MLP Game Thread

[Magicziggy]

Just checked. Mono was online about 11 hours ago. So he's the sk for sure.
Rationale on UT.
Still alive
Feck said it was a scum block
Didn't vote day 2. It would have been all three scum on ksen to tie.
He's a cunning bastard. ( in the nicest possible sense)

Against
Bussed b.t. - gets town cred for that.
Need to look at his interactions with irre on day 1.

Bedtime.

[Magicziggy]

And one more thing that nagged me about day 1. UT would not forget about how mono skates.that whole interaction with irre looks fake.

[Magicziggy]

Ksen has not been online for 39 hours. Case closed.

[oblivion]

need to think about this a bit. You think UT threw a scum special under the bus yesterday? I'm not sure we would have lynched b.tern without UT outing about having blocked Mono.

[Uselesstwit]

i'm also guessing the final scum would be a don, but i could be wrong about that. I am who I said I am. we should lynch mono today, get rid of that kill and then start thinking if it's ob or mz who is the final scum. and considering mz and irre's early behavior I know which way i'll be going with that.

[oblivion]

Ksen has not been online for 39 hours. Case closed.

I thought you were onto something here. but he could access a scumboard without logging in to ratz.

however, b.tern and Irre went after him on day 2. He's a low probability IMO, but not completely ruled out.

[Uselesstwit]

i've been thinking about this, mz i'm not a stupid player but for me to be scum i'd have to be. for me to be the scum roleblocker it would mean that yesterday, after my block revealed a likely sk candidate, instead of just letting that candidate get lynched by town, I decided to out. In the face of feck saying it felt like a scum block, and making myself a target to the sk. I then went on to save the sk from the lynch by putting my own teamate under the bus. the teammate that was immune to the sk no less. it would have been a game over move if mono had targeted me last night, I would never put a game into someone elses hands like that as scum, and you know this. either you are the last scum, or you fell into ob's trap.

ob, i'm not sure why you even need to think about it. mono is clearly the sk, ksen has to be either scum or vanilla. i can't imagine he's a special that bailed since that really doesn't seem like ksen, even though i know he's busy on the weekends. Surely as a special he'd at least make the effort to put in his actions. you know your role, so i guess the question is, are you a special, if not do you think town only had a seer?

[oblivion]

Yeah, Mono is clearly the SK. And I agree that we need to get rid of one of the night kills. In retrospect maybe it would have been better for town if we had lynched mono yesterday.

What I want to think about is what next after today.

[oblivion]

I dunno. loss of two townies last night, yeah. also loss of a question mark - feck.

[oblivion]

so let's talk about tomorrow. If we lynch mono today, then tomorrow comes down to three of UT, MZ, ksen and me. Tonight's kill will be very informative, I think. It's possible scum will pass. a 3-1 endgame is statistically more favorable than 2-1.

[oblivion]

i've been thinking about this, mz i'm not a stupid player but for me to be scum i'd have to be. for me to be the scum roleblocker it would mean that yesterday, after my block revealed a likely sk candidate, instead of just letting that candidate get lynched by town, I decided to out. In the face of feck saying it felt like a scum block, and making myself a target to the sk. I then went on to save the sk from the lynch by putting my own teamate under the bus. the teammate that was immune to the sk no less. it would have been a game over move if mono had targeted me last night, I would never put a game into someone elses hands like that as scum, and you know this. either you are the last scum, or you fell into ob's trap.

please explain the trap.

ob, i'm not sure why you even need to think about it. mono is clearly the sk, ksen has to be either scum or vanilla. i can't imagine he's a special that bailed since that really doesn't seem like ksen, even though i know he's busy on the weekends. Surely as a special he'd at least make the effort to put in his actions. you know your role, so i guess the question is, are you a special, if not do you think town only had a seer?

I'm vanilla. I'm Granny Smith (;ob; Aza).

I don't think town only had a seer, especially not with b.tern's role. IMO, either you are the legitimate town roleblocker or Mono is vig, not SK. Of the two, I buy you as roleblocker.

[oblivion]

##vote mono##

[Uselesstwit]

the trap was referring to who got nk'd last night, leaving me alone points to a player that either wanted mz to go after me, or by mz himself as an excuse to go after me. IMO you're the player left with the savy to do the first part. I kind of wish you were a special, it would have been easier for me to decide on who's left.

but yeah, we can't have two night kills tonight.

##vote mono##

who should be my block tonight?

[oblivion]

I think you should keep your block under your hat this time.

[Uselesstwit]

i'm going out for most of the day, i'll reread b.tern tonight and see if it sheds any light.

tonight i should be able to post it one minute before daybreak, but i still wouldn't mind some feedback on who it should be. at the very least it'll provide some insight into what people are thinking.