The Innsmouth Look game thread.

[ksen]

I think the following player should break ties: @@vote crumple@@

Why?

http://www.rationalia.com/forum/viewtop ... 14#p906814

dammit . . . l2read whole thread before asking questions.

@@vote oblivion@@

[Linus]

Why iclad?

iclad claimed to have played 2 games before in the sign-up thread, so probably won't be NKed early.

Then why did you make a point that your mayor vote on Crumple wasn't a seer view suggestion since by his own admission he is also a newb?

It is typical for me to distinguish my mayor vote from my seer suggestions, because I hate the seer convention. Do you find it suspicious that Mantis answered for me without having paid much attention to my posts? Or was she just a bit hasty?

[oblivion]

I think the following player should break ties: @@vote crumple@@

Why?

http://www.rationalia.com/forum/viewtop ... 14#p906814

dammit . . . l2read whole thread before asking questions.

@@vote oblivion@@

What answer did you find? Are you satisfied with it?

[r.c]

@@vote irre@@

This is also a seer suggestion. I find her difficult to read. Also with UT not playing this game, it would be interesting to see who she targets on day 1.

[Linus]

UT is #5 on the player list, you are #6.

[ksen]

I think the following player should break ties: @@vote crumple@@

Why?

http://www.rationalia.com/forum/viewtop ... 14#p906814

dammit . . . l2read whole thread before asking questions.

@@vote oblivion@@

What answer did you find? Are you satisfied with it?

I found the answer here:

http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 69#p906969

Not entirely satisfying but I can see some of his reasoning. I'm just not satisfied with why he wouldn't call for a crumple view as well since crumple fits the same criteria as iclad that linus used to call for a view of iclad.

[oblivion]

I think the following player should break ties: @@vote crumple@@

Why?

http://www.rationalia.com/forum/viewtop ... 14#p906814

dammit . . . l2read whole thread before asking questions.

@@vote oblivion@@

What answer did you find? Are you satisfied with it?

I found the answer here:

http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 69#p906969

Not entirely satisfying but I can see some of his reasoning. I'm just not satisfied with why he wouldn't call for a crumple view as well since crumple fits the same criteria as iclad that linus used to call for a view of iclad.

agree.

I thought it was odd that you kinda dropped it.

[ksen]

I thought it was odd that you kinda dropped it.

I was dropping the "why mayor vote crumple" question for now, not the "why no seer view suggestion for crumple" question. Just seems like a weird thing for linus to take the time to point out.

[Linus]

@@vote irre@@

This is also a seer suggestion. I find her difficult to read. Also with UT not playing this game, it would be interesting to see who she targets on day 1.

I don't follow. Does irre usually focus on UT on day 1?

[ksen]

Hey guys, did you know that talking about suggested seer views could help scum narrow down their seer suspects?

It's true!

[Feck]

Hey guys, did you know that talking about suggested seer views could help scum narrow down their seer suspects?

It's true!

erm No not really ?

[ksen]

How about we play mafia instead of playing let's get the specials to do all of our work?

[Zigmen]

Why iclad?

iclad claimed to have played 2 games before in the sign-up thread, so probably won't be NKed early.

Probably won't be NKed early?

What about lynched early?

Why did you point out the NK style specifically and not just say "get killed early?"

[Athene]

Why?

http://www.rationalia.com/forum/viewtop ... 14#p906814

dammit . . . l2read whole thread before asking questions.

@@vote oblivion@@

What answer did you find? Are you satisfied with it?

I found the answer here:

http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.p ... 69#p906969

Not entirely satisfying but I can see some of his reasoning. I'm just not satisfied with why he wouldn't call for a crumple view as well since crumple fits the same criteria as iclad that linus used to call for a view of iclad.

agree.

I thought it was odd that you kinda dropped it.

I think it's odd that much is being made of it tbh. Linus seems to be stratergerising.

[Linus]

Why iclad?

iclad claimed to have played 2 games before in the sign-up thread, so probably won't be NKed early.

Probably won't be NKed early?

What about lynched early?

Why did you point out the NK style specifically and not just say "get killed early?"

It's very hard to know at the start of the game who is likely to get lynched early. Who do you think, based on all the info available to you right now, is most likely to survive to endgame?