V mafia

[Zigmen]

^^ I mean those two were the most involved yesterday and there is some reason to believe either or atleast one of them can be scum. If i were seer I would view one of them, and not FECK. There is very little ambiguity in FECKs play.

It's also odd that Feck saw that as a "View" PM and not a "Block" PM. Evidently, he would not have recieved such a PM anyway.

[charlou]

mono, Feck said he was hooded and questioned ... does not sound like a "view" .. it's a block, I'm sure.

[Feck]

I think there are a few people that are going to owe me an apology ...

[charlou]

Evidently, he would not have recieved such a PM anyway.

I don't see why not .. I don't think your past experience is enough evidence to discount Feck's claim in this current game.

[Feck]

Just have to check with Ghat ...I know role PM's cannot be copied and posted But .......

[Zigmen]

I think there are a few people that are going to owe me an apology ...

Face it, Feck. You were under the gun and you contrived a pretty bad cover-up. Ghat doesn't send Block PMs to players who were not actually blocked. There's not going to be a need for any apologies.

[charlou]

Zigmen, you're basing your argument on previous games .. this is not a good idea.

mono, Feck said he was hooded and questioned ... does not sound like a "view" .. it's a block, I'm sure.

Actually, the questioned aspect is pretty ambiguous ... could make it seem like a "view" ..

Either way, Feck's confidence that he "views" as town leads me to think he probably is.

[Zigmen]

Evidently, he would not have recieved such a PM anyway.

I don't see why not .. I don't think your past experience is enough evidence to discount Feck's claim in this current game.

How's it any different?

In Flavorless Mafia, we wanted to see the Block PM so I blocked TheManeki. As Scum, I had used this ploy to my advantage in the past.

He never got such a PM. That game was run by Ghat.

If anyone has ever gotten a block PM without them actually being blocked, they should speak up.

My only experience in this situation says that no PM would be sent.

[Feck]

Just back pedal harder Zig ....

[Zigmen]

Zigmen, you're basing your argument on previous games .. this is not a good idea.

mono, Feck said he was hooded and questioned ... does not sound like a "view" .. it's a block, I'm sure.

Actually, the questioned aspect is pretty ambiguous ... could make it seem like a "view" ..

Either way, Feck's confidence that he "views" as town leads me to think he probably is.

For that matter, if anyone has ever recived a PM from Ghat informing them that they had been viewed, they should speak up as well.

[mononoke]

mono, Feck said he was hooded and questioned ... does not sound like a "view" .. it's a block, I'm sure.

questioning part looked like a view the hooded part looked like a block.

I'm trying to figure out the ObXMZ engagement.

[charlou]

Evidently, he would not have recieved such a PM anyway.

I don't see why not .. I don't think your past experience is enough evidence to discount Feck's claim in this current game.

How's it any different?

In Flavorless Mafia, we wanted to see the Block PM so I blocked TheManeki. As Scum, I had used this ploy to my advantage in the past.

He never got such a PM. That game was run by Ghat.

And you assume Ghat runs all his games the same?

[Feck]

I wish Ghat was here so I could just press control V ....

[charlou]

I'm trying to figure out the ObXMZ engagement.

Yes, me too .. though that went on the backburner with the Ani "I give up" thing and the "let's not use our noggins and believe Feck because it suits us not to" thing.

[oblivion]

This is only the second Ghat game I've played, and one of them was Paranoia, not mafia. I have no idea if he's predictable regarding the details of how he runs his games. I have seen other GMs who in some games sent pms about people being blocked and in other games did not.