Starfleet Game thread

[oblivion]

faintheartedly, the only other lynch I could get behind at the moment would be UT.

[gib]

if she flips scum then we carry on doing things however the fuck we've been doing them

if she flips town then i'm not sure what that will tell us

[gib]

faintheartedly, the only other lynch I could get behind at the moment would be UT.

it pinged when UT carried on being defensive after successfully debunking my fos (i'm assuming the 'we' thing checks out btw)

[grit]

anyone got a count

It's a slam dunk on Mantis at the moment. Irre still has herself voted, and I think UT is on bili and Aden on Feck.

[Feck]

faintheartedly, the only other lynch I could get behind at the moment would be UT.

I agree with this

[oblivion]

if she flips scum then we carry on doing things however the fuck we've been doing them

if she flips town then i'm not sure what that will tell us

fortunetellerish question:

how many of your reads have been shot down so far? and how does this compare to other recent games?

[grit]

I'm looking forward to seeing what Irre makes of all of this.

[Uselesstwit]

I always love it when I become scummier when i'm not around. Read my post about the WE thing up above. As for the missing nightfall, yep did that, in case no one noticed I was a bit miffed about that. Enough to risk getting a god kill myself by admitting I had also sent PMs.
So I didn't read the who godkill post, went straight to responding.

As for today, I'm thinking that mantis is a good lynch candidate just based on what we think might have went on last night. But if she is scum we probably need to reevaluate feck.

expressionless reactivity

this reads like you don't think mantis is scum.

I really don't have a read on her much atm, last night she seemed fairly scummy but i'm less sure today. i just think with what ksen told us and there being no night kill it makes her a very strong candidate. I just wish I had more than a mere mechanical reason for thinking that.

[Bilirubin]

Just caught up with activities ITT to the moment. Glad to see no further whiteboard links have been posted.

Just FYI, I have a condo board meeting tonight from 6-8 MDST, so there will be an extended period where I will be afk.

[Uselesstwit]

ob, am I wrong about irre being more likely to throw in the towel as a caught scum than as town? I can't ever remember her self voting as town but she has done it as scum before.

[Bilirubin]

ob, am I wrong about irre being more likely to throw in the towel as a caught scum than as town? I can't ever remember her self voting as town but she has done it as scum before.

Links?

[Uselesstwit]

this is the one i remember clearly

http://www.rationalia.com/forum/viewtop ... 83#p879483

[Uselesstwit]

never mind that's not the one i was looking for, messed up the link, one sec.

how do i just search a thread instead of all her posts?

[oblivion]

ob, am I wrong about irre being more likely to throw in the towel as a caught scum than as town? I can't ever remember her self voting as town but she has done it as scum before.

I don't remember her doing it as scum or town.

In a recent game she and I both played, I fatalistically self-voted at one point because I thought the player in the leading bandwagon was town, and that I'd be the next lynch anyway. It had an interesting impact on the day if not the game.

I wondered if irre has something similar in mind, if nothing else as a signal I would notice.

[gib]

if she flips scum then we carry on doing things however the fuck we've been doing them

if she flips town then i'm not sure what that will tell us

fortunetellerish question:

how many of your reads have been shot down so far? and how does this compare to other recent games?

lol u are so far out of character, you sure the relaxation of your PR isn't the GM balancing things - the subtle punishment we all been looking out for?

the only 'read' i got right as far as we know so far is the denny thing - it was an objective scumtell so i had something to keep pushing out there. I think bili, if he's town, hoped i managed to do the same with the UT 'good catch' , i know i did.

for gut reads it certainlly looks like i fucked up over ksen when i voted him, if irre's scum then she gets the credit for making me misread ksen, if she's town then i'll blame the weed

pretty much every other read i've had i keep flip flopping on - my gut isn't happy with my vote on mantis but as has been noted, objectively it's the right thing to do