ElfQuest Mafia - Game Thread

[charlou]

Did you read higgs' posts? Did she drop any form of a special tell to you?

Higgs is normally quite active, so her low participation on day 1 stands out.

She's had quite a few quieter games here lately. Interesting that you think it stands out.

re the bit I bolded: How so?

[Linus]

Charlou, as irre noted, MSG claimed doc. Also, AFAICT, from the dream Aza reported, he appears to have successfully protected Feck from NK. Do you still have MSG as your top suspect?

[Bolero]

Other interesting things to note from the Day 2 thread:

Aza is the one who first pointed the FoS at DP. Diva was the second. (At least, in that thread) And this was when we were mostly on board with the "Lynch irre coz she's not an elf" plan (before her explanation).

Man, I don't know. I need to take a break from this and go do some work before I get fired.

[irretating]

Did you read higgs' posts? Did she drop any form of a special tell to you?

Higgs is normally quite active, so her low participation on day 1 stands out.

She's had quite a few quieter games here lately. Interesting that you think it stands out.

re the bit I bolded: How so?

Interesting because I think a TR-based player wanted the kill on higgs. And Linus has said that higgs stood out to him (where she absolutely doesn't for me).

And, thanks bolero, for bringing up who mantis was talking about previously. I've had a re-read of her posts, she really tried to spread the attention around!

Speaking of Linus, I saw this post: http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 54#p793938

where you specifically ask mantis who she is most suspicious of... now that stands out to me, because of everyone posting, why ask mantis? You seem to have taken a cue from UT asking me who I was suspicious of (which is based on him liking my scum hunting when he knows I'm aligned with town). But... why mantis of all people?

vote Linus

[Bolero]

Did you read higgs' posts? Did she drop any form of a special tell to you?

Higgs is normally quite active, so her low participation on day 1 stands out.

She's had quite a few quieter games here lately. Interesting that you think it stands out.

re the bit I bolded: How so?

Interesting because I think a TR-based player wanted the kill on higgs. And Linus has said that higgs stood out to him (where she absolutely doesn't for me).

And, thanks bolero, for bringing up who mantis was talking about previously. I've had a re-read of her posts, she really tried to spread the attention around!

Speaking of Linus, I saw this post: http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 54#p793938

where you specifically ask mantis who she is most suspicious of... now that stands out to me, because of everyone posting, why ask mantis? You seem to have taken a cue from UT asking me who I was suspicious of (which is based on him liking my scum hunting when he knows I'm aligned with town). But... why mantis of all people?

vote Linus

Actually, Linus is looking suss to me, too, but I'm wary of BW-ing. Let me see if I can find the post of his that set bells ringing for me.

[Bolero]

After re-reading the Day 2 thread in light of what we know about Mantis, it looks to me like Linus and Mantis were working in concert to implicate praying. I mean, Linus' first popst in that thread was "vote praying".

[irretating]

AFAICT...

N0:
irre gave double-vote hammer to ut

N1:
scum NKed higgs
athene had a dream about higgs

msg protected msg
ut viewed irre
ut passed on double-vote hammer to mz ?

irre gave impotent dagger to aza

N2:
msg protected feck
scum targeted feck ?
aza had a dream about feck
aza wounded praying

??? NKed mz
denny NKed mantis
irre gave bus driver/view abilitity to ut/feck ?

Why do you assume higgs was a scum kill, yet you don't assume MZ was a scum kill?

[Bolero]

Right, I'm definitely going now. Just one question: Can we leave proxies in Mafia here?

[irretating]

After re-reading the Day 2 thread in light of what we know about Mantis, it looks to me like Linus and Mantis were working in concert to implicate praying. I mean, Linus' first popst in that thread was "vote praying".

Yes, going for the easy vote.

Linus is also the one most interested to find out what gift I gave to whom. He is also whiteknighting athene, for reasons unclear.

[irretating]

Right, I'm definitely going now. Just one question: Can we leave proxies in Mafia here?

No. You will need to put your vote down yourself.

[Linus]

where you specifically ask mantis who she is most suspicious of... now that stands out to me, because of everyone posting, why ask mantis?

She was lurking the thread at the time and I had a poor read on her. If you read through some of my TR games you'll find that that sort of questions is my standard M.O.

[irretating]

Heh, what a shame the dream thingy seems to have died with MZ. Aza got some useful info in his dream.

[Bolero]

AFAICT...

N0:
irre gave double-vote hammer to ut

N1:
scum NKed higgs
athene had a dream about higgs

msg protected msg
ut viewed irre
ut passed on double-vote hammer to mz ?

irre gave impotent dagger to aza

N2:
msg protected feck
scum targeted feck ?
aza had a dream about feck
aza wounded praying

??? NKed mz
denny NKed mantis
irre gave bus driver/view abilitity to ut/feck ?

Why do you assume higgs was a scum kill, yet you don't assume MZ was a scum kill?

Actually, I think I can answer this - didn't Aza say that in his dream about feck, someone tried to kill him (feck), but feck was protected? (Something about a party where one of the people couldn't get in?) So that would mean that either Feck or MZ was the scum target. Can scum NK more than one person?

Interesting, though, that Aza has also focused on praying. That's Mantis (known scum), Linus (IMO suss) and now Aza pointing the FoS at praying.

[Bolero]

Right, I'm definitely going now. Just one question: Can we leave proxies in Mafia here?

No. You will need to put your vote down yourself.

Alright, if I hang out logged in here all day, I won't do any work. I'll see you guys tomorrow.

In the meantime:

Vote Linus

[irretating]

Have you made a role claim, Linus?