Venture Bros: day 1

Post by **Drewish** » Wed Nov 30, 2011 4:46 pm

MattShizzle wrote:Yeah, bus drivers are usually a town role.

Really/ They're usually a scum role where I come from.

Post by **irretating** » Wed Nov 30, 2011 4:47 pm

gib wrote:andrew - good point about DP

tell me why you think MZ is a good candidate

Gib you're looking a bit scummy there, buddy. And I see the subsequent post you did, also just floating along with whatever is proposed.

Post by **Zigmen** » Wed Nov 30, 2011 4:48 pm

irretating wrote:
Magicziggy wrote:Re^^
irretating wrote:
That game was weird, I've never seen so many scum push a mayor BW like that.

I'm gonna @@vote irre@@
How else would you have me interpret this then?
You had to actually remove the post I quoted, that put my words in context. How scummy is that.

I'm not going to play into your hands, where people might think this is town-on-town bickering. I'm town, but I don't think you are.

Are you claiming MZ deleted a post?

Post by **irretating** » Wed Nov 30, 2011 4:50 pm

I'm tapatalking but IIRC feck did a post saying MZ's posts laying out his thinking did not seem like it was coming from a town perspective. Keep it in mind as a possible early purchase of town creds

Post by **Zigmen** » Wed Nov 30, 2011 4:50 pm

andrewclunn wrote:
MattShizzle wrote:Yeah, bus drivers are usually a town role.
Really/ They're usually a scum role where I come from.

I GMed a game with a Scum busdriver here one time, and that was afaik the only scum busdriver I had ever seen in any game.

It's possible, iow, but unlikely.

Post by **irretating** » Wed Nov 30, 2011 4:51 pm

Zigmen wrote:
irretating wrote:
Magicziggy wrote:Re^^
irretating wrote:
That game was weird, I've never seen so many scum push a mayor BW like that.

I'm gonna @@vote irre@@
How else would you have me interpret this then?
You had to actually remove the post I quoted, that put my words in context. How scummy is that.

I'm not going to play into your hands, where people might think this is town-on-town bickering. I'm town, but I don't think you are.
Are you claiming MZ deleted a post?

No I'm saying he quote mined me. My post was in response to, and quoted, the post from Andrew. But it served his purposes better to remove the context.

Post by **Uselesstwit** » Wed Nov 30, 2011 4:58 pm

insomnia irre?

Post by **gib** » Wed Nov 30, 2011 4:59 pm

irretating wrote:
gib wrote:andrew - good point about DP

tell me why you think MZ is a good candidate
Gib you're looking a bit scummy there, buddy. And I see the subsequent post you did, also just floating along with whatever is proposed.

well in fairness i'm not making any effort to appear not scummy but it's interesting that you're getting revengey

which post is the floating along one?

Post by **gib** » Wed Nov 30, 2011 5:01 pm

Zigmen wrote:
andrewclunn wrote:
MattShizzle wrote:Yeah, bus drivers are usually a town role.
Really/ They're usually a scum role where I come from.
I GMed a game with a Scum busdriver here one time, and that was afaik the only scum busdriver I had ever seen in any game.

It's possible, iow, but unlikely.

you pretty happy with your vote on MZ?

Post by **irretating** » Wed Nov 30, 2011 5:05 pm

Uselesstwit wrote:insomnia irre?

yeah

Post by **Zigmen** » Wed Nov 30, 2011 5:09 pm

gib wrote:
Zigmen wrote:
andrewclunn wrote:
MattShizzle wrote:Yeah, bus drivers are usually a town role.
Really/ They're usually a scum role where I come from.
I GMed a game with a Scum busdriver here one time, and that was afaik the only scum busdriver I had ever seen in any game.

It's possible, iow, but unlikely.
you pretty happy with your vote on MZ?

I am. I was all set to pull my vote off her this morning after thinking it was Way too ballsy for her to claim the same character as another player (and nobody had pointed out the duplications in the OP nor the "clone" flavor at the point I went to sleep).

But then I read Andrew's post from about 5 pages ago where he made the case that MZ looked like she had a plan that backfired and how ready she was the vote Shizz as soon as suspicion landed on her.

So I'm now thinking that MZ (or somebody on her team) caught the duplication thing from the OP, knew a bit about the "cloning" flavor, and decided to pull a somewhat risky claim out of the hat, or that Scum was given the same claim as a safe-claim.

Either way, I can't figure out any scenario where MZ could possibly be Town, know what she claims to know about the supposed similarity of the role PMs, and then throw her vote on Shizz.

Post by **Zigmen** » Wed Nov 30, 2011 5:12 pm

andrewclunn wrote:
gib wrote:andrew - good point about DP

tell me why you think MZ is a good candidate
He stated that he has reason to trust here:

Magicziggy wrote:I have good reason to believe Matt.
I have good reason to believe this is one weird arse game.
Then there's this once it looks like it's him or Matt:

Magicziggy wrote:
MattShizzle wrote:To reiterate if MZ was scum he'd be dumb to claim the same as me as once I was lynched and my role confirmed he'd be lynched - and 1 scum for 1 VT is good for town. I would almost say we should both be lynched but I wonder about weird roles. Town should still consider lynching both of us...
Now I have reason to lynch you.
##vote Mattshizzle##
Sounds like scum trying to use a townie with the same role to give their claim legitimacy, then when that plan fails, to throw them under the bus.

This post.

Post by **irretating** » Wed Nov 30, 2011 5:15 pm

Zig, MZ is a he.

My case on him relates to his acceptance if the shizz claim without checking the OP or PG to see that yes there could be multiple hanks. Then to suddenly turn on shizz at the very point he should have been OK with him. Then to make out that MY response to the situation was the off one.

Post by **irretating** » Wed Nov 30, 2011 5:15 pm

*of the shizz claim

Damn auto correct

Post by **irretating** » Wed Nov 30, 2011 5:17 pm

gib wrote:
irretating wrote:
gib wrote:andrew - good point about DP

tell me why you think MZ is a good candidate
Gib you're looking a bit scummy there, buddy. And I see the subsequent post you did, also just floating along with whatever is proposed.
well in fairness i'm not making any effort to appear not scummy but it's interesting that you're getting revengey

which post is the floating along one?

the one I quoted plus the one I noted you made about charlou

rationalia.com