Timebomb Game Thread

[Mantisdreamz]

I think I might know what you are on about though..........

Do share.

Well same thing as Ob. I just don't think it's a good idea. Maybe we are thinking a similar thing... or maybe hers is different, I'm not sure.

[Mantisdreamz]

Also, I really don't know what to make about these cell phone calls, and words that appear to be in relation to someone's code words. Does anyone have an idea ?

[oblivion]

Jut a few things I want to respond to from first page:

Mantis has been left alone by scum for 2 days running. This makes me think we need to put her over the top today.

I actually think that's why I have been left alone.. why would scum waste 4 points (or however many) to put me over the top when all I need is one... I think they are betting on town arming me... or, one of them, in the day round.

someone "wasted" a hit to put me over the top on night 2. I dunno.

strange.... I guess it's because scum think that no one's going to vote you during the day. But the funny thing is.... it's not like you're going to be put out of the game, and hence not be able to contribute any more. So -- putting myself in scum's mind -- I would rather just make sure that an appropriate number of people would be armed. Why they would waste votes to go over the top on you specifically, is kind of a mystery.. I think.

If they thought I was a special, it would have made sense.

it was an interesting choice. Not that I'm complaining about drawing those points. All in all, I'm fine with it. It's freed me up to worry about other stuff than whether I'm at risk of being armed.

[Mantisdreamz]

And I think it's worth knowing by just how much Fuzzy, Gib, and Gonzo's votes changed by last night. It will at least give us a clue on who acted on who. Ie - vig, doctor, scum. Does anyone else agree on that?

[charlou]

There is still stuff about night 1 that I simply am afraid to speculate out loud regarding.

those two hits, though, they've been huge in my theories about what is going on.

Likewise ... not the afraid to speculate part, but that they're significant and have factored into my thinking and gameplay since. I still don't know which of us were hit by whom.

Either way I look at it has pros and cons ... Did you find that too, ob?

pros and cons, yes. and other stuff. but, I did get the impression that we were sort of on the same wavelength regarding the vig yesterday.

Pretty sure we were, but it's impossible to know for sure without spelling it out and we can't do that either. Fucking mafia.

Seriously, though, I was with you, I think. I made my night move decision based on consideration of that, on a notion I had about another players' possible role (not MZ) and their tally at that point, and on what was said while I was offline. Let's just say that after considering all those factors, I took a chance that the speculation about the clue we got in the day three OP was incorrect and made my night move accordingly.

[charlou]

And I think it's worth knowing by just how much Fuzzy, Gib, and Gonzo's votes changed by last night. It will at least give us a clue on who acted on who. Ie - vig, doctor, scum. Does anyone else agree on that?

Obviously.

[charlou]

MZ, you said you were visited, presumably blocked on night two ... Did that affect your role ability?

[Magicziggy]

No it doesn't.

[Mantisdreamz]

If they thought I was a special, it would have made sense.

it was an interesting choice. Not that I'm complaining about drawing those points. All in all, I'm fine with it. It's freed me up to worry about other stuff than whether I'm at risk of being armed.

That's true. Because if you were a special, then I think when you are over the top - your ability is no longer in use...


Here's an idea. What if, the seer eventually outs themselves ( not yet ). Say they have viewed 3 people, and none of them are scum. With that - we could arm everyone, except for those 3 people. So, that means arming our town players, as well as scum. The only thing with this -- is if the don was viewed..... but maybe we could all put forth our reads on those 3 people, to get a clearer picture on whether or not that are the don.

[Mantisdreamz]

There is still stuff about night 1 that I simply am afraid to speculate out loud regarding.

those two hits, though, they've been huge in my theories about what is going on.

Likewise ... not the afraid to speculate part, but that they're significant and have factored into my thinking and gameplay since. I still don't know which of us were hit by whom.

Either way I look at it has pros and cons ... Did you find that too, ob?

pros and cons, yes. and other stuff. but, I did get the impression that we were sort of on the same wavelength regarding the vig yesterday.

Pretty sure we were, but it's impossible to know for sure without spelling it out and we can't do that either. Fucking mafia.

hmm yea...

[charlou]

Seriously, though, I was with you, I think. I made my night move decision based on consideration of that, on a notion I had about another players' possible role (not MZ) and their tally at that point, and on what was said while I was offline. Let's just say that after considering all those factors, I took a chance that the speculation about the clue we got in the day three OP was incorrect and made my night move accordingly.

Further to this: The words we were given in today's OP made me think I'd made the right night move decision ... but on reflection, that's not necessarily the case, it just seems to favour it.

[charlou]

MZ, you said you were visited, presumably blocked on night two ... Did that affect your role ability?

No it doesn't.

hmmm.

[oblivion]

There is still stuff about night 1 that I simply am afraid to speculate out loud regarding.

those two hits, though, they've been huge in my theories about what is going on.

Likewise ... not the afraid to speculate part, but that they're significant and have factored into my thinking and gameplay since. I still don't know which of us were hit by whom.

Either way I look at it has pros and cons ... Did you find that too, ob?

pros and cons, yes. and other stuff. but, I did get the impression that we were sort of on the same wavelength regarding the vig yesterday.

Pretty sure we were, but it's impossible to know for sure without spelling it out and we can't do that either. Fucking mafia.

yep. same page.
Seriously, though, I was with you, I think. I made my night move decision based on consideration of that, on a notion I had about another players' possible role (not MZ) and their tally at that point, and on what was said while I was offline. Let's just say that after considering all those factors, I took a chance that the speculation about the clue we got in the day three OP was incorrect and made my night move accordingly.

[oblivion]

augh...phoneposting. screwed that up. was replying "yep. asme page."

[charlou]

If they thought I was a special, it would have made sense.

it was an interesting choice. Not that I'm complaining about drawing those points. All in all, I'm fine with it. It's freed me up to worry about other stuff than whether I'm at risk of being armed.

That's true. Because if you were a special, then I think when you are over the top - your ability is no longer in use...


Here's an idea. What if, the seer eventually outs themselves ( not yet ). Say they have viewed 3 people, and none of them are scum. With that - we could arm everyone, except for those 3 people. So, that means arming our town players, as well as scum. The only thing with this -- is if the don was viewed..... but maybe we could all put forth our reads on those 3 people, to get a clearer picture on whether or not that are the don.

I think the possibility of a don puts the kebosh on that idea, don't you?