Catcher in the Rye and TKMockingbird out of American Schools
- Twoflower
- Queen of Slugs
- Posts: 16611
- Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2009 1:23 pm
- About me: Twoflower is the optimistic-but-naive tourist. He often runs into danger, being certain that nothing bad will happen to him since he is not involved. He also believes in the fundamental goodness of human nature and that all problems can be resolved, if all parties show good will and cooperate.
- Location: Boston
- Contact:
Re: Catcher in the Rye and TKMockingbird out of American Sch
I love Roll of Thunder.
Re: Catcher in the Rye and TKMockingbird out of American Sch
Holy crap, there's a whole series? How did I not know about this?Twoflower wrote:I love Roll of Thunder.
Nobody expects me...
- Twoflower
- Queen of Slugs
- Posts: 16611
- Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2009 1:23 pm
- About me: Twoflower is the optimistic-but-naive tourist. He often runs into danger, being certain that nothing bad will happen to him since he is not involved. He also believes in the fundamental goodness of human nature and that all problems can be resolved, if all parties show good will and cooperate.
- Location: Boston
- Contact:
Re: Catcher in the Rye and TKMockingbird out of American Sch

-
- Posts: 32040
- Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 2:03 pm
- Contact:
Re: Catcher in the Rye and TKMockingbird out of American Sch
Possible? Sure. Probable? I doubt it. I don't see why she wouldn't write more. Writing is a "craft" and as such it is generally something that isn't a one-off, but is more of a "whole bunch-off."hadespussercats wrote:What, you don't think it's possible to recognize you have one good story in you, and leave it at that? one and done?Coito ergo sum wrote:Oh, sorry. I thought everyone read TKaM. If you haven't, read it today. You won't be sorry.Animavore wrote:I just realised Coito thought I meant Catcher in the Rye when I said 'never read it' (a direct response to the last line of his OP) the first time
I've had a sneaking suspicion that Harper Lee never wrote that book, though. I thought that after I first read it, mainly because I learned she never published any other novels or anything of consequence since then. it just doesn't stand to reason that she would write NOTHING else. Someone who could write a novel like that, I mean....she doesn't even want to write something else for fun? Not a single other story came to mind in the last 50 odd years? I suspected the reason she didn't is that whatever she would try to write would expose her for not having written TKaM.
There are others who have theorized that Truman Capote actually wrote it. I think he denied it strenuously.
It's just a sneaking suspicion. Based on nothing. Just strikes me as odd, the "one off" thing.hadespussercats wrote: There are plenty of writers I wish had that sort of self-awareness.
Other possibility-- having a crazy huge hit first time out can be the kiss of death to anything published subsequently.
I understand she worked as an editor.
As for TC writing it-- it is not neaaaaarly bleak enough to be his work. Even his light work was dark, if you looked close.
Re: Catcher in the Rye and TKMockingbird out of American Sch
You've just put me right off TKMB. You make it sound like it was written by a clueless, but well-meaning whitey portraying black-folk as the poor, simple and innocent noble savage. You sound sincere and I've no doubt you're probably rightDrewish wrote:Rolling Thunder Hear My CryPappa wrote:What's your take on it hades?hadespussercats wrote:Pappa wrote:To Kill a Mockingbird is an exceptional book. Everyone should read it to their dog.
I found the device of telling the story not only from the girl's perspective, but mindset too, to be really interesting. It's not something I've seen done well before or since. Plus, I liked how completely I picture the scenes in the book... so well I can still see them now, probably 8 years or more since the last time I read it.
Plus that book had the advantage of being written from a black character's perspective and having relatable black characters, not just treating them like infantile 'others' as TKMB did.

Libertarianism: The belief that out of all the terrible things governments can do, helping people is the absolute worst.
- Gawdzilla Sama
- Stabsobermaschinist
- Posts: 151265
- Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2009 12:24 am
- About me: My posts are related to the thread in the same way Gliese 651b is related to your mother's underwear drawer.
- Location: Sitting next to Ayaan in Domus Draconis, and communicating via PMs.
- Contact:
Re: Catcher in the Rye and TKMockingbird out of American Sch
Anyone read The Invisible Man (not the scifi)?
-
- Posts: 32040
- Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 2:03 pm
- Contact:
Re: Catcher in the Rye and TKMockingbird out of American Sch
Who said anything about "possible?" Of course it's possible. I just had a sneaking suspicion. And, I'm not the one who came up with the idea that Capote really wrote it. That was bandied about quite seriously for many years.Xamonas Chegwé wrote:While we are at it, who wrote Gone with the Wind for Margaret Mitchell? Seeing as no author capable of writing a Pulitzer prize winning novel can posibly only have one book in them!
Wilde was a prolific writer. He just didn't write other novels. He also wrote Picture of Dorian Grey in 1890, and died only 10 years later. He did, however, publish other works, like the Importance of Being Earnest, after Dorian Grey. It's not like he stopped writing. He was mostly a playwright, not a novelist.Xamonas Chegwé wrote:
And while we are at it, when is Oscar's sequel to Dorian Grey coming out?
Pasternak has a ton of poetry and a bunch of prose publications. He didn't just publish Dr. Zhivago and then call it a lifetime. In fact, he published Dr. Zhivago in the late 1950s, and he died like 2 years later.Xamonas Chegwé wrote: Or the follow-up to Pasternak's Dr. Zhivago?
She wrote piles of poetry, and then wrote Wuthering Heights when she was like 29. She died within a year after finishing Wuthering Heights. And, Anna did write what was originally intended by Emily to be the the third volume --- 'cuz Emily was dead.Xamonas Chegwé wrote: And which of the other Brontë sisters wrote Wuthering Heights for Emily?
It was his only published novel, but it was not the only novel he worked on (he had a second novel which he himself said was in the works at the time Invisible Man was published, and had a lot of published "works," just not novels. He was famous for essays.Xamonas Chegwé wrote:
Invisible Man, mentioned above, was Ralph Ellison's only published work,
Died of hepatitis a few months after it was published. Next!Xamonas Chegwé wrote: Black Beauty was Anna Sewell's,
Published posthumously. I think he offed himself.Xamonas Chegwé wrote: A Confederacy of Dunces (another Pulitzer winner) was Toole's

Published months before her suicide.Xamonas Chegwé wrote:
and Sylvia Plath's only excursion into lengthy prose was the Bell Jar.

I never made the allegation it was Capote. Other people did. And, surely you see the difference between an author writing a book that was published either months before his or her death, or published posthumously. If it doesn't occur to you, let me spell it out: They can't go on to publish more works, because the died.Xamonas Chegwé wrote: Who did the ghost writing for these? Was Capote really that prolific?
Christ on a bicycle. I merely pointed out that when I first read the damn book the suspicion occurred to me. It occurred to me independent of the myth. I read about the myth later and said to myself, "holy crap, that is what I thought...." (not that Capote did, specifically, but that Lee did not).Xamonas Chegwé wrote:
I am afraid that you are guilty of repeating a long-disproven urban myth, CES. Harper Lee wrote TKAM. Capote's only involvement was in urging her to pulish it despite her protestations that it wasn't anywhere near good enough!
Re: Catcher in the Rye and TKMockingbird out of American Sch
Oh it's not quite that bad. If you've seen the movie "The Help" then imagine something like that, except that instead of being narrated by a Viola Davis' character, it was instead narrated by Jessica Chastain's character.Animavore wrote:You've just put me right off TKMB. You make it sound like it was written by a clueless, but well-meaning whitey portraying black-folk as the poor, simple and innocent noble savage. You sound sincere and I've no doubt you're probably rightDrewish wrote:Rolling Thunder Hear My CryPappa wrote:What's your take on it hades?hadespussercats wrote:Pappa wrote:To Kill a Mockingbird is an exceptional book. Everyone should read it to their dog.
I found the device of telling the story not only from the girl's perspective, but mindset too, to be really interesting. It's not something I've seen done well before or since. Plus, I liked how completely I picture the scenes in the book... so well I can still see them now, probably 8 years or more since the last time I read it.
Plus that book had the advantage of being written from a black character's perspective and having relatable black characters, not just treating them like infantile 'others' as TKMB did.
Nobody expects me...
- Xamonas Chegwé
- Bouncer
- Posts: 50939
- Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2009 3:23 pm
- About me: I have prehensile eyebrows.
I speak 9 languages fluently, one of which other people can also speak.
When backed into a corner, I fit perfectly - having a right-angled arse. - Location: Nottingham UK
- Contact:
Re: Catcher in the Rye and TKMockingbird out of American Sch
Oh, and Harper Lee worked for years on a second novel whch was eventually abandoned due to her personal dissatisfaction with it.
Self-confidence really isn't her strong point - which is a great shame because she is a completely natural and enormously talented writer!
Self-confidence really isn't her strong point - which is a great shame because she is a completely natural and enormously talented writer!
A book is a version of the world. If you do not like it, ignore it; or offer your own version in return.
Salman Rushdie
You talk to God, you're religious. God talks to you, you're psychotic.
House MD
Who needs a meaning anyway, I'd settle anyday for a very fine view.
Sandy Denny
This is the wrong forum for bluffing
Paco
Yes, yes. But first I need to show you this venomous fish!
Calilasseia
I think we should do whatever Pawiz wants.
Twoflower
Bella squats momentarily then waddles on still peeing, like a horse
Millefleur
Salman Rushdie
You talk to God, you're religious. God talks to you, you're psychotic.
House MD
Who needs a meaning anyway, I'd settle anyday for a very fine view.
Sandy Denny
This is the wrong forum for bluffing

Paco
Yes, yes. But first I need to show you this venomous fish!
Calilasseia
I think we should do whatever Pawiz wants.
Twoflower
Bella squats momentarily then waddles on still peeing, like a horse
Millefleur
- hadespussercats
- I've come for your pants.
- Posts: 18586
- Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2010 12:27 am
- About me: Looks pretty good, coming out of the back of his neck like that.
- Location: Gotham
- Contact:
Re: Catcher in the Rye and TKMockingbird out of American Sch
Thank you, Xamonas-- I was going to come back with some of this, but you beat me to the punch. It's good, though-- a point worth punching.Xamonas Chegwé wrote:While we are at it, who wrote Gone with the Wind for Margaret Mitchell? Seeing as no author capable of writing a Pulitzer prize winning novel can posibly only have one book in them!
And while we are at it, when is Oscar's sequel to Dorian Grey coming out? Or the follow-up to Pasternak's Dr. Zhivago? And which of the other Brontë sisters wrote Wuthering Heights for Emily?
Invisible Man, mentioned above, was Ralph Ellison's only published work, Black Beauty was Anna Sewell's, A Confederacy of Dunces (another Pulitzer winner) was Toole's and Sylvia Plath's only excursion into lengthy prose was the Bell Jar. Who did the ghost writing for these? Was Capote really that prolific?
I am afraid that you are guilty of repeating a long-disproven urban myth, CES. Harper Lee wrote TKAM. Capote's only involvement was in urging her to pulish it despite her protestations that it wasn't anywhere near good enough!
Another is this-- Truman Capote was one of the most devoted self-promoting authors of his time. Chances of him not putting his name on a work of his were just about zero-- particularly if that work went on to become a giant, best-selling, prize-winning hit.
A couple other points-- Harper Lee did indeed publish other works-- just not another novel. She wrote articles and anthologized short stories. And she started two other books-- a novel, when she was younger, that she decided not to finish, and a non-fiction book, in the 80s, that she set aside because she was unsatisfied with it.
I found this quote of hers telling:
Although, I have to say, given the choice between being prolific, or having one wildly successful and well-loved work, boy, I'd go with the latter. Unfortunately, no one's giving me the choice!I never expected any sort of success with Mockingbird. I was hoping for a quick and merciful death at the hands of the reviewers but, at the same time, I sort of hoped someone would like it enough to give me encouragement. Public encouragement. I hoped for a little, as I said, but I got rather a whole lot, and in some ways this was just about as frightening as the quick, merciful death I'd expected. ”
—Harper Lee, quoted in Newquist, 1964

The green careening planet
spins blindly in the dark
so close to annihilation.
Listen. No one listens. Meow.
spins blindly in the dark
so close to annihilation.
Listen. No one listens. Meow.
- hadespussercats
- I've come for your pants.
- Posts: 18586
- Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2010 12:27 am
- About me: Looks pretty good, coming out of the back of his neck like that.
- Location: Gotham
- Contact:
Re: Catcher in the Rye and TKMockingbird out of American Sch
The othering was a critical aspect of the culture the book described.Drewish wrote:Rolling Thunder Hear My CryPappa wrote:What's your take on it hades?hadespussercats wrote:Pappa wrote:To Kill a Mockingbird is an exceptional book. Everyone should read it to their dog.
I found the device of telling the story not only from the girl's perspective, but mindset too, to be really interesting. It's not something I've seen done well before or since. Plus, I liked how completely I picture the scenes in the book... so well I can still see them now, probably 8 years or more since the last time I read it.
Plus that book had the advantage of being written from a black character's perspective and having relatable black characters, not just treating them like infantile 'others' as TKMB did.
It's good to pursue different perspectives on an issue, though.
The green careening planet
spins blindly in the dark
so close to annihilation.
Listen. No one listens. Meow.
spins blindly in the dark
so close to annihilation.
Listen. No one listens. Meow.
- hadespussercats
- I've come for your pants.
- Posts: 18586
- Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2010 12:27 am
- About me: Looks pretty good, coming out of the back of his neck like that.
- Location: Gotham
- Contact:
Re: Catcher in the Rye and TKMockingbird out of American Sch
One published work is not the same as one written work, Coito. See my previous entry on same. And XC's.Coito ergo sum wrote:Possible? Sure. Probable? I doubt it. I don't see why she wouldn't write more. Writing is a "craft" and as such it is generally something that isn't a one-off, but is more of a "whole bunch-off."hadespussercats wrote:What, you don't think it's possible to recognize you have one good story in you, and leave it at that? one and done?Coito ergo sum wrote:Oh, sorry. I thought everyone read TKaM. If you haven't, read it today. You won't be sorry.Animavore wrote:I just realised Coito thought I meant Catcher in the Rye when I said 'never read it' (a direct response to the last line of his OP) the first time
I've had a sneaking suspicion that Harper Lee never wrote that book, though. I thought that after I first read it, mainly because I learned she never published any other novels or anything of consequence since then. it just doesn't stand to reason that she would write NOTHING else. Someone who could write a novel like that, I mean....she doesn't even want to write something else for fun? Not a single other story came to mind in the last 50 odd years? I suspected the reason she didn't is that whatever she would try to write would expose her for not having written TKaM.
There are others who have theorized that Truman Capote actually wrote it. I think he denied it strenuously.It's just a sneaking suspicion. Based on nothing. Just strikes me as odd, the "one off" thing.hadespussercats wrote: There are plenty of writers I wish had that sort of self-awareness.
Other possibility-- having a crazy huge hit first time out can be the kiss of death to anything published subsequently.
I understand she worked as an editor.
As for TC writing it-- it is not neaaaaarly bleak enough to be his work. Even his light work was dark, if you looked close.
The green careening planet
spins blindly in the dark
so close to annihilation.
Listen. No one listens. Meow.
spins blindly in the dark
so close to annihilation.
Listen. No one listens. Meow.
- hadespussercats
- I've come for your pants.
- Posts: 18586
- Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2010 12:27 am
- About me: Looks pretty good, coming out of the back of his neck like that.
- Location: Gotham
- Contact:
Re: Catcher in the Rye and TKMockingbird out of American Sch
Hey, there's no way Ralph Ellison wrote that. It's his only published work. That's not how writers pursue their craft, Zilla. Don't you know anything?Gawdzilla Sama wrote:Anyone read The Invisible Man (not the scifi)?
The green careening planet
spins blindly in the dark
so close to annihilation.
Listen. No one listens. Meow.
spins blindly in the dark
so close to annihilation.
Listen. No one listens. Meow.
- Xamonas Chegwé
- Bouncer
- Posts: 50939
- Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2009 3:23 pm
- About me: I have prehensile eyebrows.
I speak 9 languages fluently, one of which other people can also speak.
When backed into a corner, I fit perfectly - having a right-angled arse. - Location: Nottingham UK
- Contact:
Re: Catcher in the Rye and TKMockingbird out of American Sch
I am sure they will once you publish...hadespussercats wrote:Although, I have to say, given the choice between being prolific, or having one wildly successful and well-loved work, boy, I'd go with the latter. Unfortunately, no one's giving me the choice!

A book is a version of the world. If you do not like it, ignore it; or offer your own version in return.
Salman Rushdie
You talk to God, you're religious. God talks to you, you're psychotic.
House MD
Who needs a meaning anyway, I'd settle anyday for a very fine view.
Sandy Denny
This is the wrong forum for bluffing
Paco
Yes, yes. But first I need to show you this venomous fish!
Calilasseia
I think we should do whatever Pawiz wants.
Twoflower
Bella squats momentarily then waddles on still peeing, like a horse
Millefleur
Salman Rushdie
You talk to God, you're religious. God talks to you, you're psychotic.
House MD
Who needs a meaning anyway, I'd settle anyday for a very fine view.
Sandy Denny
This is the wrong forum for bluffing

Paco
Yes, yes. But first I need to show you this venomous fish!
Calilasseia
I think we should do whatever Pawiz wants.
Twoflower
Bella squats momentarily then waddles on still peeing, like a horse
Millefleur
- hadespussercats
- I've come for your pants.
- Posts: 18586
- Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2010 12:27 am
- About me: Looks pretty good, coming out of the back of his neck like that.
- Location: Gotham
- Contact:
Re: Catcher in the Rye and TKMockingbird out of American Sch
Hmph.Xamonas Chegwé wrote:I am sure they will once you publish...hadespussercats wrote:Although, I have to say, given the choice between being prolific, or having one wildly successful and well-loved work, boy, I'd go with the latter. Unfortunately, no one's giving me the choice!
Working on it.
The green careening planet
spins blindly in the dark
so close to annihilation.
Listen. No one listens. Meow.
spins blindly in the dark
so close to annihilation.
Listen. No one listens. Meow.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 16 guests