ElfQuest Mafia - Game Thread

[Uselesstwit]

i kind of agree about charlou. we didn't have the extra kill that night, and she has been off this game. But I think praying is my number one pick right now. so shel'll probably get the view tonight.

I'm thinking that almost has to be the last scum. A five man scum team, with an sk and an indie that could go towards helping scum seems way out of balance.

[DennyB]

Linus,

The role PM was added to the PG. So that clears no one.
I think we should lynch praying tomorrow depending on what happens overnight.

BTW, I am a wolfrider and town.

In the day 1 OP it says
"And your band has been infiltrated,"
I wonder what this meens?

[Feck]

Linus,

The role PM was added to the PG. So that clears no one.
I think we should lynch praying tomorrow depending on what happens overnight.

BTW, I am a wolfrider and town.

In the day 1 OP it says
"And your band has been infiltrated,"
I wonder what this meens?

well there wouldn't be a point to Mafia if our band hadn't ...

[Linus]

The role PM was added to the PG. So that clears no one.

I didn't say that praying is clear (indeed, I listed her as the 2nd best bet). What do you make of her discussion with Athene about her role PM? (Don't just repeat the irrelevant point that the vanilla role PM template is public knowledge from the PG. Go back, read, and actually think.)

[divagreen]

Wait a minute, I disclosed my role!

[Feck]

Wait a minute, I disclosed my role!

or a safe claim given out by Oblivion ?

[Bolero]

Hey guys. Just catching up.

Well, I feel better now about suspecting Aza - maybe my intuition in this game isn't so crap after all.

So now it's a matter of working out who we can trust, I guess.

On the assumption that that was the last scum... Some brief summaries:

ut - blocked N2 when mystery kill went through, least suspicious
feck - potential mason... potential something else? but it seems unbalancing
msg - credible doc claim, probably not SK, possibly third faction
denny - low-profile & confused lists of suspects, got extra kill, probably not SK, possibly third faction
bolero - could be
diva - could be
praying - almost 100% fluff posts, but entered discussion of role PM
charlou - low-profile, "well endowed" remark, looks like plausible N1 scum block

UT seems cleared, if he's the seer. He hasn't given us any bum steers for the whole game, so I'm up for trusting he is what he says.
Feck's claim to innocence was a message for higgs. Have we confirmed this?
MSG's doc claim has panned out in terms of protecting people who he said he'd protect.

The rest of us have yet to prove our towniness, I guess. If we make sure we vote with one of the above in terms of lynching, and pass all clues, hints, Mod PMs and such on to them, we have a good chance of winning. I'm aware that these people will also be scum targets (if there's any non-town-friendlies left), so if anyone has protection powers, they need to be used on these guys.

[MSG]

Feck's claim was credible, because he did post 2 conspicuous posts on day 1 using the capitalised word Nightfall (including using the words day break in one.)

[divagreen]

I don't understand what you mean by safe claim.

My role PM only had 18 words in it. I have no special talents, nothing. My character's name is Krim, I am a Go-Back.

[Bolero]

Feck's claim was credible, because he did post 2 conspicuous posts on day 1 using the capitalised word Nightfall (including using the words day break in one.)

Ah. Gotcha.

[Linus]

Bolero, who do you think is the bet as the person responsible for the mystery nightkills?

[Bolero]

Bolero, who do you think is the bet as the person responsible for the mystery nightkills?

I wouldn't have a clue.

Yesterday I was happy to vote to lynch charlou, but tbh, that's cause I was a bit annoyed by her suggestion I wasn't helping (Sorry, charlou! Petulant and silly of me). Today (tonight? I've lost track ) I'm not sure at all, and I wouldn't want to point the FoS without a good reason.

Again, not so helpful, but if you have any suggestions with decent reasons, I'd really like to hear them. (Of course I realise that I'm on the suspect list myself, as are you, but I don't know how to go about remedying that. I've no special powers or gifts, and no role beyond waiting to get killed, as far as I can see.)

[Bolero]

I've gotta go teach my class, so I'll say au revoir for now. I'll check back in at lunchtime, if I can.

[MSG]

Is Day 5 going to start early?

[oblivion]

yes it is. I'm working on it now.