Venture Bros: day 1

[Mantisdreamz]

I have good reason to believe Matt.
I have good reason to believe this is one weird arse game.

OK, you know we're going to ask you 'why?'

Because I'm hank.

Why are you not immediately lynch voting him? You're both claiming the same character?

Because either:

1) Linus has fucked up Matt's safe claim

or 2)Linus has fucked up the town roles

or 3) It's a weird arse game with identical characters

you don;t make up a word like fungible. It's why asked about hank.

It's not enough to condemn Matt though.

this is strange.

[Mantisdreamz]

MZ, when you saw Shizz claim the same as your character, why was your first instinct to trust him?

General question: Would you have trusted Shizz if you were in MZ's spot?

I would not have.

IMHO, this makes MZ look equally if not more suspicious than Shizz.

Not really. There would be no reason for MZ as scum to claim the same character. Doesn;t say anything about Matt's claim though.

[Mantisdreamz]

MZ, when you saw Shizz claim the same as your character, why was your first instinct to trust him?

General question: Would you have trusted Shizz if you were in MZ's spot?

I would not have.

IMHO, this makes MZ look equally if not more suspicious than Shizz.

agreed, which makes irre's reaction so very pingworthy. why vote shizzle instead or trying to figure out which one to trust. Along with the self voting, i'm just seeing her town game.

##vote irre##

mm.. i saw matt's claim as being more suspicious than mz's

[gib]

To reiterate if MZ was scum he'd be dumb to claim the same as me as once I was lynched and my role confirmed he'd be lynched - and 1 scum for 1 VT is good for town. I would almost say we should both be lynched but I wonder about weird roles. Town should still consider lynching both of us...

Now I have reason to lynch you.
##vote Mattshizzle##

explain to me what you were thinking here please

a scum move to get a town player to the lynch.

you thought a scum shizzle would draw attention to himself just to get a townie lynched

how does that work exactly?

[Mantisdreamz]

##vote UT##

gib - don't you think that as scum, MZ wouldn;t be pointing out and claiming that he's the same character as Matt?

[Magicziggy]

To reiterate if MZ was scum he'd be dumb to claim the same as me as once I was lynched and my role confirmed he'd be lynched - and 1 scum for 1 VT is good for town. I would almost say we should both be lynched but I wonder about weird roles. Town should still consider lynching both of us...

Now I have reason to lynch you.
##vote Mattshizzle##

explain to me what you were thinking here please

a scum move to get a town player to the lynch.

you thought a scum shizzle would draw attention to himself just to get a townie lynched

how does that work exactly?

Don't know. Why would a town player suggest lynching two town players? I'm not suggesting it.

[Mantisdreamz]

Don't know. Why would a town player suggest lynching two town players? I'm not suggesting it.

good point. Matt - why did you say that?

[gib]

Just read the thread backwards. Irre is voting for herself because scum got the don voted in last game.

Her vote on shizzle is bothering me. Its the complete logic fail about Matt's hank claim. She says it's more likely that the gm would fuck up a scum safe claim over a town role pm. That doesn't compute. I'd vote her if I didn't have the nagging suspicion she were trying to get lynched.

that's a terrible reason not to vote someone

[Magicziggy]

Just read the thread backwards. Irre is voting for herself because scum got the don voted in last game.

Her vote on shizzle is bothering me. Its the complete logic fail about Matt's hank claim. She says it's more likely that the gm would fuck up a scum safe claim over a town role pm. That doesn't compute. I'd vote her if I didn't have the nagging suspicion she were trying to get lynched.

that's a terrible reason not to vote someone

Can't believe that Irre would string together to shaky town games back to back.
But she's a possible for my vote.

[Feck]

Why have none of you bunch of Hankers voted me for Mayor ? .
I find MZ 's thoughts in the order he posted them about Matt confusing and not at all natural for town (mind you natural around here is often freaky)

[gib]

##vote UT##

gib - don't you think that as scum, MZ wouldn;t be pointing out and claiming that he's the same character as Matt?

i think both hanks are probably town, yes

[Magicziggy]

Why have none of you bunch of Hankers voted me for Mayor ? .
I find MZ 's thoughts in the order he posted them about Matt confusing and not at all natural for town (mind you natural around here is often freaky)

That's because you aren't me.
Be grateful.

[Feck]

Can we assume that there is another Hank ? can we assume all Hanks are town ?

[gib]

Now I have reason to lynch you.
##vote Mattshizzle##

explain to me what you were thinking here please

a scum move to get a town player to the lynch.

you thought a scum shizzle would draw attention to himself just to get a townie lynched

how does that work exactly?

Don't know. Why would a town player suggest lynching two town players? I'm not suggesting it.

you don't know how your own thought process worked?

shizz was pretty clear about how he thought trading himself as vt for a scum was a good deal

[Mantisdreamz]

##vote UT##

gib - don't you think that as scum, MZ wouldn;t be pointing out and claiming that he's the same character as Matt?

i think both hanks are probably town, yes

I don't know about Matt... but, it seemed like you were drilling MZ. I just can't imagine scum claiming the same name.