Carnivale Game Thread

[Magicziggy]

I'm going with:
night 0: failed recruit
night 1: failed kill
night 2: recruit
night 3: nothing

I realise now that this mean mantis didn't enable killing.
Back to her enabling blocking
Back to the idea they can no longer recruit.
But it does explain Feck's senseless kill.

I think 2 cult. My best guess is charlou + one other.

[Uselesstwit]

magic you are making no sense. So now night 1, the night we had two kills, scum failed to kill anyone? So once again, who killed feck? Also how on earth can you tell what happened on night 0?

You do have a point about there being to many votes on denny, but it's starting to feel like you want anyone else to be lynched. And why are you off higgs now? you voted for her earlier, said recently that either her or gib are scum for their votes on denny. but now it's char that's the cult member. Why not char and higgs?

[Magicziggy]

The last two votes on Denny came quickly that's all.

[Magicziggy]

I had a vote on higgs when I was thinking three teams. I now think 2, which means Higgs is in the clear.
I actually have Charlou and UT as the cult team atm.

[higgs2]

I would have voted for denny a while ago but I was waiting to hear from other players first. Have we heard from the squid at all?

How could the enabling blocking be what manits did since people continue to be visited? Or are you saying the visits are not effective?

[Magicziggy]

I'm saying town has a blocker. Mantis enabled the scum blocker.

[Magicziggy]

I don't know about Denny. I only know if he's town, we're in trouble if he's lynched.

[Uselesstwit]

I had a vote on higgs when I was thinking three teams. I now think 2, which means Higgs is in the clear.
I actually have Charlou and UT as the cult team atm.

that's no surprise, since I have you as illogical and panicky. We have two competing theories for the night kills.
1) night one we had a one shot vig kill and the rest of the kills have been scum kills.
2) we've have three nights of vig kills and no scum kills. Feck evidently died under mysterious circumstances MZ will explain later.

I think I'll just stick with the simple one we've seen dozens of times before, while wondering what MZ is up to.

[Magicziggy]

I had a vote on higgs when I was thinking three teams. I now think 2, which means Higgs is in the clear.
I actually have Charlou and UT as the cult team atm.

that's no surprise, since I have you as illogical and panicky. We have two competing theories for the night kills.
1) night one we had a one shot vig kill and the rest of the kills have been scum kills.
2) we've have three nights of vig kills and no scum kills. Feck evidently died under mysterious circumstances MZ will explain later.

I think I'll just stick with the simple one we've seen dozens of times before, while wondering what MZ is up to.

Let's stick with the illogical theme.
Night 1, our 1-shot vig takes out Feck???? WTF.

Night 1, scum take out Feck over recruiting him. WTF

So from my POV
Night 1, scum take out MZ. Effect is that Feck dies.
Makes perfect sense.

[Uselesstwit]

I would have voted for denny a while ago but I was waiting to hear from other players first. Have we heard from the squid at all?

How could the enabling blocking be what manits did since people continue to be visited? Or are you saying the visits are not effective?

no way, a two person blocking role? I don't see that at all why even have the second person. What about something like a seer role, marking people for possible recruitment. I could almost see that, mantis marks them then irre finishes the job the next night. it restricts the recruiting nicely, but it would almost certainly mean that the scum could still do night kills.

[Uselesstwit]

I had a vote on higgs when I was thinking three teams. I now think 2, which means Higgs is in the clear.
I actually have Charlou and UT as the cult team atm.

that's no surprise, since I have you as illogical and panicky. We have two competing theories for the night kills.
1) night one we had a one shot vig kill and the rest of the kills have been scum kills.
2) we've have three nights of vig kills and no scum kills. Feck evidently died under mysterious circumstances MZ will explain later.

I think I'll just stick with the simple one we've seen dozens of times before, while wondering what MZ is up to.

Let's stick with the illogical theme.
Night 1, our 1-shot vig takes out Feck???? WTF.

Night 1, scum take out Feck over recruiting him. WTF

So from my POV
Night 1, scum take out MZ. Effect is that Feck dies.

okay it's a possibility that the kill was flipped off of someone, but why you, and why no other night kills?
Makes perfect sense.

[DennyB]

If there are only 2 teams Then we will most likely start seeing NK's now that the recruiter is gone.

Oh, and guys, If you don't want to lose another town....Don't lynch me.

[Uselesstwit]

sorry messed up the quote tag there, I added.

okay it's a possibility that the kill was flipped off of someone, but why you, and why no other night kills?

to mz's post.

[Magicziggy]

UT, you have expended a lot of energy on special hunting.

[Magicziggy]

I've got to go.

vote UT