MGS3: Snake Eater Mafia - Tactical Espionage Action (GAME)

[gib]

based on b.tern's flip and the vote bw on her. my new list is:

probable town: aden,char,zig,andrew, and amok
leaning town: aza, mz
unsure everyone else.

I'm not likely the shift in play from irre. she was much less interested day 2 and part of me can't help but think she's seething a bit about scum loosing night actions.

aza, not only did andrew out as an unlikely safeclaim role last night, but b.tern was all over him for 2 days including voting for him both days. He's looking pretty clear to me.

plus it's unlikely that andrew would have such a major character as a safeclaim

gotta wonder if aza is just trying to justify his vote there

[Uselesstwit]

trying to hint at something feck? like that you wouldn't bus a teammate that looked to be going down anyway? You want credit for your votes, explain them, and make then before the issue is pretty much decided.

[Uselesstwit]

based on b.tern's flip and the vote bw on her. my new list is:

probable town: aden,char,zig,andrew, and amok
leaning town: aza, mz
unsure everyone else.

I'm not likely the shift in play from irre. she was much less interested day 2 and part of me can't help but think she's seething a bit about scum loosing night actions.

aza, not only did andrew out as an unlikely safeclaim role last night, but b.tern was all over him for 2 days including voting for him both days. He's looking pretty clear to me.

plus it's unlikely that andrew would have such a major character as a safeclaim

gotta wonder if aza is just trying to justify his vote there

yeah, it would be like having capt kirk as a scum safe name claim for a star trek game, it could happen but seems unlikely.

Aza is really only on that town list because b.tern went after him a bit in her summation list. I wouldn't be horribly shocked if either aza or mz showed up as the traitor.

[gib]

btern's list for easy reference:

Yeah, adenosine, I lynch voted andrew, and people wer all 'ooo poor newb, give 'im a chance!' so I made an effort to see that pov and help him out. Personally, I don't think it's necessarily scummy to do that. YMMV.

What is your list, b.ter ... most town to least town/scummiest?

God I hate making this kind of list, especially with subs and extra players tossed in.

Most to least townish:
Charlou - outed doc
Amok - can't see her as scum, with the confused posts etc.
DP - I buy his willingness to take a bullet for charlou (so sweet! )
Irre - Got a good town feeling is all, played a few games with her now ans seems like town Irre.
Feck - hasn't posted much but I agreed with the posts he made, for the most part.
Gib - town Gib, cheerily trying to make town friends, I think
MZ - Dunno, seems townish as hell, usual flip-flop style - don't think I've ever played a game with MZ where he wasn't town, but there's always a first time.
UT - Nothing pinged, but I should re-read his posts
Matt - calmer than usual, townish
Contra - Dunno, really. I was a bit sus. of Athene tbh
zigmen - started the game late, seems less interested than usual
Adenosine - trolly tracking me a bit, which always bugs me and makes me think scum trying to out specials, maybe.
Az - really pinging - playing oblivion? Funny, but why would az sign on for a mafia game when he knew he'd be too involved in something else?
andrewclunn - really really not townish at all, newb or not.

D'I miss anyone?

[Azathoth]

based on b.tern's flip and the vote bw on her. my new list is:

probable town: aden,char,zig,andrew, and amok
leaning town: aza, mz
unsure everyone else.

I'm not likely the shift in play from irre. she was much less interested day 2 and part of me can't help but think she's seething a bit about scum loosing night actions.

aza, not only did andrew out as an unlikely safeclaim role last night, but b.tern was all over him for 2 days including voting for him both days. He's looking pretty clear to me.

plus it's unlikely that andrew would have such a major character as a safeclaim

gotta wonder if aza is just trying to justify his vote there

Nonsense. Most GMs keep a major character back to use as a safeclaim for the precise reason of making name claiming worthless. I don't need to justify my vote. Just look at his posts. He drops a classic scumtell in nearly every one

[Feck]

trying to hint at something feck? like that you wouldn't bus a teammate that looked to be going down anyway? You want credit for your votes, explain them, and make then before the issue is pretty much decided.

interesting , where and when could I have put my vote that you wouldn't have claimed was scummy ?

[gib]

based on b.tern's flip and the vote bw on her. my new list is:

probable town: aden,char,zig,andrew, and amok
leaning town: aza, mz
unsure everyone else.

I'm not likely the shift in play from irre. she was much less interested day 2 and part of me can't help but think she's seething a bit about scum loosing night actions.

aza, not only did andrew out as an unlikely safeclaim role last night, but b.tern was all over him for 2 days including voting for him both days. He's looking pretty clear to me.

plus it's unlikely that andrew would have such a major character as a safeclaim

gotta wonder if aza is just trying to justify his vote there

Nonsense. Most GMs keep a major character back to use as a safeclaim for the precise reason of making name claiming worthless. I don't need to justify my vote. Just look at his posts. He drops a classic scumtell in nearly every one

name a game where scum had a comparably major character given to them as a safeclaim

[gib]

trying to hint at something feck? like that you wouldn't bus a teammate that looked to be going down anyway? You want credit for your votes, explain them, and make then before the issue is pretty much decided.

interesting , where and when could I have put my vote that you wouldn't have claimed was scummy ?

oo ooh, does it rhyme with 'sup your glass'?

[Azathoth]

based on b.tern's flip and the vote bw on her. my new list is:

probable town: aden,char,zig,andrew, and amok
leaning town: aza, mz
unsure everyone else.

I'm not likely the shift in play from irre. she was much less interested day 2 and part of me can't help but think she's seething a bit about scum loosing night actions.

aza, not only did andrew out as an unlikely safeclaim role last night, but b.tern was all over him for 2 days including voting for him both days. He's looking pretty clear to me.

plus it's unlikely that andrew would have such a major character as a safeclaim

gotta wonder if aza is just trying to justify his vote there

Nonsense. Most GMs keep a major character back to use as a safeclaim for the precise reason of making name claiming worthless. I don't need to justify my vote. Just look at his posts. He drops a classic scumtell in nearly every one

name a game where scum had a comparably major character given to them as a safeclaim

You can pick from any of mine or any of oblivion's. MLP is a good place to start

You are the scum team. When the siren sounds you will change into your silent hill avatars. b. tern is pyramid head and is immune to night kill, Ob is zombie nurse and Irre is Split head. Both vanilla scum. Each night you must choose a player to kill and nominate one of your number to perform the kill. If you do not one of you will kill a random player from a list including yourselves.



during the day you appear as:
b.tern-fluttershy http://mlp.wikia.com/wiki/Fluttershy
ob-granny smith http://mlp.wikia.com/wiki/Granny_Smith
Irre-scootaloo http://mlp.wikia.com/wiki/Scootaloo

writeboard here

http://123.writeboard.com/s88cowenth9j3c5f/v/new

pw:silent

[gib]

i have no idea if those ponies are captain kirks dude

but listen, i do agree that a half out is pointless seeing as if he is town then scum will know to target him anyway

[Uselesstwit]

trying to hint at something feck? like that you wouldn't bus a teammate that looked to be going down anyway? You want credit for your votes, explain them, and make then before the issue is pretty much decided.

interesting , where and when could I have put my vote that you wouldn't have claimed was scummy ?

where did i say it was scummy? I said you didn't get town cred for an unexplained last minute vote. You want on the town list? let's have yours, and your reasoning for it. Don't go thru the game skating and expect to instantly be recognized as town.

[amok]

I agree character claims aren't the be all and end all, but on the cusp of a lynch when there's at least reasonable doubt raised and other reasonably scummy alternatives, I'm not seeing the logic in not taking the risk.

I also don't know if the Ponies example is helpful. The MLP website lists dozens and dozens of Ponies, but I can't find a reference to any one of them being Pony Prime or something like that.

[Don't Panic]

DP had one post today. In response to irre saying that Andrew's pairing of irre and DP was impossible:

yeah, me and you as scum would be… dramatic.

What does clunny mean?

Did not stick around for an answer.

Someone should tell me how he is town.

because I am?

What were your questions?

I haven't been online at all for the past day, check the rest of the forum, I got a few minutes free to check in on tapatalk when I posted that and then I was gone again. I've been doing the scheduling equivalent of juggling chainsaws all weekend and into yesterday and early today, I'm tired and I'm cranky, and I'm town, and from my willingness to take a bullet to save Charlou(a special) it should be pretty obvious that I'm vanilla.

The rest of my week is fairly normal so if I'm still alive you'll see increased participation, and if I'm dead: Dúirt mé duit go raibh mé baile.

[Don't Panic]

For what it's worth I'm Dr. Aleksandr Leonovitch Granin, I'm GRU(I am the actual G in GRU) and I'm town.

[gib]

DP, how would you think a scum would respond if asked to take a bullet?