Darkover Mafia Game Thread

[CookieJon]

Guys, we have Cookie caught in one lie as well as his unexplained knowledge of Ade's hiding..

1. It wasn't a lie. Maybe deliberately misleading, but not a lie since "You could not find Adenosine last night.", I didn't actually get to block him.

2. My knowledge of Ade's hiding is not unexplained, since I just explained it.

[charlou]

I reread the thread, and decided Adenosine is an SK.

Linus made the point already about SKs choosing to hide or kill each night ... I looked up the Elfquest link and oblivion did mention that the SK in that game could choose to hide or kill each night. Cookie tried to block Ade, but Ade was hiding. Ade eventually said he'd hidden (to avoid the cats). Ade was keen to put the night two death down to an SK, and to point out it wasn't him because he was hiding. The night two death was a scum (cat) kill, IMO.

[Linus]

Charlou and Linus:

Why Ade over Cookie?

Mostly because of hiding which I associate with SK, though I had not heard of the Coward role---it's another possibility.

[CookieJon]

Ok I'm off to bed now.

Zigmen, if you still doubt me then pls before lynching my, at least read back through the thread from the point of view that I AM telling the truth, and ask yourself if my behaviour is inconsistent with what I'm claiming.

Later folks!

[Feck]

Vote Adenosine I had to decide between one of the two . @Linus I am the watcher

[Linus]

Victim of a crescent sword? That doesn't sound like a cat-person attack. Our indie is definitely a Serial Killer, I would say, taking out the Regent like that.

I concur!

Any other thoughts today?

[Zigmen]

Sounds reasonable, as far as the SK thing.

Unvote

Vote Adenosine

[ksen]

vote zigmen

And the people that have been cleared need to stick together. I'd like to lynch bolero because she has been pinging for me all game.

[ksen]

'k I'm convinced vote ade

[charlou]

Vote Adenosine I had to decide between one of the two . @Linus I am the watcher

Sure you're not the scum prostitute/roleblocker?

[charlou]

There are three reasons I ask, Feck ... One, the coincidence of picking both Mantis and I to "watch" on the nights we were visited and scratched ... Two, the fact that the watcher role* is not as you depicted it ... and Three, one of the reasons I voted for diva was because she used a term for the first time that I know you like to use in relation to being scum: ebil.

I'm happy with my vote on the SK ... but wanted to post this as I may not be back online before nightfall, and may not be here after nightfall.

[charlou]

Two, the fact that the watcher role* is not as you depicted it ...

The mafia wiki link says ... read it carefully people ...

The Watcher is most commonly understood to be an information role that can target a person at night and learn who else targeted (or visited) that person on that same night.

[charlou]

There's a fourth reason I'm skeptical of Feck's claim ... game balance.

[Mantisdreamz]

There's a fourth reason I'm skeptical of Feck's claim ... game balance.

yes, but how would he know the precise details. Specifically mentioning cat hag


vote Adenosine

[charlou]

If that's his role, he'd know.