V mafia

[charlou]

My view, in light of Zigmen's experience and my own, is that he is not.

Now, back to Ani, who else thinks he's given up on this game because he's onto a better one, or because he knows he's toast?

[charlou]

My view, in light of Zigmen's experience and my own, is that he is not.

Predictable, I mean.

[mononoke]

I'm putting Ani as town at this point. the couple of times I've seen ani play scum he's been very very meek.

FECK has some explaining to do. I still haven't gotten anything about why he threw away that vote at that time. And his story about been viewed or blocked seems a little weak to me.

ObXMZ is amusing i think they are both trying to size each other up. But MZ's claim that he changes his game all the time looks like an excuse to cover up for what he thinks are deficiencies in his town game.

[mononoke]

What's up with Morti

[Feck]

I voted because I thought Normal was looking slightly scummier than Ani ,It would not be in scum's interests for me to make that vote (it certainly wasn't in mine )
now if you want to explain why a scum player would make that vote like I did then go ahead ! A last minute vote to (possibly) save a doomed team mate on Day one ?

Doesn't sound like my scum play does it ? So If Ani flips Scum today then He is dead and I'm dead too ,or you kill me and then Ani ?

I haven't had a brain fart like like Normal and no matter how much you think this is Wifom or flailing makes no difference. If I were scum I wouldn't have made that vote!

[Morticia]

Good Morning! I am here just catching up on the thread before I post. I am going to...

Vote Ani.

I should have done that yesterday but I didn't get back in time for nightfall. This game is running on different times than I am online. Ani used a very similar video game excuse in a previous game where he was scum. Also when is nightfall? It is noon my time and I will be out for the afternoon. I usually can check in on these games around now and around 8pm my time.

[oblivion]

Good Morning! I am here just catching up on the thread before I post. I am going to...

Vote Ani.

I should have done that yesterday but I didn't get back in time for nightfall. This game is running on different times than I am online. Ani used a very similar video game excuse in a previous game where he was scum. Also when is nightfall? It is noon my time and I will be out for the afternoon. I usually can check in on these games around now and around 8pm my time.

your post was made 5 hours 39 minutes before nightfall, I think.

[oblivion]

I'm thinking about it this way - if I were a town role blocker, who would I have blocked last night? My three picks for scum at the end of the game day were Feck, Ani and MZ. Of those three, I would have blocked either Feck or MZ because I would anticipate the scum team not having Ani do the kill given he was under so much suspicion yesterday.

More than anything, the plausibility of a town blocker targeting Feck makes me believe the block claim. If it's a scum blocker, then I dunno.

[Feck]

Ghat says I can't post the PM ..(wait 'till he next plays !)

[Azathoth]

Ghat says I can't post the PM ..(wait 'till he next plays !)

Threatening the GM?

nono.gif (477.77 KiB) Viewed 258 times

[Don't Panic]

What I don't get about the lynch yesterday is why didn't oblivions mayor vote count? It should have been 4.5 to 4.

Onto today, Ani is still looking scummy to me, so is Feck, either MZ, oblivion or both, possibly SR, not sure about anyone else yet.

Still too many quiet players, but some of those are probably timezone related.

For today: Vote Ani, still the most likely suspect in my book.

[Morticia]

Ok then I have about 5 hours until nightfall which would be about 6pm my time. I will try to get back to the board before then. Anyway I believe this was also pointed out by Oblivion, but MZ's tactics are not pro-town. FOS MZ. I have never figured MZ's game out and almost always see scummy behavior.

[Don't Panic]

Ok then I have about 5 hours until nightfall which would be about 6pm my time. I will try to get back to the board before then. Anyway I believe this was also pointed out by Oblivion, but MZ's tactics are not pro-town. FOS MZ. I have never figured MZ's game out and almost always see scummy behavior.

It is 5 hours 48 minutes to nightfall for anyone who needs to synchronise to the game clock.

[Zigmen]

I have to go to work in about an hour. I should have a very short break at 6pm (one hour before nightfall) cuz my 6pm student is always late on Tuesdays.

In the meantime, I've been considering Oblivion and Charlou's defense of Feck. For them to be right, Ghat would have had to altered his GMing style. As a GM, I know I have certain things I always do the same way, but i do change up small things to keep from being predictable.

I'm not sure that a GM would suddenly start informing blocked/viewed players when these actions have zero consequence.

It's a bit of a stretch for me to but into that defense.

Feck was under the pressure of 2 early votes, and then all of a sudden he recieved a nonconsequential PM? I just don't buy it.

If I do not make it back before nightfall, I just want to point out that SR, Ani, and MZ round out my top picks for Scum. Charlou and Oblivion are gonna look pretty sketchy as well, assuming Feck gets lynched and pops Scum.

I'll check in after I shower and before i leave.

[Zigmen]

ETA "To buy into that defense."