Carnivale Game Thread

[Magicziggy]

Charlou, you are hunting an Sk, when you should be hunting scum.

[charlou]

IMO an SK is scum too.

An SK aside, I don't know who looks scummy. If I'm going to go with anyone being scum it would be squid or gib for being too quiet .. and I'd like to hear more from Callan .. and higgs has gone a bit quiet now too.

I think I'd rather give everyone more time to speak up during the day .. Theres almost 16 hours until nightfall, I think.

[Magicziggy]

With only six of us left spread all over the globe, we'll just have to take inputs when we can get them.
The thing about hunting an SK is that it's a very proactive thing for town and scum to do.
I don't think there is one. There were justified reasons why a vig would have taken out zig and mono.
I've repeatedly said that I would have chosen Mono on night 2. I can't remember all the way back to night 1. But zig had pinged as well.

In my opinion, town has a vig. Scum have not made a hit since night 1. That hit was on me.

[higgs2]

grrrr .. so frustrating! Okay .. I'll leave you be.


What do you think, higgs? I'm at a loss, really.

I don't know wtf you guys are talking about tbh. I'll read again. I did a quick scan and i was literally saying "what the fuck?" out loud.

[higgs2]

With only six of us left spread all over the globe, we'll just have to take inputs when we can get them.
The thing about hunting an SK is that it's a very proactive thing for town and scum to do.
I don't think there is one. There were justified reasons why a vig would have taken out zig and mono.
I've repeatedly said that I would have chosen Mono on night 2. I can't remember all the way back to night 1. But zig had pinged as well.

In my opinion, town has a vig. Scum have not made a hit since night 1. That hit was on me.

werenl't there 2 hits day one? or early in the game. That is what has been messing me up. And you're saying there was a third hit on you that didn't work?

[higgs2]

If there is an sk we need to get rid of them. They are no good for town for sure, usually help scum. Unless they count towards parity for town, that's the only time they could help town I think. Charlou do you think there is one? Would it be instead of a vig? That would be about par for the course, oblivion has given us quite a twisty game.

[charlou]

MZ, I remember you mentioning a hit that deflected off you and onto Feck. Why Feck?

[charlou]

What kind of mafia role is it that deflects a kill?

[higgs2]

When will we hear from gib, callan, squid? I don't know their time zones. gib and especially squid have been so quiet I cant help but wonder if they are recruits and are just trying to stay under the radar.

[higgs2]

A bus driver can switch players so the each gets the benefit of the others night action.Could MZ have done that for himself and fleck? That's all I can think of.

[charlou]

I know squid has rl stuff to keep him from the game .. as it should .. his gf is visiting from overseas. That doesn't say anything about his role though. gib's usually quiet around now as is Callan. I hope we might get more out of them later.


I've been reading through the mafia role list and the carnivale characters trying to work MZ out.

[charlou]

A bus driver can switch players so the each gets the benefit of the others night action.Could MZ have done that for himself and fleck? That's all I can think of.

Yeah, I considered that one too. MZ's comment about 'last time scum tried' (paraphrasing) has me thinking it's something else .. although that comment could have been a bluff.

Also, if MZ's a bus driver, why is he only referring to the Feck kill and no other switches during the game?

[higgs2]

Maybe we need the others to out their roles. I'm not sure about that one so I don't want to do it willy nilly but it's an idea to at least get some clue. Charlou and I are both out.

[higgs2]

Maybe we need the others to out their roles. I'm not sure about that one so I don't want to do it willy nilly but it's an idea to at least get some clue. Charlou and I are both out.

Or characters, that might be the more accurate way to say it. I'm still not saying specials should out.

[higgs2]

A bus driver can switch players so the each gets the benefit of the others night action.Could MZ have done that for himself and fleck? That's all I can think of.

Yeah, I considered that one too. MZ's comment about 'last time scum tried' (paraphrasing) has me thinking it's something else .. although that comment could have been a bluff.

Also, if MZ's a bus driver, why is he only referring to the Feck kill and no other switches during the game?

That's a good question, I'm sure he would have made more switches. I guess if neither one was targeted nothing would happen. I thought he was almost warning that he was some kind of bomb, but we'd know if someone set him off. Did you find any sort of deflecting role other than busdriver?