Old West Mafia game thread

[gib]

Looks to me like we've caught Gonzo as Scum, and DP and Irre seem very suspicious if I'm correct about Gonzo, cuz they tried to get some very shaky BWs going.

This post, sense it makes does not.
I voted irre based on her first post where it looks like she was saying "I'd be happy to see zig or gonzo lynched, but I won't go near the bws", interestingly both of you were at 3 votes at the time, so she would have been 4th vote on one of them, for those that believe in that one, but it would also have been a deciding vote one way or the other, votes feck, then unvotes once the zig/gonzo tie is broken, hmmm, think I was right first time ##vote irre##

DP I asked you if you actually read my post properly. Seems you still haven't.

in fairness i couldn't see anything in your first post about not going for the cheap vote

[irretating]

Looks to me like we've caught Gonzo as Scum, and DP and Irre seem very suspicious if I'm correct about Gonzo, cuz they tried to get some very shaky BWs going.

This post, sense it makes does not.
I voted irre based on her first post where it looks like she was saying "I'd be happy to see zig or gonzo lynched, but I won't go near the bws", interestingly both of you were at 3 votes at the time, so she would have been 4th vote on one of them, for those that believe in that one, but it would also have been a deciding vote one way or the other, votes feck, then unvotes once the zig/gonzo tie is broken, hmmm, think I was right first time ##vote irre##

DP I asked you if you actually read my post properly. Seems you still haven't.

in fairness i couldn't see anything in your first post about not going for the cheap vote

In my first post I outlined why I didn't lean scum on either zig or gonzo despite their debatably anti-town posts. I didn't say, as DP is claiming, that I like both of them for the lynch but what the hey I'll vote someone else

[gib]

Hi guys, sorry matt I thought you said this game starts your thursday ie my Friday. It's pure luck I checked in today.

OK, as UT mentioned, I am away on hols, with only tapatalk access and iphone so sorry I won't be keeping my super dooper spreadsheet.

My initial reaction to reading the thread so far is that I'm liking gonzo or zigmen for the lynch today, seeing as they both seem to be fishing for reactions. But, gonzo's lynch votes based on players saying something he thinks is anti-town, is his town tell. And zigmen could be fishing for specials (by dint of reactions to his blue skying a mass out) or he could just be trying to be analytical.

@@vote UT@@

##vote feck## cos I'm not seeing any reason for his seer outing that he says is fake

my bold

[irretating]

I'm tapatalking. Can't see bold

[gib]

bold is "I'm liking gonzo or zigmen for the lynch today"

[irretating]

"...initial reaction...but...town tell...and..."

I know it was more than a two sentence post, but

[gib]

fair enough

[irretating]

MZ is your gonzo vote your way of saying you want to save zigmen from the lynch?

btw tapatalking and no computer for a spreadsheet sucks..does anyone have a vote tally? And, how people have moved on and off the BWs? TIA

[irretating]

Re nite chat I have no idea

[gib]

gonzo's tr profile shows he was online there like 5 hours after he stopped posting here

[gib]

yeh i have a vote count, hold on

[irretating]

gonzo's tr profile shows he was online there like 5 hours after he stopped posting here

He's had a bad run of being lynched early as town. I'm sitting here wondering which of the two BWs I'm happier about. I'll reread all gonzo's posts now, to see if I should vote on one of the BWs to save the less scummy-seeming player

[gib]

zigmen 2 (feck votes, gonzo votes, jerome votes, feck unvotes)
r.c 0 (zig votes, zig unvotes)
gonzo 4 (zig votes, UT votes, r.c votes, mz votes)
feck 0 (irre votes, irre unvotes)
irre 1 (mz votes, DP votes, DP unvotes, mz unvotes, DP votes)

feck still to revote
irre still to revote
gib still to vote
ksen still to vote
mantis still to vote

[irretating]

##vote zigmen##

He seems waaaaay scummier than gonzo.

[irretating]

Thanks so much, gib. I don't get a scum vibe off gonzo. On reread zigmen looks bad.