with something like that.

possible. Anyone had experience of this no reveal stuff before?

[Magicziggy]

@feck. What was your mindset when playing traitor with no info?

[Azathoth]

Anyone think Zigmen might have been the traitor, hence no info given on his death? Would be typically Gonzoesque to try to balance his posted PM error with something like that.

possible. Anyone had experience of this no reveal stuff before?

Hopefully there will be a janitor role that has the info on him

[gib]

Anyone think Zigmen might have been the traitor, hence no info given on his death? Would be typically Gonzoesque to try to balance his posted PM error with something like that.

possible. Anyone had experience of this no reveal stuff before?

Hopefully there will be a janitor role that has the info on him

hopefully?

http://mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Janitor

says "The Janitor is an anti-Town role"

[Magicziggy]

Irre mentioned janitor and jailing last night. What gives?

[charlou]

Janitor vig?

The Janitor is an anti-Town role who "cleans up the body" after its kill, thus preventing players from learning anything about the player when they flip. At daybreak, it is simply said that the player died with no information about their role or their alignment.

Usually Janitor is X-Shot so as to not deny the Town too much information. In this case, the Janitor must choose whether or not to clean up the kill.

Janitor is usually anti-Town; however, Janitor Vigs have been known to exist (with the Janitor aspect compulsive).

[gib]

Anyone think Zigmen might have been the traitor, hence no info given on his death? Would be typically Gonzoesque to try to balance his posted PM error with something like that.

well there was clearly something weird about zig's role otherwise why the no reveal

[Gonzo]

LYNCHEE
01 Amok
02 andrewclunn
03 Azathoth [2.5] MagicZiggy, charlou
04 charlou
05 Contra [1] azathoth
06 DP
07 Feck
08 gib
09 Irre
10 MagicZiggy
11 MattShizzle [1] charlou
12 UselessTwit

[charlou]

Irre mentioned janitor and jailing last night. What gives?

Link please.

[gib]

Irre mentioned janitor and jailing last night. What gives?

a search for 'janitor' shows that was andrew:

http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 3#p1037233

It's not worth it to counter claim a scum fake cop claim on day 1, but is it generally considered a good idea to counter claim a doctor fake claim around here? I'd think not, so long as there's no janitor (as if there is a real doc, then when they die the fake claimer would be next to be lynched), so charlou's claim should go unanswered whether it's true or not. That said, I think we have to act as if it's true.

but he seems to be using it to mean jailkeeper, which is how my eyes read it at the time. This is the first i ever heard of janitor so it does seem weird that aza is now using that term

[charlou]

Anyone think Zigmen might have been the traitor, hence no info given on his death? Would be typically Gonzoesque to try to balance his posted PM error with something like that.

well there was clearly something weird about zig's role otherwise why the no reveal

If there is a janitor involved, there may have been nothing weird about zig's role at all.

Intriguing stuff.

[Feck]

@feck. What was your mindset when playing traitor with no info?

I did write a bit (and then didn't post it )about how I played Traitor ... Because I thought I did a good job of it and Maybe if we have a traitor they might not have grasped the subtleties so I'm not sure if I should tell you all how I played it just now .

[gib]

irre was talking about jailkeeper:

Subject: MGS3: Snake Eater Mafia - Tactical Espionage Action DAY 2

irre i nodded a lot reading your longish post there, i don't regret keeping my vote on zigmen either. What do you make of his claim?

Geez, I need to do a reread asap. I'd forgotten about his claim. So, can't be NK'd, is what he's saying. Interesting. In a gonzo game, that role might just be in play (in a raven game I'd never buy it.) If I were vig I'd be seriously tempted to try to kill him. Actually, I'm pretty sure that's what I'd do.

What is more interesting is contra's OTT response to zig's outing.

I'm adding contra nicely to the top of my scum pile.

iirc, zigmen claimed he can't be killed by friendly fire at night ... iow, scum can kill him.

ah, ok. That's a weird role claim. Zigmen and role claims, though... Scum could have a jailer role, and will jail zigmen tonight... Yeah, I guess I'm saying I don't buy zig's role claim.

[gib]

actually irre is talking there about jailer as a scum role, never heard of that