Standard start:
Hi guys.
Non-committal defence of Zigmen:I am as nerdish as the next backyard naturalist and SF geek, but this flavour is about as distant from my normal interests as Pluto is from the Sun, so I will be asking dumb questions.
Nice follow, especially when you look later and she says that MZ hasn't posted enough for her to get a read on him. But by this time she had a good enough read that she voted him for mayor.be nize, guyz.
Zigmen may not have seen the game has started yet.
And backing irre up.
Sticks up for Zigmen again and then votes for ac for playing in a way that isn't familiar:Joining the crowd...
@@vote MagicZiggy@@
But Irre voting for someone else for mayor doesn't strike me as off - calling attention to herself, maybe, not exactly a great scum strategy..
Nice bit of explaining, the first of three or so filler posts that look really helpful and push her postcount up but don't actually contribute much.Don't Panic wrote:
Afternoon kids, sorry for being late, was a little busy all weekend, have caught up quickly with the thread, liking town noises from a few people, irre, feck and aza, for anyone interested.
@@vote irre@@
Not sure of mz, wouldn't put it past him to jump on gonzos admission of a mistake and run with it if he was the traitor.
Still nothing from zigmen?
##vote zigmen##
Come and play.
I haven't seen zigmen online at TR yesterday or today so far - he may not know the game started. Weekend, eh.
##vote andrewclunn##
He's new here, maybe, but where do they play mafia where everybody roleclaims on Day 1?
Cough up a site link, Andrew, so we can see for ourselves.
Nothing post then she goes away until the day is over:{quotes from feck and andrewclunn left out}Thanks for the link.
##unvote andrewclunn##
There are roles where you would want to be viewed or acted upon. Think someone mentioned scum don, who often views as town, or for town a bomb that kills any player doing a night action on the bomb player, etc.
But Day 1 mass role claiming sounded bizarre to many of us, gives scum a great advantage in special hunting and so on.
S/he goes away and comes back after the irre-charlou-no lynch thing happened.I'm biting my tongue here, Feck
Andrew, I skimmed that game's first few pages - yep, very different mafia culture.
And this is her impression. I read most of yesterday in one hit and to me the irre-charlou thing was definitely oimportant enough to comment on. b.ter's response seems to be a nice hedge; doesn't want to comment in case irre needs bussing later and won't back charlou in case there is enough doubt later for a viable wagon.WTF happened here while I was out?
NM, I'll go read.
More 'helpful' posts without any scum hunting.mafia dramazzz.
Lesson: don't let amok read the flavour source ever again because.
Put on the spot...Amok, I think you confused people - confused me too - because you kept referring to traitors when we all knew there was a traitor role, it's in the OP. And I at least assumed it was in the OP because Gonz had accidentally posted it in the PG, so decided to just state it was there plainly. It's a small game, it's unlikely there's another traitor role, so I couldn't figure out what you were trying to get at. It looked like redundant wifom or as if you were steadfastly refusing to read the OP.
Then there's two posts to andrewclunn explaining the difference in mafia and why early role claims are bad, iow filler with no substance, then this in response to charlou asking for further thoughts:Which thoughts? I already noted amok seemed confused to me and why. I accept she got sucked into the flavour and couldn't decide what to do about it as a town player. I think she's town.charlou wrote:b.ter, your thoughts too, please.
Charlou backs up with a question on MZ, DP and Aza. b.ter responds:Heh. Not very coherent, tbh. I think you, amok and irre are town. Also Athene, probably feck, probably shizzle. I'm not as sold on andrew the town newb as others seem to be, easy to hide in all that newbishness, but not convinced either way. I'm in my usual day 1 dunno mode.
Need moar posts? From MZ? Hmmm.In neutral on all three. Need moar posts. MZ seems towny from the get-go, but I've been fooled before.
But the real magic happened at the end when irre said that b.ter was on her wavelength and that irre had b.ter as town too.
And then b.ter says:
That is what pinged and pinged hard. b.ter has done no scum hunting this whole game. She ignored the huge discussion between charlou and irre, focussed briefly on amok's confusion and explained things to andrewclunn. But as for actual scum hunting...zero. Zero fosses, zero questions, zero votes, zero real analysis. But irre has b.ter in her town column.hmmm.
##vote b.ternarius##
