MiniMafia 02

[Animavore]

I'm thinking Ghat too.
I thought he was a bit aggressive in wanting to put the votes on me at the start of the day with nothing to go on.

What do others thing?

[irretating]

Ziggy, your day one behaviour was either townie making an error about ed, or that of the most ballsy scum ever seen. That you are asking why you should be cleared just further paints you as town. If you're scum it's the best performance I've seen yet?

I believe sifaka is who she claims to be, too?

Budski was unfortunate; I think feral, ani and feck are on my most suspicious list. Seer could consider viewing ani or ghat then outing tomorrow ?

[Feral_Punctuation]

1 Ghat - suspicious
2 Feck - ???
3 sifaka - most likely vig or sk
4 feral p - me
5 twinkie - probably innocent
6 Ani - probably innocent
7 MZ - ???

Ghat looks suspicious because he was pressing the vote on Eduard and Ani (who now looks innocent).
I can't really read Feck, but I'll look back at his posts later.
Sifaka looks to be vig or sk. I'm not sure killing someone on a hunch (even if it turned out to be a good move) is a great reason for a vig to kill someone, so she may well be a sk. Still, I don't how to play vig and I don't think a sk's as much of a problem as the scum right now. We can wait and see if a vig kill actually happens or if she was just bluffing.
I can't make a judgment on how scummy I'm looking right now.
Twinkie said I was 'fossing' her by asking how she knew both Ani and Ghat were town. I thought it was a perfectly reasonable question and for what it's worth, I think Twinkie is one of the more trustworthy people here.
Ani seems innocent, for reasons already stated.
MZ. Voted for Budski with the reason "Why not?". I don't think scum would be that stupid. He seems to be acting pro-town now, getting people talking about why they think people are innocent or scummy.

At least that's how it's looking to me.
I'm going to go over the last couple of pages and look at the sifaka bw now.

The other thing that struck me as strange is how three people in a row turned straight to Budski when sifaka was let off the hook. Ghat, MZ and Sifaka. Sifaka, at least, seemed to be jumping on the bw.

btw, What does FOS stand for?

[irretating]

Interesting analysis, feral?

FoS is finger of suspicion which is letting someone know they are suspect without lynch voting them.

If I survive the night I'm going to look over the whole thread with a fine tooth comb, yes?

[Azathoth]

Interesting that you didn't put an analysis for feck. Are you and he the scummers?

[Feral_Punctuation]

OK, thanks Twinkie.

Ghat, I haven't seen anyone post much of an analysis of Feck. He just seems difficult to read. He hasn't dropped any obvious hints he's scum, but I've got no reason to believe he's anything more than a good scum player.

Besides, that would be a bit obvious, don't you think?

[Feck]

I'm just trying not to jump on any band wagons but to consider my lynch votes

Have we not lynched enough town to learn that yet ?

[Magicziggy]

I'm just trying not to jump on any band wagons but to consider my lynch votes

Have we not lynched enough town to learn that yet ?

You jumped on Ani's bandwagon and did not shift in the light of Mantis's death.
Isn't that right?
Are you convinced about Ani? Why?

[Feck]

I'm just trying not to jump on any band wagons but to consider my lynch votes

Have we not lynched enough town to learn that yet ?

You jumped on Ani's bandwagon and did not shift in the light of Mantis's death.
Isn't that right?
Are you convinced about Ani? Why?

I can't believe that Ani would act like he did ,it was almost like he wanted us to think he is scum , but then Ghat changed his mind so quickly I feel that one of them is scum and Ani seems more likely to me

call it an informed guess ?

[Zigmen]

A busy night, you ask?

Twinkie was impaled by a violin bow. Twinkie is very dead. She was Vanilla Town.

Ghat is found with green (fast acting) poison in the mouth. Ghat was your Seer and was town.

The Living:

3 Feck
5 sifaka
6 feral p
8 Ani
10 MZ


The Dead:
1 Charlou - Vanilla Town
2 Ghat - Town Seer
4 Mantisdreamz - Scum Don
7 twinkie - Vanilla Town
9 Eduard - Town Doc
11 Budskiboo - Vanilla Town

Can town still win?

[Zigmen]

Day 3 is up!
http://rationalia.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=81&t=16156

Having fun?

[Azathoth]

[Feral_Punctuation]

OK. I guess Ghat was killed by the vig/sk (almost certainly sifaka) because he was poisoned, like mantis. Which means scum killed Twinkie. Why would they do that, when they could get the vig? Presumably they thought either the vig would kill the wrong person (meaning they are considered to be town), that Twinkie was a special (she would have had to be seer to be more of a threat than the vig, though, I think) or that Twinkie was onto them. I think the latter isn't too likely, it doesn't seem to be something considered when playing scum. But I know less about that than the rest of you veterans

Perhaps sifaka could tell us why she chose Ghat?

[Feck]

@ zigman Yes we can still win but we will have to be bloody careful who we lynch today won't we?

[Magicziggy]

sifaka = sk?
thoughts?

me = town

Ghat must have seen me because he was convinced I was town very early.
It was my guess that he was seer and I think scum saw this as well.

The first vote on me will come from a scum player.
I hope sif is vig, because otherwise town is cactus.

Our only chance is that Sif is vig. In which case it's a 3-2 split. If she's sk, then it's 2-2-1.

Ani? FP? FecK?