Old West Mafia game thread

[Magicziggy]

My view of you is you are town and having a very bad game.
I have posted my rationale for believing you are town in the face of others saying you play like this as scum.
I haven't seen that. However, you are now trolley tracking me. There's no reason to.

[Zigmen]

My view of you is you are town and having a very bad game.
I have posted my rationale for believing you are town in the face of others saying you play like this as scum.
I haven't seen that. However, you are now trolley tracking me. There's no reason to.

What's wrong with my game? I've partially cleared players based on yesterday's events, looked at who remains, and voted for a player for 3 solid reasons (4 if you count "followy") and has yet to address any of the reasons i put forth.

I've also inspired discussion and put forth a synopsis that even you found valuable.

So, why is my game "very bad?"

[Magicziggy]

Because you are an easy lynch and I'm just about giving up defending you.

[Zigmen]

Because you are an easy lynch and I'm just about giving up defending you.

I'm an easy lynch because the most vocal players tend to garner the most suspicion. That doesn't make my logic wrong, though, does it?

If you think my list is wrong, please, by all means explain why. If you think I've voted for you because my reasons are incorrect, then correct me.

And I officially give you permission to go ahead and give up defending me. I can handle the pressure just fine on my own by pointing out the facts of this game.

Again, why is my game "very bad?" Because I'm an easy lynch? I don't mind dying to get discussion moving and get some people on the record making pro-town or anti-town stands.

It's how games are won.

[Magicziggy]

And lost, if you trolley track on the wrong player for the wrong reasons.

Go for your life. No one will back you up in lynching me.
You are on your own.
You have made it about you and what you want to do.
Mass claim? No discussion because no one will listen to you.

[Zigmen]

And lost, if you trolley track on the wrong player for the wrong reasons.

Go for your life. No one will back you up in lynching me.
You are on your own.
You have made it about you and what you want to do.
Mass claim? No discussion because no one will listen to you.

So who do you have as cleared-looking because of yesterday's actions?

[Magicziggy]

I have as cleared the four on ksens bw. Feck, Irre, rc and the departed gib.
I have no reason to think gonzo is cleared.
I have UT as town. I have you as town.

My suspect list consists of Mantis, DP and gonzo. I really don;t think Jerome is scum, but he's absolutely useless to town.

[Zigmen]

I have as cleared the four on ksens bw. Feck, Irre, rc and the departed gib.
I have no reason to think gonzo is cleared.
I have UT as town. I have you as town.

My suspect list consists of Mantis, DP and gonzo. I really don;t think Jerome is scum, but he's absolutely useless to town.

So, with the exception of Jerome and yourself, we have the exact same list of who is probably cleared.

You might want to read back over the discussion about Jerome again and possibly rethink your position bearing one question is mind. If Jerome was Scum, why didn't Ksen for for me to save him? And, if you think Scum was bussing, and you think Jerome was Scum, why Didn't Ksen vote for Jerome?

My suspect list is identical to yours, except you are on my list as well. I also still have Jerome on that list, but near the bottom.

Now look at the votes we've seen today.

We really need to pull this together if we plan to win.

I'll tentatively unvote you as a gesture of good faith because I think you're keeping your calm under pressure, but pressing a few scummy issues.

##unvote##

Here's our common ground:

6. Mantisdreamz
9. dp

I'd lean toward DP from this list. Thoughts?

[Uselesstwit]

ksen asked for a sub in the peanut gallery, so we should probably increase the idea of a bussing, since scum might have wanted the remaining players to look innocent more than a sub.

MZ why do I look so town to you? It feels like my contribution has been lackluster at best to me, so having people defend me is raising my suspicions.

Irre, same question to you, with the additional, wtf? I openly admitted to voting gonzo yesterday to help stave off a zigmen BW, but you think zigmen is one of the 2 most likely scum? How is the person who in your opinion voted for a townie to save a scum your pick for most cleared? It doesn't make a lot of sense in light of the day one lynch, which if it was an all town win, should have cleared people more than my behavior to date has.

Sorry to be so focused on myself, but being cleared early is something I look for in both mz and irre's scum games.

[Uselesstwit]

shouldn't jerome be moving his vote off of irre if he was just looking for a reaction, or does he just leave the first vote that comes into his mind on all day?

[Uselesstwit]

mantis really isn't looking town to me, also not really scum she's just kind of there. I do agree with her analysis of rc. There was absolutely no need for a hammer vote on scum unless BOTH zigmen and gonzo were scum, which would be a 4 man scum team so not possible. He could have not voted or dropped the hammer on either of the other two with very little repercussions.

[Uselesstwit]

actually an add to my last post, if it was a bus, IMO feck and rc would be the most likely scum on that BW, and like I said earlier ksen did need to be subbed out so it does make a bus more likely.

[Zigmen]

actually an add to my last post, if it was a bus, IMO feck and rc would be the most likely scum on that BW, and like I said earlier ksen did need to be subbed out so it does make a bus more likely.

I agree with this, if there was a bus. I don't think there was, but it's possible.

I have to go to work in a few. In case I miss nightfall, which is a good possibility, I'll vote now. I'm choosing Mantis over DP based on a gut feeling.

Also, in response to your question about Jerome, he could leave his vote where it is and that would be fairly normal for him. Like I said, you can't read him from his voting. He will flail if put under pressure, though. He does that as Town and Scum, unfortunately . . . but a bit more so as Scum.

##Vote Mantis##

[Gonzo]

You don't think Jerome could be a jester? It's a weird vote with no justification.

No, it's a Jerome vote, and I think you're way overreacting to it.

Also, I wasn't asking you.

lol you made a post just like this in Eve Mafia as scum. Your scum game seems to be indistinguishable from your current gameplay.

[Gonzo]

Oh, anyone wanna discuss a mass claim?

Not me.