Darkover Mafia Game Thread

[DennyB]

Vote cookie
Him not wanting to be truthful about his night action when called on it is a scum tell.

[charlou]

What ever happen to lynch all liers? Yet there are votes for cookie for mayor??
He help nail the SK. Scum could do that too?

How many blockers do you think there are in this game, Denny?

[Feck]

OK Linus why do you think I'm scum ?

I think your role claim doesn't provide much evidence about your alignment and you haven't looked positively townish. I'm a bit concerned by e.g. your statement that appears to say implicitly that you had knowledge of Mantis' alignment.

So I've cleared 2 town already and you think I'm scum ? ...nice compared to you I look "positively townish" don't I ?

[DennyB]

What ever happen to lynch all liers? Yet there are votes for cookie for mayor??
He help nail the SK. Scum could do that too?

How many blockers do you think there are in this game, Denny?

I have been very busy and have not been taking notes in this game.
Does anyone have a list of role claims/cleared players?

[Linus]

I have been very busy and have not been taking notes in this game.
Does anyone have a list of role claims/cleared players?

As far as I remember:

athene - mason
aza - mason
zigmen - innocent child

charlou - claims 1-shot (?) bodyguard
cookie - claims role blocker
denny - claims 1-shot (?) lie detector
feck - claims watcher
ksen - claims double voter

[def]

OK Linus why do you think I'm scum ?

Probably for the same reason he voted for me yesterday. Scummy, trying to add to the confusion.

What do you think about Feck, then?

Unfortunately, he gave the results about Bolero after Cookie said he was blocked. And it is very easy for scum to 'clear' players, since they know who's good and bad... But (and I can't go back to read day two and three to see how he cleared them) watchers can only tell who was targeted, so his story would seem to hold up.

He's not on my top suspect list at the moment. I'd just like to know what puts Bolero at the top at the moment Not doubting, I just missed the argument when it came up.

[CookieJon]

Vote cookie
Him not wanting to be truthful about his night action when called on it is a scum tell.

Oh for Pete's sake.

--

In the meantime, I've been reflecting on def's "snippy" posts a day or two ago when pressed about flying under the radar.

While def's reaction was justifiable, I suppose, it seemed to me that it gave him a nice hook to contribute something, and that he was taking advantage of that opportunity to be seen, but do little else.

Just a hunch, but FoS def.

What do you have to say for yourself def?

--

And also - does anyone know ANYTHING about praying??

[DennyB]

I have been very busy and have not been taking notes in this game.
Does anyone have a list of role claims/cleared players?

As far as I remember:

athene - mason
aza - mason
zigmen - innocent child

charlou - claims 1-shot (?) bodyguard
cookie - claims role blocker
denny - claims 1-shot (?) lie detector
feck - claims watcher
ksen - claims double voter

OK thanks

2. Feck-claims watcher
4. Mantisdreamz-cleared by denny with SK gone
9. ksen-claims double voter, kidnaped N1
11. Bolero
12. CookieJon-claims role blocker
13 Charlou- claims 1-shot (?) bodyguard
14. DennyB-claims 1-shot (?) lie detector
15. Linus
16. def
17. praying

Please feel free to update that list.
Who kidnapped ksen on N1? Was it Charlou?

[DennyB]

unvote
vote bolero

[DennyB]

So far I'm good with a Linus, def, praying or bolero lynch today

[Feck]

I would go Bolero Linus Def Praying in that order so far

[Linus]

I'd just like to know what puts Bolero at the top at the moment

My overall impression is not townish and with so much suspicion I think Bolero's alignment needs to be cleared up before endgame.

[DennyB]

I would go Bolero Linus Def Praying in that order so far

I think if bolero flips scum we should move Def up to the next lynch.

[def]

What do you have to say for yourself def?

At least at this point, the people FOS'ing me might have an actual reason. The ones on day two and even three were just random nonsense. So it was annoying.

As for flying under the radar, nope. I voted days two and three, and tried my best to follow things up, get involved in the discussion, particularly on three and today. Not as much as you, but I made a number of substantial posts.

[center]~~~~~~[/cemter]

Since everyone seems to be claiming roles in the open, which seems utterly crazy to me, but maybe that's in a PM game... I have a town role, nothing conflicting with other claims so far.

Which is why I wanted to hear people's ideas about who they think is safe and unsafe (http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 59#p851459). It gives all town more to work with, and it tells us more after someone gets offed.

[def]

I would go Bolero Linus Def Praying in that order so far

I think if bolero flips scum we should move Def up to the next lynch.

Care to explain?