ElfQuest Mafia - Game Thread

[divagreen]

Excuse me...correction.

Denny. He is the one who was gung ho about claiming Mantis's death.

[Linus]

Excuse me...correction.

Denny. He is the one who was gung ho about claiming Mantis's death.

If we have an SK, then I believe it would be rather unusual to give the SK an extra night kill in addition to the regular night kill.

[divagreen]

Ah, fuck it, it was MZ wasn't it?

You are right Linus.

I am just still stuck on Day 2 and the weird exchange between Aza, Feck and Denny. I think one of them is scum. Or maybe none of them are and they just can't keep track.

Do you think my question to UT is a valid one, Linus? Why is it getting ignored? If he is our seer and he outed himself early in the game, shouldn't he be coming forth and sharing whom he has viewed?

[Linus]

I am just still stuck on Day 2 and the weird exchange between Aza, Feck and Denny. I think one of them is scum. Or maybe none of them are and they just can't keep track.

What specifically makes you think one of them is scum?

Do you think my question to UT is a valid one, Linus? Why is it getting ignored? If he is our seer and he outed himself early in the game, shouldn't he be coming forth and sharing whom he has viewed?

If there is only 1 scum and a 1 mysterious killer left, then it probably doesn't matter so much. But in general outing info late can make the day more informative (e.g. if a view averts a mislynch or if scum have to guess which of them has been viewed as scum and will go down).

[Uselesstwit]

yep, that's the plan, see if we can't make them sweat a bit before i give out last night's view. we still have 17 ours of daylight left so i'll out when i get up in the morning. night all.

[divagreen]

But UT has not come forth with any viewings at all, since Irre.

What specifically makes you think one of them is scum?

I wish I could answer that.

If the "hauntingly familiar" blade is the trademark of an SK kill, then they are doing a better job at aiming their targets, IMO. MZ, Irre...those were two of the strongest pro-town players in this game.

[divagreen]

yep, that's the plan, see if we can't make them sweat a bit before i give out last night's view. we still have 17 ours of daylight left so i'll out when i get up in the morning. night all.

Whoa, wait a minute UT. You have two nights of info that you should have inquired and you should have received. That is if you are doing your job.

[Linus]

But UT has not come forth with any viewings at all, since Irre.

What specifically makes you think one of them is scum?

I wish I could answer that.

If the "hauntingly familiar" blade is the trademark of an SK kill, then they are doing a better job at aiming their targets, IMO. MZ, Irre...those were two of the strongest pro-town players in this game.

Irre was a scum kill.

[divagreen]

Okay, I reread the opening post. But why Athene? She has hardly been active in the last few days.

[MSG]

Athene is dead. Do try to keep up diva.

UT was blocked on night 2:

okay to clear things up. I sent the hammer on to mz figuring i wouldn't make it thru the night. I was visited by a well endowed women last night who prevented me from taking any actions. Well outside of the bed i guess.

(My bold) - that's consistent with the role description for zigmen, who was Oddbit, the scum roleblocker

http://www.elfquest.com/pubs/bios/Trolls/Oddbit.html

Oddbit embodies all the maidenly virtues: greed, deception, opportunism, manipulativeness, coyness, vanity, and fickleness.She is the ultimate material girl, adorning the footstools of both King Greymung and King Guttlekraw.

[divagreen]

I know that Athene is dead...I am asking why her?

okay to clear things up. I sent the hammer on to mz figuring i wouldn't make it thru the night. I was visited by a well endowed women last night who prevented me from taking any actions. Well outside of the bed i guess.

That explains one night...but the other?

[MSG]

rolls eyes

today is day 4

night 0 - no view

night 1 - views irre

night 2 - blocked

night 3 - hasn't revealed yet

are you really this dumb?

[MSG]

why athene? cos whoever did it wants town to lose?

where are you going with this diva? are you just deliberately creating wifom?

[divagreen]

The role of the investigator was not disclosed in the original game thread. I guess I really am that dumb for not assuming that it is there. Call it lack of experience and that I do not make assumptions.

I think that the choice of Athene as an SK kill should be considered with respects as to why. Shoot me. She was not a threat, as far as I could read.

[MSG]

So what you are asking is, what is the SK's probable win condition?