MLP Game Thread

[Magicziggy]

Ok. How's this? Mono was the vig. Killed charlou and now feels so bad has stayed away.

[oblivion]

so if the slashy death is scum, then Mono is most likely not scum.

[oblivion]

this is a huge break.

[Uselesstwit]

yep, but the question is, do we go after likely scum today or take out the most likely candidate for the sk, if we have one. which in a game this size is really a tough call.

[Magicziggy]

When was mono last online?

[b.ternarius]

Yeah, the block question needs to be addressed so town can make a fully informed decision. Ob is right a mislynch here could be fatal. I'm spinning my wheels trying to figure out the possibilities, so some help would be appreciated. I blocked mono last night. I'm leaning towards the slashings being the scum kills. If I were on the scum team I'd be using mono for all the night kills since he's made himself a throwaway player. That's why i'm not really for lynching him today, he's probably not scum. On the other hand if we do have a sk and not a one shot vig he's the top suspect since we didn't have a second kill last night. And obviously it would be in town's best interest not to have two kills tonight. I'm getting a town vibe off of mz and ob and since you're both around I want to out now so we can discuss before i'm killed tonight.

to fully out, i'm Big Mcintosh.

Well, that clarifies a lot. I couldn't for the life of me figure out why you'd not want to get rid of mono in the circumstances, but your reasoning makes some sense now.

Though if mono is a SK, taking him out ensures one less kill tonight.

[Uselesstwit]

Ok. How's this? Mono was the vig. Killed charlou and now feels so bad has stayed away.

kind of my thoughts, he takes a long break, comes back, isn't quite sure what a miller is so kills her, sees all of our reactions to the kill and bails. But if that was a sk kill not a vig kill, it's likely him and it would be great to be sure of not having two night kills.

[b.ternarius]

If mono is just a poor decision maker vig (I've been there, mono - vig is not easy) there's time for him to come and explain himself. Otherwise I really see no reason not to lynch him to avoid another kill.

##vote mono##

[oblivion]

you know, we are assuming there isn't a doctor in this game.

[Uselesstwit]

so the fact that he's almost certainly not scum isn't a good reason?

[Uselesstwit]

you know, we are assuming there isn't a doctor in this game.

also true, and that could account for why there was only one kill, but mono was blocked and the slasher kill still went thru. and like i said i'm really leaning towards that being the scum kill.

[Feck]

It would be better to find scum than lynch mono but better to lynch Mono than lynch another town .


Bronies shouldn't play poker .

[oblivion]

nah. if mono is vig another special is too many.

[Uselesstwit]

It would be better to find scum than lynch mono but better to lynch Mono than lynch another town .


Bronies shouldn't play poker .

granted on both counts, but who are your scum picks now?

[oblivion]

this is getting too crazy for phoneposting. I should be at my laptop in about 10 minutes.