Tarot III Mafia: Game Thread

[charlou]

I'm really buying aza's claim, there's been no counterclaim, false claims almost never use a role that is probable, they tend to go for a rare role that might fit the flavor. Also his testy post to mz and char to get their votes off of him is text book aza. What I was asking about earlier is why people formed that bw in the first place. It seems to me that a quiet aza is almost always a town aza. I actually had him down as vanilla town yesterday just because that's when he's most likely to ignore a game.

So yeah dp is full of it, i'm just not sure it's something dp would do when he's scum.

Mz is really starting to worry me, his voting seemed odd yesterday, then today he buys aza's claim unquestioningly only to become doubtful when dp posts thoughts that all mafia players consider when a roleclaim is made. On top of this somehow he's giving me town cred for seeming to know aza's alignment before he outed, which is info scum have. It's his thinking that I should be fos'd if aza flipped scum but cleared if aza is town that really confuses me. It seems to me that scum are more likely to defend someone they know is town than a teammate.

re the bit I've bolded ... would like to hear your response to this, MZ ... when you're not driving, of course.

[charlou]

More from Feck would be helpful.

[charlou]

I'm happy to look at anyone who is not aza or dp. Ani was weird yesterday. Feck I'm unsure about. UT and charlou are in my town list. Athene leaning town. Shizzle is not imploding, so maybe scum.

re the bit I've bolded ... Why not DP?

[Magicziggy]

I've already said that UT pinged wrt to shielding aza.

[Magicziggy]

Because dp could be the doc.

[charlou]

There's a point ... but it wouldn't explain his bad logic wrt scum's response to Aza's claim.

I'm going with not.

[Magicziggy]

I disagree

[charlou]

I've already said that UT pinged wrt to shielding aza.

I will read UT's day one posts again ... meanwhile, a link to where you saw this would be good.

[Magicziggy]

I have dp/ aza as one of them is the doc.

I am weighing up whether dp would challenge aza in thus way if he were scum. I'm thinking not.

[Magicziggy]

I've already said that UT pinged wrt to shielding aza.

I will read UT's day one posts again ... meanwhile, a link to where you saw this would be good.

Later, when I get back on the computer. I'm installing a new wireless router because the old one packed up.

[charlou]

I found the UT post http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 36#p998136

hmmm ... I do recall thinking at the time that the question of why Az over DP indicated a lack of attention on UT's part ... As I pointed out, Az had been noted as being on the forum without posting in the game, while DP hadn't been seen at all.

[Magicziggy]

I would really like some input from Ani.

[charlou]

The UK players will be online later methinks.

[Magicziggy]

Just saying. He has contributed nothing.

Do you think I'm town charlou?

[Uselesstwit]

I found the UT post http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 36#p998136

hmmm ... I do recall thinking at the time that the question of why Az over DP indicated a lack of attention on UT's part ... As I pointed out, Az had been noted as being on the forum without posting in the game, while DP hadn't been seen at all.

I was paying attention char, but as I said, aza ignoring a game is hardly a scum tell in his case. It just seemed that you and mz used athene's observation to plant a vote while ignoring an equally absent person. I'm not sure if scum were to try and go under the radar they wouldn't just keep away from the site altogether. I am getting a strong scum hunting vibe off of you and am starting to lean a bit town on mz, but I must admit the way you two teamed up last night is worrying.