Ethics of Castration

[Atheist-Lite]

Chemical or mechanical castration is a effective means in reducing libido in certain unsavoury people. Is it effective? Even if it isn't effective is this a re-assuring way of obtaining justice for society? Should vigilante castration be punished as a serious crime if the 'victim' is a repeat offeder or caught doing what they shouldn't? Let's talk castration or 'newtering' if your sqeamish.

[.Morticia.]

I've proposed castration as a solution to most the world's problems on many occasions and, strangely enough, haven't received much support from the male side .

Go figure.

[Animavore]

I've proposed castration as a solution to most the world's problems on many occasions and, strangely enough, haven't received much support from the male side .

Go figure.

Why not ovary removal?

[Atheist-Lite]

I've proposed castration as a solution to most the world's problems on many occasions and, strangely enough, haven't received much support from the male side .

Go figure.

Why not ovary removal?

A more complicated procedure. Male castration can be done using a simple flick knife at the back of the pub. It isn't rocket science to cut off a couple of balls.

[Gawdzilla Sama]

1170820794384.gif

[.Morticia.]

I've proposed castration as a solution to most the world's problems on many occasions and, strangely enough, haven't received much support from the male side .

Go figure.

Why not ovary removal?

because it's not women who run the world and create all the problems

[Cunt]

I think chemical or mechanical castration are pretty useless. If a male sexual offender had been castrated (let's say BOTH ways), would you be comfortable leaving him alone in a room with a sleeping woman? What if that male sexual offender had agreed to castration (again, BOTH ways) as a way to assure his early release from prison? Would you then think he was 'safe'?

I say it doesn't help in either case, and I have known people who have been chemically castrated, and are back in their community. Rape can be done with a finger, screwdriver or caribou antler. Many will say that rape isn't about sex, but about power. I don't agree 100%, but it IS sometimes a power demonstration. Balls or no balls, some will be predators.

Oh, if the castration is done by mechanically removing the balls from the offender by severing the neck, it might be more effective. I am not supportive of capital punishment, but it would be effective as a means to curb the desire of the sexual offender.

[Atheist-Lite]

I think chemical or mechanical castration are pretty useless. If a male sexual offender had been castrated (let's say BOTH ways), would you be comfortable leaving him alone in a room with a sleeping woman? What if that male sexual offender had agreed to castration (again, BOTH ways) as a way to assure his early release from prison? Would you then think he was 'safe'?

I say it doesn't help in either case, and I have known people who have been chemically castrated, and are back in their community. Rape can be done with a finger, screwdriver or caribou antler. Many will say that rape isn't about sex, but about power. I don't agree 100%, but it IS sometimes a power demonstration. Balls or no balls, some will be predators.

Oh, if the castration is done by mechanically removing the balls from the offender by severing the neck, it might be more effective. I am not supportive of capital punishment, but it would be effective as a means to curb the desire of the sexual offender.

Sounds good to me.