Carnivale Game Thread

[higgs2]

Okay now I see we're on the same page. So if you have been protecting yourself, is that why otheres have dies? Or is it only when someone else tries to kill you? Why did you choose to have feck die day one?

[higgs2]

Ben harper: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ben_Harper

he's kind of cute.

[Magicziggy]

The effect is random.
You choose your kill at your peril.
I didn't say I'd only protected myself.
Only that I had on nights 1 and 2.

[Magicziggy]

He's also in my av I think which is kind of ironic.

[higgs2]

So every time you protect someone someone else dies? Or if you protect someone and they are targeted someone else dies? I'm trying to see how this adds up with what has happened in the game and I don't get it.

[Magicziggy]

Ok.
If a player I protect is hit, someone else dies. Could be you.

[Magicziggy]

What it means is that I have only successfully protected a maximum of one person.

[charlou]

It's not adding up for me either yet, higgs.

The effect is random.
You choose your kill at your peril.
I didn't say I'd only protected myself.
Only that I had on nights 1 and 2.

There have been four nights ... you've protect yourself on nights 1 and 2 ..

... and last night?

I fully expected to be hit last night. But I can protect myself as often as I like.
I also protected myself on night 2.
I have no interest in protecting anyone except specials.
Since I don't know who they are, I'll continue to protect myself.

Did you protect yourself last night or not?

Which nights didn't you protect yourself ... 3? ... 3 and 4? .. and who else did you protect? If all the colt kills are scum kills, why has your self protection only amounted to Feck's death?

[higgs2]

Oh because there was one day with two kills? So shit. I think we are still down to 2 scum, 4 town. Town consists of specials and vanilla. Scum is scum and or cult. THat doesn't account for the sk charlou has expressed concern about, if there is one and they count as town for parity then the scenario still makes sense. It's 9:32PM and I have to get my kids to bed. I may or may not be back tonight but I will have some time in the morning before nightfall. I'm not meaning to seem clueless, MZ but this is a tricky game. I would never have figured out your role.

[charlou]

If all the colt kills are scum kills, why has your self protection only amounted to Feck's death?

*scum kills or vig kills ... same question applies.

[higgs2]

Um, Mz. Were these powers explained to you in your role or did you figure them out by trial and error?

[Magicziggy]

Charlou, I'm exasperated in saying this over and over again.

I believe that colt kills = vig. Look at the victims. Irre!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Scum have only had one kill. Feck. Senseless. He was ideal recruit material. That makes me think it was a hit on me. I could be wrong.

I'm not telling you who I protected on nights 3 and 4. I protected those players who I thought may be hit. I was wrong obviously.

[Magicziggy]

Um, Mz. Were these powers explained to you in your role or did you figure them out by trial and error?

In my role.

[Magicziggy]

You have enough information.
My unsuccessful attempts at protection are really only useful for scum to second guess what I might do tonight.
Your excessive questioning is duly noted.

[charlou]

Charlou, I'm exasperated in saying this over and over again.

I believe that colt kills = vig. Look at the victims. Irre!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I did amend that to scum or vig kills.

I'm not telling you who I protected on nights 3 and 4. I protected those players who I thought may be hit. I was wrong obviously.

Did you protect irre and UT on nights 3 and 4? Both have turned out to be cultists.

You haven't explained why there haven't been other random kills from your 'protection'.

I'm finding your role claim very difficult to believe and this is starting to look like a flail.

There's a character named Stroud: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Characters ... iv%C3%A0le

An SK?

Your excessive questioning is duly noted.

I'm scum hunting.