ElfQuest Mafia - Game Thread

[divagreen]

I am pretty sure Bolero has a mentor. That is about the only other insight that I can offer that is not based upon wildly paranoid speculation.

We also have to look at that if recruitment was possible, it most likely happened on Night 0.

[Bolero]

We have seven players left ... If we remove one, town is still likely to be well represented among the remaining six. I'm willing to vote Bolero on the chance that she is an SK, so that possibility is dealt with and out of the way.

Great. Thanks a lot.

( Sorry, just taking a blow to the ego over being a possibilty to be dealt with and out of the way.)

Look, I know I'm innocent, so of course I'm thinking of what the other possibilities could be. At this stage I think it's more than likely we're dealing with a 3rd faction working together.

[charlou]

So do I, fwiw, Bolero.


What is the likelihood, in a nineteen player game, that there are town, scum (at least 4), masons (at least two) and two indies?


What is the likelihood, in a nineteen player game, that there are town, scum (at least 4), masons (at least two), one indie and another faction?

[Linus]

We also have to look at that if recruitment was possible, it most likely happened on Night 0.

Why is N0 most likely? There have been two regular nights without dagger kills.

[charlou]

so you think the seer that has correctly identified everyone he's viewed is an indie? That is really kinda nuts. You think with a scum team that at the very least has a don and a scumblocker, town wouldn't have a seer? Charlou, you might be having the off game to end all off games.

Mason members can have additional roles (Cop, Doctor) in addition to being a mason.

in addition to

Sometimes, one member of the masonry group is a scum mason, a person in the masonry who is secretly part of the mafia or some other scum group. This occasionally happens in games where the moderater does not specifically tell all masons that they are all town.

But like I said, I'm willing to vote Bolero to eliminate the possibility of her as an SK if anyone else thinks that's more likely.

[Bolero]

I am pretty sure Bolero has a mentor. That is about the only other insight that I can offer that is not based upon wildly paranoid speculation.

We also have to look at that if recruitment was possible, it most likely happened on Night 0.

Actually, I don't. I was offered one, but turned it down. I'd already played a game as vanilla town before, and just didn't think I needed one. I'm sure oblivion can confirm this if need be.

[charlou]

divagreen, do you have a mentor?

[charlou]

We also have to look at that if recruitment was possible, it most likely happened on Night 0.

Why is N0 most likely? There have been two regular nights without dagger kills.

Yes, kill or recruit ...

[Uselesstwit]

go back and read bolero on day two. see how much cheerleading she does. It really looks like she's deliberately tightened her game up since then. I think what we should do is get rid of the unknowns either thru lynching them or thru views and then start the wifom. Yesterday's lynch was a travesty, you killed someone who had a proven action on the same night the dagger was used on someone else. That's where this sort of wifom has gotten us. Let's stick to the basics for now.

[Feck]

Seems strange that we have missed them all in lynches and scum team have also not killed any of them ! and as for recruiting I've been cleared town most of the game why not recruit me ,It's makes little sense . I don't think it's as complicated as some of you are trying to make it .

[Uselesstwit]

exactly feck, i think we have a simple sk on our hands. anything more than that at this point is just going to get people running in circles.

[Linus]

It's really hard not to lynch praying, but I guess her consistent inattention saves her. I've basically got nothing so I'll go with flavor and Rayek.

vote bolero

[charlou]

UT, you've done a bit of clearing, but little scum hunting. Feck, you're not doing much scum hunting either. Day five you just went along with the vote changes at the end of the day.

[charlou]

go back and read bolero on day two. see how much cheerleading she does. It really looks like she's deliberately tightened her game up since then. I think what we should do is get rid of the unknowns either thru lynching them or thru views and then start the wifom. Yesterday's lynch was a travesty, you killed someone who had a proven action on the same night the dagger was used on someone else. That's where this sort of wifom has gotten us. Let's stick to the basics for now.

If you're a separate faction, of course you'd want to eliminate the "unknowns" as they're most likely town.

[Bolero]

go back and read bolero on day two. see how much cheerleading she does. It really looks like she's deliberately tightened her game up since then. I think what we should do is get rid of the unknowns either thru lynching them or thru views and then start the wifom. Yesterday's lynch was a travesty, you killed someone who had a proven action on the same night the dagger was used on someone else. That's where this sort of wifom has gotten us. Let's stick to the basics for now.

I was cheerleading it's true. That's the way I play on Ratskep. Then someone FoSed me for it (zigmen, I think?) and I realised maybe it wasn't done like that over here. I tightened up. No big mystery.

Guys, I can tell you you're barking up the wrong tree, but I'm bereft of alternative ideas to suggest. Someone's using a Sunfolk dagger, and I'm guessing that's designed to do exactly what it's doing - i.e. casting suspicion on me.