McDonald's Mafia Game Thread

[higgs2]

Hey guys. I just realized I am in this game. I forget about the auto signup. So this is my here I am post, but I have to be gone for a bit. I will get back to this in a couple of hours more or less.

[irretating]

He is normally frisky when he's scum he over compensates .

This is not correct. Are you chaneling Ani this game?

[Mantisdreamz]

should I list all the people I am always wary too? or should we maybe do some scumhunting?

Well Aza voted DP. And then you voted Aza because he voted for DP.

But then Ob, you say it's not a good idea to vote DP for mayor. Which means you are concerned of him, just as Aza is. So why vote Aza for the same reasons?


^hope this makes sense.

[Feck]

He is normally frisky when he's scum he over compensates .

This is not correct. Are you chaneling Ani this game?

Yeah I was for while but I stopped when the game got serious ,and no DP tends not to be around much when he is scum .

[oblivion]

should I list all the people I am always wary too? or should we maybe do some scumhunting?

Well Aza voted DP. And then you voted Aza because he voted for DP.

But then Ob, you say it's not a good idea to vote DP for mayor. Which means you are concerned of him, just as Aza is. So why vote Aza for the same reasons?


^hope this makes sense.

there is a difference between wanting to watch a player who claims viewing him is worthless before coming to a decision and wanting him to have tiebreaker ability.

[irretating]

should I list all the people I am always wary too? or should we maybe do some scumhunting?

Well Aza voted DP. And then you voted Aza because he voted for DP.

But then Ob, you say it's not a good idea to vote DP for mayor. Which means you are concerned of him, just as Aza is. So why vote Aza for the same reasons?


^hope this makes sense.

The difference, as I see it, is that DP is an easy place for scum to park a lynch vote. But, I think there's a gap between what oblivion expects the reaction to be when a person claims miller, and what our reactions actually will be. I can see the point of ignoring a claimed miller for a day or so, to try to scumhunt elsewhere (as when we lynch DP we catch either a miller or a scum anyway).

edit: crosspost

[oblivion]

there is also experience in games that had miller roles. they never survive long. town often gets useful info from the reactions.

btw have I mentioned that I kinda wonder if there is a scum team? 11 players and a bunch of indies doesn't leave a lot of room for scum.

heh. dp may be the only player who views as scum.

[Don't Panic]

At one point DP had played scum for 85% of his games ,dice do not have memories , odds of being scum are the same for everyone every game .

I am now at 54% town.

[Don't Panic]

should I list all the people I am always wary too? or should we maybe do some scumhunting?

Well Aza voted DP. And then you voted Aza because he voted for DP.

But then Ob, you say it's not a good idea to vote DP for mayor. Which means you are concerned of him, just as Aza is. So why vote Aza for the same reasons?


^hope this makes sense.

there is a difference between wanting to watch a player who claims viewing him is worthless before coming to a decision and wanting him to have tiebreaker ability.

Yeah, I'd prefer the mayor to be someone who is good at spotting scum. Hence my vote on Oblivion, Irre is a good choice too when she's town. Bloody nightmare when she's scum though.

[Don't Panic]

there is also experience in games that had miller roles. they never survive long. town often gets useful info from the reactions.

btw have I mentioned that I kinda wonder if there is a scum team? 11 players and a bunch of indies doesn't leave a lot of room for scum.

heh. dp may be the only player who views as scum.

That would be more like one of Azathoth's games.

[Don't Panic]

I think DP might be telling the truth but with the amount of wifom he would create later in the game if left in bothers me. Best we find out now if he is ballsy scum or not while we still have some wriggle room.

Vote DP

unvote; vote Aza

He came out of the gate making a lot of noise and only claimed miller when the FOSs started coming in. Do you trust him enough to give him a ticket to endgame on his word? I don't

your vote post was exactly what I would post if I were scum.

Yeah, I was looking for someone to do that too, didn't think it'd be Aza though.

Unvote, Vote Azathoth

[oblivion]

there is also experience in games that had miller roles. they never survive long. town often gets useful info from the reactions.

btw have I mentioned that I kinda wonder if there is a scum team? 11 players and a bunch of indies doesn't leave a lot of room for scum.

heh. dp may be the only player who views as scum.

That would be more like one of Azathoth's games.

we'll see I guess. I'm not seeing room for much indie presence otherwise.

[Don't Panic]

there is also experience in games that had miller roles. they never survive long. town often gets useful info from the reactions.

btw have I mentioned that I kinda wonder if there is a scum team? 11 players and a bunch of indies doesn't leave a lot of room for scum.

heh. dp may be the only player who views as scum.

That would be more like one of Azathoth's games.

we'll see I guess. I'm not seeing room for much indie presence otherwise.

I was thinking about the balance earlier, miller counts as a negative for town, possibly to balance a small scum team(2? 1 don, 1 vanilla) then maybe 1 Indie and 7 town.

Does that balance out?

[oblivion]

I was thinking about the balance earlier, miller counts as a negative for town, possibly to balance a small scum team(2? 1 don, 1 vanilla) then maybe 1 Indie and 7 town.

Does that balance out?

depending on the other town roles it would. but it wouldn't jibe with the pg description of the game setup.

[irretating]

btw have I mentioned that I kinda wonder if there is a scum team? 11 players and a bunch of indies doesn't leave a lot of room for scum.

heh.

That would be more like one of Azathoth's games.

...now you've given him an idea