The Innsmouth Look game thread.

[ksen]

ssshhhhh....don't tell him!

[charlou]

It's mafia ... a game. I don't see any reason to point a finger of blame in this case.


I hope diva will reconsider and come back to play again.

I wasn't blaming. I'm trying to figure out if Feck intentionally did it because he knew diva would most likely meltdown and draw a lynch.

sorry .. I was kinda thrown by the diva leaving thing, and didn't see your question in terms of simple game strategy.

[oblivion]

you know who else turned up just after the nick of time? Athene and ksen.

[Ironclad]

ssshhhhh....don't tell him!

[Linus]

I think he looks more scummy than others do, but not scummy enough to ignore other players' scumminess. I haven't played with him before iirc, so I don't know his usual style.

Which other players are you thinking of here?

[Athene]

you know who else turned up just after the nick of time? Athene and ksen.

Who did you end up voting for?

[Linus]

ssshhhhh....don't tell him!

Now that you know what "UT" means, could you tell me what you think of his contributions?

[oblivion]

you know who else turned up just after the nick of time? Athene and ksen.

Who did you end up voting for?

I took my vote off diva after I woke up and caught up with the thread. I didn't put a vote down. I'm concerned about b.tern, but I've seen her mislynched too many times lately. And I'm concerned about you, but was getting mixed enough signals to not want to put a vote down on you at this time.

What do you think about the diva pile-on?

[Ironclad]

ssshhhhh....don't tell him!

Now that you know what "UT" means, could you tell me what you think of his contributions?

UT is pulling more names out than a bingo caller. I'm not sure what this means right now. What do you think?

[Ironclad]

Back in a bit, got to go shopping.

Does this forum use tapatalk? It's on the list but I can't sign in.

[b.ternarius]

I think he looks more scummy than others do, but not scummy enough to ignore other players' scumminess. I haven't played with him before iirc, so I don't know his usual style.

Which other players are you thinking of here?

Yesterday I thought oblivion looked a little scummy, with her change of style (which hasn't been entirely consistent, imv, but it is difficult to change completely all in one fell swoop as it were), and also Feck, because he seemed more confident than he usually appears when playing town. There are players here I don't know, or have only seen one game played by, so some of them look scummy but I may just be reacting to what is their normal style of play. I won't name that category unless I see others reacting as well.

Today I don't think Oblivion is scummy sounding, but that might be because I'm seeing within her play her more familiar (to me) townish responses. She seems also to be concentrating more on when people show up and respond to things, something I haven't noticed in other games with her, and that seems to be part of what she is trying to do.

I don't see feck as scum to day either. I'm not finding anyone pinging hard yet.

And fwiw, I could not see diva as scum yesterday.

Tbh though, I am not that good at sussing out scum, and am often surprised.

[b.ternarius]

OT, how does one multi-quote on this board? I has a dumb.

[Linus]

Now that you know what "UT" means, could you tell me what you think of his contributions?

UT is pulling more names out than a bingo caller. I'm not sure what this means right now. What do you think?

I think talking about many players is a town tell, though it depends on what is said. The only thing I find I notable so far about UT is that he seems to have interpreted Athene's and Oblivion's posts as them eventually leaning town about each other, if I read UT's comment right.

[Athene]

you know who else turned up just after the nick of time? Athene and ksen.

Who did you end up voting for?

I took my vote off diva after I woke up and caught up with the thread. I didn't put a vote down. I'm concerned about b.tern, but I've seen her mislynched too many times lately. And I'm concerned about you, but was getting mixed enough signals to not want to put a vote down on you at this time.

I know what you mean, it get's so confusing on day 1, so many people, so many tells, how is a poor mafia player supposed to know who to vote for? (((hugs)))

What do you think about the diva pile-on?

Not really a pile-on imo.
You seemed to start it by mildly fosing diva then putting a vote on her later. In between that time nobody responded to your fos. Mantis calls for diva, diva appears and foses r.c and feck, votes for r.c. R.C magically appears. There is an interaction between diva and various others, no significant foses on diva that I could see then suddenly Feck puts a vote down, doesn't really explain his vote other then to allude to some foses etc that diva made - he also says he's hungover as part of his reason for voting diva. Irre then votes for diva over a figure of speech, charlou votes for diva for dummy spitting out and for heavily fosing feck while voting r.c. Ob then unvotes diva on the grounds that the meltodown doesn't seem like her scum game.

Two votes bother me, fecks and yours, you start the bw and then you unvote (distancing yourself?) but you don't vote for anybody else even though you were around.

Feck pings when he uses his drink problem as an excuse for dodgy play, and with his initial 'joke' vote made after there had been a lot of stuff going on. The vote on diva was random, and his refusal to explain is troublesome.

[Athene]

Fake ETA, you start the bw and then unvote after it has found some traction.