Do numbers exist in nature or are they human contructs?

Post Reply
User avatar
JimC
The sentimental bloke
Posts: 74202
Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2009 7:58 am
About me: To be serious about gin requires years of dedicated research.
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Contact:

Re: Do numbers exist in nature or are they human contructs?

Post by JimC » Sun Dec 15, 2013 7:59 pm

Azathoth wrote:Is a worker ant discrete? It is useless unless it is part of a colony

Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk
In the physical sense, it has a clear external boundary. A collection of worker ants can be counted; they do not blur into each other like drops of paint on a surface.

In a functional sense, it partakes of some of the properties possessed by cells in a multicellular organism...
FBM wrote:

...Even aside from divisibility into components which eventually become wave functions and fields, in what way is an apparently singular fish discrete, other than just as a convenient fiction? It seems to me that it could be just as accurately described as a local, ongoing set of phenomena within a larger continuum. There's a constant flow of stuff going in and out, and the external boundaries are far less clear-cut than a casual look would suggest, I think....
Firstly, when considering a fish at the macroscopic level, one does not have to envisage the quantum fields of its sub-atomic components; one acknowledges they exist, but a good reductionist uses the appropriate level of physical reality to deal with the matter at hand, which for us, is fish qua fish...

Individual organisms may not have the "perfect discreteness" that one would expect of a platonic object. They are indeed dynamic, and over time, most their atoms will undergo replacement as they feed and excrete, and their size and other aspects of their nature will change. For some purposes, it may be useful to consider them as a "local, ongoing set of phenomena within a larger continuum". Again, none of this changes the fact that it is absurdly easy to count them, name them, scoop them up individually etc. Their discreteness is not down to human consciousness "chopping up" reality into bits, it exists inherently in the nature of at least some objects in the universe we inhabit.

Of course, there are situations where humans do grab discreteness where none really exists; the classic example would be the names we give to the colours of the rainbow; quantum effects aside, the spectrum of light is a true continuum, and our "chunking" of it is a process of our consciousness. The fact that the human mind does this (for quite practical reasons) in some circumstances is not evidence that the whole of reality is non-discrete.

The whole point of my excursion into the way that our physical reality contains objects that are discrete is to back up my assertion that numbers (at least counting numbers) exist in nature. In any defined region of space time, a set of countable objects exists, and the number of those objects is not imposed by an intelligent observer, but an inherent property of that set. Not only that, but the property of "seven" is transferrable - it is a property of any other set containing the same number of discrete objects, even in a universe where intelligent observers had never evolved.
Nurse, where the fuck's my cardigan?
And my gin!

User avatar
FBM
Ratz' first Gritizen.
Posts: 45327
Joined: Fri Mar 27, 2009 12:43 pm
About me: Skeptic. "Because it does not contend
It is therefore beyond reproach"
Contact:

Re: Do numbers exist in nature or are they human contructs?

Post by FBM » Mon Dec 16, 2013 3:06 am

I had a response going about the pragmatic fallacy and whatnot, Jim, but I deleted it. Aside from being wary of annoying people, I think we could go back and forth about this indefinitely without making any progress. One reason I say this is because one of the links I posted above goes to a discussion among some pretty top-level scientists who disagree with each other over this question. Both camps have some pretty compelling arguments, so I'm still :dunno:
"A philosopher is a blind man in a dark room looking for a black cat that isn't there. A theologian is the man who finds it." ~ H. L. Mencken

"We ain't a sharp species. We kill each other over arguments about what happens when you die, then fail to see the fucking irony in that."

"It is useless for the sheep to pass resolutions in favor of vegetarianism while the wolf remains of a different opinion."

User avatar
pErvinalia
On the good stuff
Posts: 60810
Joined: Tue Feb 23, 2010 11:08 pm
About me: Spelling 'were' 'where'
Location: dystopia
Contact:

Re: Do numbers exist in nature or are they human contructs?

Post by pErvinalia » Mon Dec 16, 2013 4:00 am

You mean "high powered" scientists?? :hehe: And yes, Jim is pretty annoying. I'm wary of him too. :tea:
Sent from my penis using wankertalk.
"The Western world is fucking awesome because of mostly white men" - DaveDodo007.
"Socialized medicine is just exactly as morally defensible as gassing and cooking Jews" - Seth. Yes, he really did say that..
"Seth you are a boon to this community" - Cunt.
"I am seriously thinking of going on a spree killing" - Svartalf.

User avatar
FBM
Ratz' first Gritizen.
Posts: 45327
Joined: Fri Mar 27, 2009 12:43 pm
About me: Skeptic. "Because it does not contend
It is therefore beyond reproach"
Contact:

Re: Do numbers exist in nature or are they human contructs?

Post by FBM » Mon Dec 16, 2013 4:04 am

High-powered, top-level... :ask:

And Jim isn't annoying; I am. :hehe:
"A philosopher is a blind man in a dark room looking for a black cat that isn't there. A theologian is the man who finds it." ~ H. L. Mencken

"We ain't a sharp species. We kill each other over arguments about what happens when you die, then fail to see the fucking irony in that."

"It is useless for the sheep to pass resolutions in favor of vegetarianism while the wolf remains of a different opinion."

User avatar
JimC
The sentimental bloke
Posts: 74202
Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2009 7:58 am
About me: To be serious about gin requires years of dedicated research.
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Contact:

Re: Do numbers exist in nature or are they human contructs?

Post by JimC » Mon Dec 16, 2013 4:32 am

rEvolutionist wrote:You mean "high powered" scientists?? :hehe: And yes, Jim is pretty annoying. I'm wary of him too. :tea:
I am a gin-powered scientist! :{D
Nurse, where the fuck's my cardigan?
And my gin!

User avatar
FBM
Ratz' first Gritizen.
Posts: 45327
Joined: Fri Mar 27, 2009 12:43 pm
About me: Skeptic. "Because it does not contend
It is therefore beyond reproach"
Contact:

Re: Do numbers exist in nature or are they human contructs?

Post by FBM » Mon Dec 16, 2013 7:44 am

A timely find:

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kkGeOWYOFoA#t=103[/youtube]
"A philosopher is a blind man in a dark room looking for a black cat that isn't there. A theologian is the man who finds it." ~ H. L. Mencken

"We ain't a sharp species. We kill each other over arguments about what happens when you die, then fail to see the fucking irony in that."

"It is useless for the sheep to pass resolutions in favor of vegetarianism while the wolf remains of a different opinion."

User avatar
JimC
The sentimental bloke
Posts: 74202
Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2009 7:58 am
About me: To be serious about gin requires years of dedicated research.
Location: Melbourne, Australia
Contact:

Re: Do numbers exist in nature or are they human contructs?

Post by JimC » Mon Dec 16, 2013 8:14 am

Fascinating video, FBM! :tup:
Nurse, where the fuck's my cardigan?
And my gin!

User avatar
FBM
Ratz' first Gritizen.
Posts: 45327
Joined: Fri Mar 27, 2009 12:43 pm
About me: Skeptic. "Because it does not contend
It is therefore beyond reproach"
Contact:

Re: Do numbers exist in nature or are they human contructs?

Post by FBM » Mon Dec 16, 2013 9:14 am

I thought it was ossum! :D
"A philosopher is a blind man in a dark room looking for a black cat that isn't there. A theologian is the man who finds it." ~ H. L. Mencken

"We ain't a sharp species. We kill each other over arguments about what happens when you die, then fail to see the fucking irony in that."

"It is useless for the sheep to pass resolutions in favor of vegetarianism while the wolf remains of a different opinion."

User avatar
mistermack
Posts: 15093
Joined: Sat Apr 10, 2010 10:57 am
About me: Never rong.
Contact:

Re: Do numbers exist in nature or are they human contructs?

Post by mistermack » Mon Dec 16, 2013 11:40 am

Nice bit of music there. Bookmarked. But too short.
It would be nice to watch and listen to a whole album, while mildly stoned.
Shame that there's no off switch on hash, or I'd be tempted to indulge. Maybe a good thing though.

What about dimensions? There are three that I know of. They were there long before humans.
Again, the number is a property of spacetime.
While there is a market for shit, there will be assholes to supply it.

Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests