Archive: Zombie Day 1, 2, 3, 4, 5

[Azathoth]

Reading over day one the thing that jumps out most at me is the flailing from sciencerob. Complete meltdown every time anyone looked at him. It reads to me as newbie scum panic.

vote sciencerob

[DennyB]

MZ, Just seems like more fluff than your non scum game I have seen you play.

Thats kinda like a revenge vote.. ponderious

[charlou]

Reading over day one the thing that jumps out most at me is the flailing from sciencerob. Complete meltdown every time anyone looked at him. It reads to me as newbie scum panic.

vote sciencerob

Also, 8 hours on the piano with his ladeh? Is that a euphemism, SR?

[Magicziggy]

MZ, Just seems like more fluff than your non scum game I have seen you play.

Thats kinda like a revenge vote.. ponderious

If I had two votes you'd get them both.

[DennyB]

Reading over day one the thing that jumps out most at me is the flailing from sciencerob. Complete meltdown every time anyone looked at him. It reads to me as newbie scum panic.

vote sciencerob

Also, 8 hours on the piano with his ladeh? Is that a euphemism, SR?

Now that is

[Magicziggy]

For the benefit of all, I am in a particularly fluffy mood.
But my vote on DennyB is serious. What is scummy about my play?
And if you believe it, vote for me. I want to see you put your money where your mouth is.

[oblivion]

interesting night.

Charlou do you still want an answer to your question from the other thread?

Not sure if it will be the same answer I would have got before the night results but fire away ...

My response is informed by your known alignment, but I think I can still put across the gist. It seemed odd to me that after repeated vocal suspicions that I was scum and acting in concert with UT(?) that when I expressed some suspicion, your tack was to undermine that FoS by attacking my reads as a town player rather than continuing your case against me as scum.

I was going to press that a little today, but since we know your alignment it obviously wasn't a scum slip-up.

[Feck]

plenty of time left but Denny is looking scummy ,Magic is being forceful (woooooo)

[Magicziggy]

plenty of time left but Denny is looking scummy ,Magic is being forceful (woooooo)

Yes but in a fluffy way.

Now I MUST go to bed. I have given you some posts to mull over. I have voted.

My posting tomorrow may be fragmented, but I will do my best. Goodnight.

[charlou]

For the benefit of all, I am in a particularly fluffy mood.
But my vote on DennyB is serious. What is scummy about my play?
And if you believe it, vote for me. I want to see you put your money where your mouth is.

I wasn't serious with the fluff and scumtell comments, MZ .. I know you were just easing into the game as a sub

[DennyB]

MZ I havent figured out who I will vote for yet.
Although I FoS you along with several others and you get very defensive. That seems very scummy to me.

Reread my post. I am town

[mononoke]

Mono, Why not vote yesterday?

I don't believe in the first day witch hunt. Those have almost always failed in the past, and this game was no exception.

[Zigmen]

Zigman,

If a Seer has a view and comes back as a zombie can they post results?
Just putting this out there I am not Seer.
I would like the rule out in the open so the Seer knows.

Thanks

As in previos games that allow Zombie posts, a Zombie may post anything they like within the rules of the game. These rules prohibit things like screenshots from outside the game thread and verbatim Role PMs.

Beyond that, Zombies are still active players and may post information gained while they were alive.

[mononoke]

What about this post by Totals
http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 00#p623186

It looks like a massive scum fail, as well as fail in general, to me

[oblivion]

Mono, Why not vote yesterday?

I don't believe in the first day witch hunt. Those have almost always failed in the past, and this game was no exception.

whether town or scum are lynched on day 1, day 1 lynches are not failures. People's reactions, the timing of those reactions and the votes they cast are all valuable information for later days.

Town players are going to get lynched. It's a very rare game where every lynch is of a scum player. It's what mafia is about.

I understand the hesitance to lynch a potential town player, but it's misplaced IMO.

Read this post by J.A. Poisson for more on playing town roles (and by inference, how to play scum roles): http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 50#p469516

That's my soapbox post for the day.