Dune 2.0 Game Thread

[MissingNo.]

The goal of the serial killer was to cause chaos among both factions. I don't see why her win condition would be to kill Paul.

[Animavore]

Maybe I should read those rules now

[sifaka]

if I was given an Indie task that meant I won by picking off one person[/b] I wouldn't go trying to pick a random on the first night.

Don't be so sure about that, that's exactly what Lion (the PI) did in the first game. He used his one bullet on Starr who was an innocent.

[Don't Panic]

The goal of the serial killer was to cause chaos among both factions. I don't see why her win condition would be to kill Paul.

From the storyline of the book it would be, but I think we need to remember that the game is only using the book as background.

[MissingNo.]

Err, sorry, it was to "weaken" both factions. Maybe you're right. From what I've seen, it seems like Paul is the main character in Dune? If he could be considered the "leader" of our faction, I could see how having him killed could be a weakening of our team.

[Animavore]

This game is really confusing when you don't have a clue of the roles

[CookieJon]

Seems like a lucky guess to pick one player out of twenty and hit a probable major character.

I was wondering that. I mean if I was given an Indie task that meant I won by picking off one person I wouldn't go trying to pick a random on the first night.

Ani why do you say that? Where do you get the impression that the Indie task's aim was to "pick off one person" in particular?

In the last Mafia game, I noticed you deliberately "misunderstanding" rules and events, etc, and it appears you're doing the same again here.

Please explain!?

I can't be arsed reading the rules. That's why.
Someone said the Indie had an independent winning condition. I presumed the winning condition was to take out Paul, I could be wrong, but I don't see why it wouldn't be that.

I see. That's a fair assumption, I suppose.

Why did rezling go straight for Paul unless she had information?

Hmm. You're not making sense, and I know you're smarter than that...
1. Why assume the assassin only had one attack in the whole game?
2. Why do you say "go straight for Paul"? She didn't attack Paul.
3. Why say "unless she had information"? What information could she possibly have had, and even if there was any, it wasn't very good information since she got the wrong victim, which makes the question "Why go straight for Paul unless she had information?" redundant.

Something's fishy here.

[sifaka]

Err, sorry, it was to "weaken" both factions. Maybe you're right. From what I've seen, it seems like Paul is the main character in Dune? If he could be considered the "leader" of our faction, I could see how having him killed could be a weakening of our team.

I agree with that, but how would it be a weakening of the scum team?

[95Theses]

Righto

I am Ramallo, the Fremen Reverend Mother of Sietch Tabr. I am a truthsayer.

I can test peoples claims for truth.

I tested this claim :

Subject: Dune 2.0 Game Thread

I have no idea why animavore is making this campaign against me. I'm with town.

As a sign of good faith I will not vote against animavore, but I would like him to stop thinking about a prior game - a prior life - and focus on the here and now. If he is with town, he needs to stop dividing the good people.

Mephistophiles - we honour your bravery and sacrifice.

Specifically the 'I am town' part and found it to be true.

Therefore Irre can be 100% trusted and I have just got quite valuable for the innocents.

I'd like to see every single person make an clear statement about who's side they are on in this game.

Anyone who can protect me should probably consider doing so at your earliest opportunity as I'm no doubt Scum target numero uno now.

[Animavore]

2. Why do you say "go straight for Paul"? She didn't attack Paul.

She did attack Paul but Paul had a bodyguard (Meph) who protected him.

[MissingNo.]

Err, sorry, it was to "weaken" both factions. Maybe you're right. From what I've seen, it seems like Paul is the main character in Dune? If he could be considered the "leader" of our faction, I could see how having him killed could be a weakening of our team.

I agree with that, but how would it be a weakening of the scum team?

It wouldn't. Maybe her goal was to kill the leaders of both teams.

[virphen]

I'm sticking with animavore unless extremely convincing evidence appears on someone else. He's spreading as much disinformation and confusion as he can.

Even if he's innocent if he keeps this up he's a liability.

[irreligionist]

retract vote for 95theses

[CookieJon]

2. Why do you say "go straight for Paul"? She didn't attack Paul.

She did attack Paul but Paul had a bodyguard (Meph) who protected him.

Oh yeah, sorry... you're right.

[Animavore]

Unvote 95theses