ElfQuest Mafia - Game Thread

[charlou]

ETA: I was allowed to hint that I knew why Feck was quiet yesterday, which is why I posted this.

Now that just seems a bit far fetched. An identical posting restriction to Feck's, but with that exception?


If UT and Bolero were switched, would that have given last night's view to Bolero? Or would the switch have only affected any nightkill action against one of the two? I guess it would probably be the latter.

[Bolero]

ETA: I was allowed to hint that I knew why Feck was quiet yesterday, which is why I posted this.

Now that just seems a bit far fetched. An identical posting restriction to Feck's, but with that exception?


If UT and Bolero were switched, would that have given last night's view to Bolero? Or would the switch have only affected any nightkill action against one of the two? I guess it would probably be the latter.

Hey guys. I've been in class, so I missed the excitement.

So Night 4 switched me and UT, eh? Well, I can tell you nothing happened to me - good or bad (no, I didn't get UT's night view), so I'm guessing UT wasn't a target on night 4.

I THOUGHT you must've had a posting restriction, Linus. You just popped up with one thing to say, then nothing else for the rest of the day, despite hanging around.

[charlou]

ETA: I was allowed to hint that I knew why Feck was quiet yesterday, which is why I posted this.

You posted that on day four.

[Bolero]

So what happens now? Do we get to have another short night, or are we going for the full night round?

Linus, was the gift from irre a pass-it-on type thing? Or a one-shot deal? I'm not saying tell me all the details - it would just give us a bit of hope if there was something out there being used for town.

Also, what does Denny's lynching tell us about MSG and/or diva? Maybe nothing, except that we're all grasping at straws and unable to agree on where to point the FoS.

[charlou]

Bolero, which timezone are you?

[Linus]

ETA: I was allowed to hint that I knew why Feck was quiet yesterday, which is why I posted this.

Now that just seems a bit far fetched. An identical posting restriction to Feck's, but with that exception?

I the posting restriction seems to be identical. Technically, the PM only said the posting restriction would happen the day after I used the gift, but I thought it might violate the spirit of the rule if used my inside knowledge to explicitly confirm Feck's restriction. I checked with Oblivion and it was OK to link to Irre post on the matter.

If UT and Bolero were switched, would that have given last night's view to Bolero? Or would the switch have only affected any nightkill action against one of the two? I guess it would probably be the latter.

No. But if UT had chosen to view Bolero, it would have given him a view of himself instead. It's perfectly symmetric. Night actions targeting UT would've targeted Bolero instead, and vice versa. I'm not sure what would've happen if Bolero is the killer and targeted UT---suicide or nothing...

[Linus]

Linus, was the gift from irre a pass-it-on type thing? Or a one-shot deal? I'm not saying tell me all the details - it would just give us a bit of hope if there was something out there being used for town.

I could have chosen to pass it on, but didn't.

[Linus]

So what happens now? Do we get to have another short night, or are we going for the full night round?

Depends, I guess. Have you submitted your night action?

[Feck]

vote Oblivion

[Linus]

Praying, who are your top suspects?

[praying]

msg
linus

[charlou]

Linus, was the gift from irre a pass-it-on type thing? Or a one-shot deal? I'm not saying tell me all the details - it would just give us a bit of hope if there was something out there being used for town.

I could have chosen to pass it on, but didn't.

Why not?

[Linus]

Linus, was the gift from irre a pass-it-on type thing? Or a one-shot deal? I'm not saying tell me all the details - it would just give us a bit of hope if there was something out there being used for town.

I could have chosen to pass it on, but didn't.

Why not?

Mostly because I wanted to make sure the seer lived another night.

[divagreen]

I just got back and I am catching up.

Why in the world did you guys vote for Denny? Denny killed the Don with an elfbow. Not the same weapon used on anyone else. It was a random gift given by the GM...why the heck would the GM give the SK another weapon?

I wasn't white-knighting Denny, I was following his logic which made a helluva lot more sense then MSG's.

[charlou]

I just got back and I am catching up.

Why in the world did you guys vote for Denny? Denny killed the Don with an elfbow. Not the same weapon used on anyone else. It was a random gift given by the GM...why the heck would the GM give the SK another weapon?

I wasn't white-knighting Denny, I was following his logic which made a helluva lot more sense then MSG's.

Can you summarise why you find MSG's logic ... illogical?