Starfleet Game thread

[divagreen]

divagreen please forgive me for pyrotechnically exploding us both in roulette. caution is my patronym. submissiveness is not, unfortunately.

This isn't even about that, so don't even try it. This is my experience with you when you have been the mayor. In the games that I have played with you where you have been mayor you have had a tendency to lynch town.

I thought the same thing in the Russian Roulette game, that is why I did not vote for you then.

I also think that leadership roles should be shared; that is how players learn. That is just good group dynamics.

[irretating]

Next thing is the Mayor vote.

I don't object to gib too much, but I think, posting restriction or not, Ob would be a safer choice.

I disagree. Ob has a pretty good record of lynching town when she is mayor, so no, I don't think that she is a safer choice. I don't fully trust her judgment.

You haven't played enough mafia with her IMO.

[irretating]

divagreen please forgive me for pyrotechnically exploding us both in roulette. caution is my patronym. submissiveness is not, unfortunately.

This isn't even about that, so don't even try it. This is my experience with you when you have been the mayor. In the games that I have played with you where you have been mayor you have had a tendency to lynch town.

I thought the same thing in the Russian Roulette game, that is why I did not vote for you then.

I also think that leadership roles should be shared; that is how players learn. That is just good group dynamics.

Please tell me a player who, as mayor, lynches mainly scum (over the long run of mafia).

[divagreen]

Stay out of it Irre. Please let Ob and I sort this out ourselves. I am not going into it anymore, I have my opinion and that it is based on my experience with her, not on what other people say.

Maybe this convo needs to happen at another time, but I think that it is perfectly appropriate to voice my opinion even if it is not a popular one. I am not saying she is a shitty player or anything of the like, I think quite the opposite. But I just don't trust her judgment at the mo as far as a mayor position.

[irretating]

Stay out of it Irre. Please let Ob and I sort this out ourselves. I am not going into it anymore, I have my opinion and that it is based on my experience with her, not on what other people say.

Maybe this convo needs to happen at another time, but I think that it is perfectly appropriate to voice my opinion even if it is not a popular one. I am not saying she is a shitty player or anything of the like, I think quite the opposite. But I just don't trust her judgment at the mo as far as a mayor position.

Take it out of the game. Then I won't respond to it. You lobbed it into the game, I'm free to reply.

[Bilirubin]

Guys, how often does the mayor weighted voting come into play in a typical game?

[irretating]

Guys, how often does the mayor weighted voting come into play in a typical game?

Well yeah, there is that, too.

[Adenosine]

Next thing is the Mayor vote.

I don't object to gib too much, but I think, posting restriction or not, Ob would be a safer choice.

I disagree. Ob has a pretty good record of lynching town when she is mayor, so no, I don't think that she is a safer choice. I don't fully trust her judgment.

I know you want this left alone but...it isn't just the Mayor that decides the lynch, it's the whole town. And I am yet to find a Mayor who has a good record with lynching. Mainly because it isn't "their" record, it's towns.

[Adenosine]

Also, is Nightfall in five minutes?

[Zigmen]

13 minutes

[Adenosine]

Thanks.

[divagreen]

Next thing is the Mayor vote.

I don't object to gib too much, but I think, posting restriction or not, Ob would be a safer choice.

I disagree. Ob has a pretty good record of lynching town when she is mayor, so no, I don't think that she is a safer choice. I don't fully trust her judgment.

I know you want this left alone but...it isn't just the Mayor that decides the lynch, it's the whole town. And I am yet to find a Mayor who has a good record with lynching. Mainly because it isn't "their" record, it's towns.

I look at a person's voting entire voting record, whether they are mayor or not. In most of the games that I have played with Oblivion she has been the mayor, so hers has come under the most scrutiny, so that is why I said, "as a mayor, she...".

I concede to Irre's point that I have probably not played enough games with her, but I am basing my opinion on the games that I have played with her. It is subject to change from game to game and that is for everyone, whenever I need to take in account for someone's voting history.

[Zigmen]

Nightfall

Results shortly.

[Zigmen]

You all surround Denny with Phasers Drawn. Captain Kirk steps to the forefront and announces that he knows how to deal with a trator. He gives Denny a real tongue lashing.

Denny, being a green-haired Romulan, is instantly stunned by human saliva.

The punch to Denny's head, though, is enough to kill him.

Denny was Green-haired Romulan Chick, and was Scum.
\
The living:

01. gib
02. Aza
03. ksen
04. grit
05. Uselesstwit
06. oblivion
07. Feck
08. irretating
09. Adenosine
10. Little Indians! Divagreen
12. Mantisdreamz
13. bilirubin


The dead:

11. DennyB - Scum

Night moves are due in 11 hours, by 11 AM EST.

Night Chat is allowed.

GM NOTE: Grit has broken the rule against editing posts. His team will receive a fair punishment tonight or tomorrow.

Oblivion is your Mayor

[Mantisdreamz]

Mantis and Adenosine, yes. Is it typical to have so many non voters on day 1?

Mantis is working and Adenosine is doing detective work I think. He is on at RatSkep reading Irre's game.

thanks Diva.

vote Irre... from what I see so far

Which is...?

Also why the change of heart on diva?

Just caught up with everything now.. I was thinking of voting for her based on her lynch on Feck. Who (Feck) I was seeing at the time as not being scummish. (Granted, this was at the beginning of the day - nearly 24 hours from this post). I've noticed we haven't seen a lot from Feck lately.

Denny looks to be the lynch today. Question -- Irre, earlier in the thread today you said that Denny seemed townish. Now, you are voting for him -- you said it's the 'least worst choice'.... did your mind change? or are you still reluctant?

So mysterious.

I unvoted Irre in response to reading more of the thread. I didn't see your question above - "why the change of heart on diva?"


grit - too bad. you were playing an awesome scum game.


I've got gib, Ob, UT as town. Most people probably do. I'm also trusting Ob on her read of Aza right now