Venture Bros: day 3

Post by **gib** » Sat Dec 03, 2011 6:57 pm

who's scum then mantis?

Post by **Mantisdreamz** » Sat Dec 03, 2011 7:04 pm

gib wrote:who's scum then mantis?

Gonzo, Zigmen, Amok or Matt.

Why did Gonzo offer up so much information?

Post by **gib** » Sat Dec 03, 2011 8:32 pm

MZ, did you put in your block last night or were you like gonzo and forgot?

Post by **gib** » Sat Dec 03, 2011 8:34 pm

do we have anything that confirms the blockers' claims other than each other?

Post by **Magicziggy** » Sat Dec 03, 2011 8:36 pm

Yes, I blocked mantis. She confirmed it.

Post by **gib** » Sat Dec 03, 2011 8:38 pm

sorry, missed that, my bad

Post by **Magicziggy** » Sat Dec 03, 2011 8:38 pm

It's why I wanted to wait for mantis. She'd mentioned batman. I had already said I dressed up as someone. This means that gonzo has a mechanism to confirm he is the blocker

Post by **amok** » Sat Dec 03, 2011 8:47 pm

Gonzo wrote:
amok wrote:
gib wrote:i think it's gonzo mantis and zigmen
I think it's Gonzo. I'm pretty sure about Mantis. I'm hesitant about Zigmen, because I'm trying to decide if I'm just being snotty over his FOSes on me. I was really, really sure you (Gib) was Scum for most of this game, and reading back, I have to concede a lot (not all) of that was feeling targetted (plus I thought you were intentionally not answering my questions.)

I honestly can't see DP (as Scum) making that kind of mistake. DP (as Town), yes, I can see it.

So that, for me, clears Charlou/Aza, Gib & DP. I had already cleared MZ and Matt, in my mind.

That leaves ... Zigmen, Gonzo, irretating, Mantisdreamz.

I do not like amok's list here. Mantis makes some sense, but I am having my doubts about her. I am not scum and do not see her case against Zig or Irre so FOS amok.

It was a process of elimination.

Post by **Zigmen** » Sat Dec 03, 2011 8:50 pm

Going out to see The Muppets.

bbl.

Post by **gib** » Sat Dec 03, 2011 8:52 pm

DP is going to be the favorite choice for scum to kill tonight i would think

assuming mantis is lynched that would leave

mz - confirmed as blocker, potentially scum blocker i guess
gonzo - if mz is town then gonzo is likely town or got lucky guessing which nights a counterpart would be able to block. Also, MZ figured he would have a counterpart, and no one has counterclaimed as odd night blocker.

still the potential both are scum i guess - unliklely imo, but someone tell me if i'm missing something there

Aza - cleared by DP
gib - cleared by DP

shizzle - it's possible he's scum but only really if the GM gave out hank as a safeclaim which would be pretty shitty. Tempted to treat him as cleared unless i've missed something

amok
irre
zigmen

so, assuming none of the claims are scum gambits then we're left with amok, irre and zigmen. If mantis flips scum then we just need to get one of those 3 cleared somehow to help us work out which 2 are scum

Post by **gib** » Sat Dec 03, 2011 8:53 pm

gonzo you need to put in a block tonight

Post by **gib** » Sat Dec 03, 2011 8:55 pm

Magicziggy wrote:It's why I wanted to wait for mantis. She'd mentioned batman. I had already said I dressed up as someone. This means that gonzo has a mechanism to confirm he is the blocker

i sort of follow - do you mean gonzo could right now post something that would satisfy you that he is town?

Post by **amok** » Sat Dec 03, 2011 8:59 pm

gib wrote:DP is going to be the favorite choice for scum to kill tonight i would think

assuming mantis is lynched that would leave

mz - confirmed as blocker, potentially scum blocker i guess
gonzo - if mz is town then gonzo is likely town or got lucky guessing which nights a counterpart would be able to block. Also, MZ figured he would have a counterpart, and no one has counterclaimed as odd night blocker.

still the potential both are scum i guess - unliklely imo, but someone tell me if i'm missing something there

Aza - cleared by DP
gib - cleared by DP

shizzle - it's possible he's scum but only really if the GM gave out hank as a safeclaim which would be pretty shitty. Tempted to treat him as cleared unless i've missed something

amok
irre
zigmen

so, assuming none of the claims are scum gambits then we're left with amok, irre and zigmen. If mantis flips scum then we just need to get one of those 3 cleared somehow to help us work out which 2 are scum

That's a good plan. DP must be the seer, because there's been no counter-claim. Which absolutely clears Aza and Gib. I'm very confident of MZ and fairly confident of MattShizzle.

I'm going to a Christmas Party.

##vote Mantis##

Post by **gib** » Sat Dec 03, 2011 9:01 pm

in theory DP could be the scum version of the flavor cop but i really can't see the GM doing that without putting a town seer in and like you say, no one has claimed seer

Post by **gib** » Sat Dec 03, 2011 9:06 pm

DP you should still put a view in just in case scum have other ideas mmk

rationalia.com