Simpsons Game Thread

[gib]

Gallstones has been about http://www.rationalia.com/forum/search. ... 3&sr=posts

Hey Gallstones, how come you didn't want to post in this thread?

[charlou]

Question for Callan, when she returns: Why do you think I have a jar of honey? I was given no explanation for it in my role PM and was actually thinking it might mean I'm a bomb ..

hmmm .. Then again, maybe it's both ..

But no, I'm inclined to believe irre's role.

[Feck]

anyone got a vote count ? I don't think Irre is running a scam . That last post of Normals made me think .

[oblivion]

Gallstones has been about http://www.rationalia.com/forum/search. ... 3&sr=posts

Hey Gallstones, how come you didn't want to post in this thread?

am I missing something? that search indicates she hasn't been online since day 2 started.

or are you calling attention to her continuing to post a little during the 3 hours after her last post in the day 1 thread? I'll have to take a look. I don't remember how active the game thread was during those 3 hours.

[Mantisdreamz]

I know as a new player here I have zero credibility, and I'm feeling pretty close to giving up, but I will ask ONCE AGAIN why no-one seems worried about the reasons why irre and MZ are singing in such pretty harmony, why Gib's performance yesterday is being shelved in favour of making people out their roles in order to be "trusted" by a "self-cleared innocent" and why Mantis backed irre so passionately on Day One.

But maybe they are really onto something? If Irre has been given hints to find other town members.... this is a good thing. Why not try to take it for what it is, instead of working against it?

Anyone reading carefully enough would note that it's unlikely to be a scam .. Is Callan being skeptical or muddying the water? She's also reluctant to find Gallstones's lack posting a concern even though she was reading the previous game where Gallstones behaved exactly like this .. and was scum.

Well, I find it a concern. But, what are you supposed to do? It's hard to vote for someone who hasn't really said much. It doesn't seem fair.

I can see why it would look suspicious to Callan that all of a sudden, there seems to be trust between some players (MZ/Irre). But, I think the trust is justifiable. Irre has also said something that relates to my character, so I know what she says can't be a lie.

[oblivion]

Gallstones has been about http://www.rationalia.com/forum/search. ... 3&sr=posts

Hey Gallstones, how come you didn't want to post in this thread?

am I missing something? that search indicates she hasn't been online since day 2 started.

or are you calling attention to her continuing to post a little during the 3 hours after her last post in the day 1 thread? I'll have to take a look. I don't remember how active the game thread was during those 3 hours.

there were not quite two pages worth of posts in that time. It was one of the slower periods of the game.

[charlou]

Irre has also said something that relates to my character, so I know what she says can't be a lie.

What do you have for irre?

[charlou]

Gallstones has been about http://www.rationalia.com/forum/search. ... 3&sr=posts

Hey Gallstones, how come you didn't want to post in this thread?

am I missing something? that search indicates she hasn't been online since day 2 started.

or are you calling attention to her continuing to post a little during the 3 hours after her last post in the day 1 thread? I'll have to take a look. I don't remember how active the game thread was during those 3 hours.

there were not quite two pages worth of posts in that time. It was one of the slower periods of the game.

She said she was going to be busy and looking in sporadically .. then when she did come back to rationalia she avoided the game thread altogether. Why are you defending her?

[Mantisdreamz]

Irre has also said something that relates to my character, so I know what she says can't be a lie.

What do you have for irre?

No. All I'm saying is that she was looking for specific hints that led to town members. I am with town, actually Apu - and sell a specific type of fish. She mentioned this before I said anything. That tells me that her role might be true in aiding to find other townies.

[Feck]

You are right if she is town she is not being any help ,the last game I viewed her and she turned out scum, is this the same play used as wifom ?

I might change my vote but I will leave it until later in case we hear from her .

[mononoke]

I agree with Callan about MZ and Irre. And I also have a feeling that we might strike gold if we:

Vote morticia

why mortica. There was one post of hers that pinged me. It involved a wobbly take on mantis, seemed like sort of indecisiveness scum tend to have, especially if a team mate is involved

[charlou]

Irre has also said something that relates to my character, so I know what she says can't be a lie.

What do you have for irre?

No. All I'm saying is that she was looking for specific hints that led to town members. I am with town, actually Apu - and sell a specific type of fish. She mentioned this before I said anything. That tells me that her role might be true in aiding to find other townies.

Okay, cheers.

[normal]

Ok, I'm feeling I've made bad choices, and done little thinking. I'll unvote for now

Unvote

[oblivion]

Gallstones has been about http://www.rationalia.com/forum/search. ... 3&sr=posts

Hey Gallstones, how come you didn't want to post in this thread?

am I missing something? that search indicates she hasn't been online since day 2 started.

or are you calling attention to her continuing to post a little during the 3 hours after her last post in the day 1 thread? I'll have to take a look. I don't remember how active the game thread was during those 3 hours.

there were not quite two pages worth of posts in that time. It was one of the slower periods of the game.

She said she was going to be busy and looking in sporadically .. then when she did come back to rationalia she avoided the game thread altogether. Why are you defending her?

I'm not defending her. I'm reporting what I found.

IMO she is not a bad choice for lynch today because it's going to be day 3 at the earliest before we get anything of substance from her, and by then we'll be even more enmired in discussions of people who have a track record.

I'd rather she weren't around at end game for that reason. If she is town, a mislynch today or tomorrow is less costly than later.

[Magicziggy]

Irre has also said something that relates to my character, so I know what she says can't be a lie.

What do you have for irre?

No. All I'm saying is that she was looking for specific hints that led to town members. I am with town, actually Apu - and sell a specific type of fish. She mentioned this before I said anything. That tells me that her role might be true in aiding to find other townies.

This is very important. Irre should check out this fish in the morning.
My vote on the non-participating gallstones stands.
It's bed time for me.