The Innsmouth Look game thread.

[oblivion]

I'm still not convinced our 2nd kill is an SK, though I'm keeping worst case scenario in mind. To the denizens of Innsmouth, Dagon is a good guy. He's g'g'g'g' grand daddy. We sacrifice outsiders to him.

[Uselesstwit]

Mantis you're math is wrong, I'm guessing 3 scum plus the sk so we only have 7 town atm.

Once again Ob, i'm sorry I didn't listen to you, but being your protector really sucks. I got caught up with my role instead of figuring out what was best for town.

I think we're boned, if we kill ob tonight we're down to 6 town 3 scum 1 indie(probably) two nights of kills and unless the sk hits scum at least once we're gone. If we lynch a scum today it's 7 town 2 scum and probably an indie. they kill ob tonight and we'll still lose if the sk doesn't hit a scum.

I just don't really see how town was supposed to win this.

[oblivion]

Town: UT

Townish: Mantis, b.tern, Ironclad, DP

Unsure: r.c, Charlou

Scummy-looking: ksen, Athene, Feck (he's on the border between unsure and scummy-looking, could go in either bucket)

Ironclad looks townish for a lot of reasons, but his vote reasons look random and goofy even when I agree that someone looks scummy. I don't get his focus on Mantis at all. He's right for the wrong reasons that I'm going to fuck up this game.

I'm totally down for either a ksen or Athene lynch. And despite UT's request that I not try to get myself lynched today, I'm ok with being the lynch, myself. I'll require convincing of anyone else.

I've got for town to least

oblivion
ut
ironclad
b.ternarius
DP
ksen
Feck
Athene
Charlou
r.c

why is r.c at the bottom of your list? because diva was on him? She thought Feck was scummier, right?

[charlou]

I'm still suspicious of Athene for even considering about a No-lynch there are very very few times when a no-lynch can possibly help town this wasn't one of them .

A no lynch would have kept crumple in the game. I said lynching him was an understandable and good decision, but as Mantis pointed out, the numbers don't look good .. I think we have royally fucked up.

Feck, what do you make of Ironclad's posts?

[Uselesstwit]

I'm still not convinced our 2nd kill is an SK, though I'm keeping worst case scenario in mind. To the denizens of Innsmouth, Dagon is a good guy. He's g'g'g'g' grand daddy. We sacrifice outsiders to him.

if it was a vig instead of an sk wouldn't there be 4 scum then. Unless aza deliberately made them light because of you.

[oblivion]

yeah, I think my instinct was right that we couldn't risk killing any other town besides me yesterday.

god damn it. I don't know what to do if I ever get this role again. I've tried it both ways - staying quiet and outing it early. Outing it on day 1 is a nonstarter. without some sort of track record it would be dismissed out of hand as jestering.

[Uselesstwit]

i'm starting to get concerned about mantis. she seemed pretty sure feck was scum yesterday, but now 4 people are further down her scum list. I also thought her questions about charlou had a whiff of wifom generation about them.

[Ironclad]

I'm still suspicious of Athene for even considering about a No-lynch there are very very few times when a no-lynch can possibly help town this wasn't one of them .

A no lynch would have kept crumple in the game. I said lynching him was an understandable and good decision, but as Mantis pointed out, the numbers don't look good .. I think we have royally fucked up.

Feck, what do you make of Ironclad's posts?

Just to say, all I got was the same as Irr did one day-1. an invisible force and dreams of winged creatures and towers. I am just thinking this is reinforcing my thoughts and hence my voting.
My post style is me trying to get into the theme, I thought, I hope it isn't too confusing.

I've voted today and I'm saying no more on the matter. See you on day-4, I hope.

[oblivion]

yeah, I've asked her about that as well. She could slip out of my town pile today.

[oblivion]

I'm still suspicious of Athene for even considering about a No-lynch there are very very few times when a no-lynch can possibly help town this wasn't one of them .

A no lynch would have kept crumple in the game. I said lynching him was an understandable and good decision, but as Mantis pointed out, the numbers don't look good .. I think we have royally fucked up.

Feck, what do you make of Ironclad's posts?

Just to say, all I got was the same as Irr did one day-1. an invisible force and dreams of winged creatures and towers. I am just thinking this is reinforcing my thoughts and hence my voting.
My post style is me trying to get into the theme, I thought, I hope it isn't too confusing.

I've voted today and I'm saying no more on the matter. See you on day-4, I hope.

your vision has to be the result of someone's night action, or some sort of game mechanism we don't know about yet.

why do you think the GM would set up a mechanism to reinforce your thoughts and votes? That's not mafia. We play by our skill and our wits, not by hints, clues and signposts from the GM.

And especially not any clues from Aza. He's one twisted fucker of a GM.

[charlou]

I'm still suspicious of Athene for even considering about a No-lynch there are very very few times when a no-lynch can possibly help town this wasn't one of them .

A no lynch would have kept crumple in the game. I said lynching him was an understandable and good decision, but as Mantis pointed out, the numbers don't look good .. I think we have royally fucked up.

Feck, what do you make of Ironclad's posts?

Just to say, all I got was the same as Irr did one day-1. an invisible force and dreams of winged creatures and towers. I am just thinking this is reinforcing my thoughts and hence my voting.
My post style is me trying to get into the theme, I thought, I hope it isn't too confusing.

I've voted today and I'm saying no more on the matter. See you on day-4, I hope.

Fuckit, I'm going to be bold and flat out ask you if you're a special because I think the way things stand now, we need all the information we can get. Are you?


crosspost ob .. I'm wondering if there's an element of RatSkep style mafia fantasy play in Ironclad's posts.

[Feck]

@ Charlou Re Ironclad I think he gets better grass than I do . And will I concentrate on posts I can understand first before I try to understand where Iron clad is coming from .

UT do you have the same role as Oblivion ? i'm confused as to how you fit in with her ,I get that she can clear you because of shared info in a pm but what your actual role is is lost on me (or maybe I need a drink )

[Uselesstwit]

I'm still suspicious of Athene for even considering about a No-lynch there are very very few times when a no-lynch can possibly help town this wasn't one of them .

A no lynch would have kept crumple in the game. I said lynching him was an understandable and good decision, but as Mantis pointed out, the numbers don't look good .. I think we have royally fucked up.

Feck, what do you make of Ironclad's posts?

Just to say, all I got was the same as Irr did one day-1. an invisible force and dreams of winged creatures and towers. I am just thinking this is reinforcing my thoughts and hence my voting.
My post style is me trying to get into the theme, I thought, I hope it isn't too confusing.

I've voted today and I'm saying no more on the matter. See you on day-4, I hope.

your vision has to be the result of someone's night action, or some sort of game mechanism we don't know about yet.

why do you think the GM would set up a mechanism to reinforce your thoughts and votes? That's not mafia. We play by our skill and our wits, not by hints, clues and signposts from the GM.

And especially not any clues from Aza. He's one twisted fucker of a GM.

Unfortunately if he's played at ratskep, they do rely on hints and clues from the gm. That's why I refer to ratskep mafia as a mafia flavored party game. it's still fun, but it's not true mafia.

[oblivion]

they still do that? I was kinda hoping real mafia had seeped over from ratz by osmosis.

[Mantisdreamz]

Town: UT

Townish: Mantis, b.tern, Ironclad, DP

Unsure: r.c, Charlou

Scummy-looking: ksen, Athene, Feck (he's on the border between unsure and scummy-looking, could go in either bucket)

Ironclad looks townish for a lot of reasons, but his vote reasons look random and goofy even when I agree that someone looks scummy. I don't get his focus on Mantis at all. He's right for the wrong reasons that I'm going to fuck up this game.

I'm totally down for either a ksen or Athene lynch. And despite UT's request that I not try to get myself lynched today, I'm ok with being the lynch, myself. I'll require convincing of anyone else.

I've got for town to least

oblivion
ut
ironclad
b.ternarius
DP
ksen
Feck
Athene
Charlou
r.c

why is r.c at the bottom of your list? because diva was on him? She thought Feck was scummier, right?

I don't know. He was on here earlier today, and no post from him. His posts haven't been very suspicious, they've been more neat and friendly, and he's making decent points. But - they've mostly consist of a few player analysis's. But, ya - I think Diva's mentioning of him is what is making me rethink. We obviously can't get her to expand on why she thought that. Her fos of him got lost in the jumble of the end of first day.

Another thing - is that I'm trying to narrow it down. I'm comfortable with you, UT being town (for obvious reasons). b.ternarius made several posts that looked like townish frustration at our foses towards her. DP brought up the fact that Aza doesn't usually send block messages against Irre. (Irre thought this would have been a poor case to make as scum). Ironclad looks town.

Aside from the jester reaction that I focused on Charlou for.. she does seem townish . . .

leaving
ksen, Feck, Athene, r.c

and r.c just happens to lie somewhat closer to the top, for me