U.K. is not a synonym of England

Post Reply
User avatar
MiM
Man In The Middle
Posts: 5459
Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 10:07 pm
Location: Finland
Contact:

Re: U.K. is not a synonym of England

Post by MiM » Sun Nov 04, 2012 2:04 pm

Bella Fortuna wrote:Let's just call it all "over there."


:leave:
Maybe "lesser United States" or "East America", from a EU/European perspective :coffee:
The first principle is that you must not fool yourself, and you are the easiest person to fool - Richard Feynman

User avatar
Cormac
Posts: 6415
Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2009 3:47 pm
Contact:

Re: U.K. is not a synonym of England

Post by Cormac » Sun Nov 04, 2012 2:07 pm

Red Celt wrote:OK, to answer your question...
klr wrote:If/when Scotland gets its independence, would you object to someone who uses the term "Great Britain"? Or even "Britain" ...
When referring to England and Wales , "Great Britain" would be factually untrue. It would be like referring to the U.S.A. as North America, ignoring Canada. "Britain" is a shorthand for United Kingdom of Great Britain. So, again, it would be untrue.

The island of Ireland is the second-largest of the British Isles. This is true. It has been true for (at least) 2000 years, when the names first originated. If Ireland somehow stopped being one of the British Isles, when did this happen? If it did happen (it didn't), it would be for political reasons (separation from the U.K.) rather than geographical reasons... which is what I've said from the start.

This isn't about opinions. Sorry and all that, but it really isn't.
Geography cannot be divorced from politics.

When did the people in England, Wales, and Scotland begin to refer to themselves as British?

The name "The British Isles" is intended to mean that these islands are inhabited and owned by British people, and indeed, that it is the place of origin of British people. It is a declaration of or recognition of ownership.
FUCKERPUNKERSHIT!


Wanna buy some pegs Dave, I've got some pegs here...
You're my wife now!

User avatar
Animavore
Nasty Hombre
Posts: 39276
Joined: Sun Mar 01, 2009 11:26 am
Location: Ire Land.
Contact:

Re: U.K. is not a synonym of England

Post by Animavore » Sun Nov 04, 2012 2:10 pm

I don't think I've heard anyone in Ireland use the term. It's not even on our maps as that. I think the first place I've heard it used was on the BBC weather forecast.
Libertarianism: The belief that out of all the terrible things governments can do, helping people is the absolute worst.

User avatar
Cormac
Posts: 6415
Joined: Thu Feb 26, 2009 3:47 pm
Contact:

Re: U.K. is not a synonym of England

Post by Cormac » Sun Nov 04, 2012 2:16 pm

Animavore wrote:I don't think I've heard anyone in Ireland use the term. It's not even on our maps as that. I think the first place I've heard it used was on the BBC weather forecast.
Officially, the position is that this island is not part of that group referred to as the British Isles, (although it isn't easy to dig that out from official documents).
FUCKERPUNKERSHIT!


Wanna buy some pegs Dave, I've got some pegs here...
You're my wife now!

User avatar
Svartalf
Offensive Grail Keeper
Posts: 41035
Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 12:42 pm
Location: Paris France
Contact:

Re: U.K. is not a synonym of England

Post by Svartalf » Sun Nov 04, 2012 2:16 pm

klr wrote:
Red Celt wrote: ...
These group of islands, off the Western coast of Europe are called the British Isles. Not because they're all owned, controlled or been the possession of London, but because that's what they're called. The subsequent history of these isles have given Irish people a very understandable reason to reject that label, but facts aren't altered by wishes or opinions. Ireland is one of several British Isles and that would be true even if it hadn't been under the control of invaders from the largest British Isle.
Hmmm ... as someone who protests (rightly) about the UK being confused with England, this is an odd perspective to hold.

If/when Scotland gets its independence, would you object to someone who uses the term "Great Britain"? Or even "Britain" ...

Just because the term "British Isles" dates all the way back to the Greek and Romans, doesn't mean it's valid usage anymore. There are plenty of geographical names that are no longer common currency for some reason or other.
Isn't "Prydein" a Pictish name?
Embrace the Darkness, it needs a hug

PC stands for "Patronizing Cocksucker" Randy Ping

User avatar
Red Celt
Humanist Misanthrope
Posts: 1349
Joined: Sat Sep 08, 2012 8:30 pm
About me: Crow Philosopher
Location: Fife, Scotland
Contact:

Re: U.K. is not a synonym of England

Post by Red Celt » Sun Nov 04, 2012 2:16 pm

Cormac wrote:Geography cannot be divorced from politics.

When did the people in England, Wales, and Scotland begin to refer to themselves as British?

The name "The British Isles" is intended to mean that these islands are inhabited and owned by British people, and indeed, that it is the place of origin of British people. It is a declaration of or recognition of ownership.
That wasn't what Ptolemy was doing. He was labeling some islands. He had no interest in ownership. Your use of "British Isles" may well be what you're suggesting. History, however, predates you be a very long way. To (further) challenge what you said, it isn't "the place of origin of British people". These islands have seen a succession of invasions and settlement by people who wouldn't have claimed Britain as their origin. Indeed, the Bretagnes of Western France could make better claims as far as "Britishness" is concerned.

You're trying to apply current thinking onto history (for political reasons). I don't have anything else (that I haven't already offered) to dissuade you from doing so. Each to their own and all that.
Image

User avatar
Red Celt
Humanist Misanthrope
Posts: 1349
Joined: Sat Sep 08, 2012 8:30 pm
About me: Crow Philosopher
Location: Fife, Scotland
Contact:

Re: U.K. is not a synonym of England

Post by Red Celt » Sun Nov 04, 2012 2:21 pm

Cormac wrote:
Animavore wrote:I don't think I've heard anyone in Ireland use the term. It's not even on our maps as that. I think the first place I've heard it used was on the BBC weather forecast.
Officially, the position is that this island is not part of that group referred to as the British Isles, (although it isn't easy to dig that out from official documents).
Officially? :) uhm... nah. Based on which (non-political) officials? Please provide a source.

Not the source for anyone's certainty, but here's Wikipedia's entry on The British Isles, just to show that I'm not inventing my own facts.
Image

User avatar
Red Celt
Humanist Misanthrope
Posts: 1349
Joined: Sat Sep 08, 2012 8:30 pm
About me: Crow Philosopher
Location: Fife, Scotland
Contact:

Re: U.K. is not a synonym of England

Post by Red Celt » Sun Nov 04, 2012 2:26 pm

Red Celt wrote:Officially? :) uhm... nah. Based on which (non-political) officials? Please provide a source.

Not the source for anyone's certainty, but here's Wikipedia's entry on The British Isles, just to show that I'm not inventing my own facts.
Hah. That page answered the question:-

"The term British Isles is controversial in Ireland,[8][13] where there are objections to its usage due to the association of the word British with Ireland.[14] The Government of Ireland does not use the term[15] and its embassy in London discourages its use.[16] As a result, Britain and Ireland is becoming a preferred description,[14][17][18] and Atlantic Archipelago is increasingly favoured in academia,[19][20][21][22] although British Isles is still commonly employed.[17]"

Politics, politics and more politics... dissociating itself from a truth purely because the phrase appears to show ownership, when it does no such thing.
Image

User avatar
MiM
Man In The Middle
Posts: 5459
Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 10:07 pm
Location: Finland
Contact:

Re: U.K. is not a synonym of England

Post by MiM » Sun Nov 04, 2012 2:36 pm

Red Celt wrote:
Red Celt wrote:Officially? :) uhm... nah. Based on which (non-political) officials? Please provide a source.

Not the source for anyone's certainty, but here's Wikipedia's entry on The British Isles, just to show that I'm not inventing my own facts.
Hah. That page answered the question:-

"The term British Isles is controversial in Ireland,[8][13] where there are objections to its usage due to the association of the word British with Ireland.[14] The Government of Ireland does not use the term[15] and its embassy in London discourages its use.[16] As a result, Britain and Ireland is becoming a preferred description,[14][17][18] and Atlantic Archipelago is increasingly favoured in academia,[19][20][21][22] although British Isles is still commonly employed.[17]"

Politics, politics and more politics... dissociating itself from a truth purely because the phrase appears to show ownership, when it does no such thing.
"Atlantic Arcipelago" :fp2:. First of all it's mainly two giant land masses, no archipelago, secondly, that could and should be contested by real Atlantic archipelago, like the Azores.
The first principle is that you must not fool yourself, and you are the easiest person to fool - Richard Feynman

User avatar
Svartalf
Offensive Grail Keeper
Posts: 41035
Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 12:42 pm
Location: Paris France
Contact:

Re: U.K. is not a synonym of England

Post by Svartalf » Sun Nov 04, 2012 2:43 pm

and he did it from Egypt in complete ignorance of the people actually living there... althout "a" Ptolemy (Claudius Ptolemaeus) wrote a Geographica where he already called it Ἰουερνία'.

Plus, 'little' or 'lesser' Britain used to be a name for Brittany.
Embrace the Darkness, it needs a hug

PC stands for "Patronizing Cocksucker" Randy Ping

User avatar
laklak
Posts: 21022
Joined: Tue Feb 23, 2010 1:07 pm
About me: My preferred pronoun is "Massah"
Location: Tannhauser Gate
Contact:

Re: U.K. is not a synonym of England

Post by laklak » Sun Nov 04, 2012 2:55 pm

Mrs. Lak gets her knickers in a knot when called "English". She considers herself African, even though her family are all feral Geordies. She doesn't sound like one though, eeee no like. She uses "British" as shorthand for "Citizen of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland".
Yeah well that's just, like, your opinion, man.

User avatar
Rum
Absent Minded Processor
Posts: 37285
Joined: Wed Mar 11, 2009 9:25 pm
Location: South of the border..though not down Mexico way..
Contact:

Re: U.K. is not a synonym of England

Post by Rum » Sun Nov 04, 2012 2:58 pm

I vote for keeping it murky.

User avatar
Svartalf
Offensive Grail Keeper
Posts: 41035
Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 12:42 pm
Location: Paris France
Contact:

Re: U.K. is not a synonym of England

Post by Svartalf » Sun Nov 04, 2012 3:02 pm

Mellow United Royal Kingdom of York?
Embrace the Darkness, it needs a hug

PC stands for "Patronizing Cocksucker" Randy Ping

User avatar
Red Celt
Humanist Misanthrope
Posts: 1349
Joined: Sat Sep 08, 2012 8:30 pm
About me: Crow Philosopher
Location: Fife, Scotland
Contact:

Re: U.K. is not a synonym of England

Post by Red Celt » Sun Nov 04, 2012 3:12 pm

Svartalf wrote:and he did it from Egypt in complete ignorance of the people actually living there...
Poor Ptolemy, taking flack because he didn't know that 2000 years later, a group of people would politically refuse the label of "British Isles" purely because it might make some inhabitants look as if they were the possession of other inhabitants. Silly old Greek-Egyptian, and him not being able to see into the future. Tsk!

:)
Image

User avatar
Jason
Destroyer of words
Posts: 17782
Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2011 12:46 pm
Contact:

Re: U.K. is not a synonym of England

Post by Jason » Sun Nov 04, 2012 3:57 pm

"U.K. is not a synonym of England" and why not?

Who is your head of state? An English Monarch.
What language do you speak? English.
What is the capitol of this 'United Kingdom'? The capitol of England.
Where are your laws made? London, England.

Yeah. The U.K. is not a synonym for England in the same way a guy in a pink dress, tiara, silk wings and holding a wand is a princess - 'not a fairy'! :roll:

Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest