Not just up - up ridiculously, contrary to the promises upon which it was based. Do we not remember the pre-Obamacare conversations about this? Oh, it would reduce costs, reduce fraud, streamline the administrative processes, and reduce premiums across the board, except for the very wealthy. If you like your doctor, you can keep him or her. If you like your plan, you can keep it. All bullshit. Unadulterated bullshit.Tero wrote:Of course the rates go up.
It's no answer to say "of course" this and "of course" that. The plan was sold on the exact opposite.
That's a huge problem. Having only one payer is a problem. Your state had multiple payers competing a while back. Aetna basically left Florida. They offer 3 plans in Florida now, all of which are insanely expensive, and none of which are accepted by most physicians. I had to go shopping for a plan our pediatricians take. Because, hey, if we like our doctor, we can keep our doctor... provided we go shopping for the plan they take this year. That changes every fucking year, too. Time was, you could just re-fucking-new your plan. Now, they discontinue plans all the time, so you have reapply for a new plan, go through all the god-damn stipulations, and copay provisions, and deductible provisions, and compare and contrast this plan and that plan, do I want a PPO or an HMO, do I want high premium/low deductible (and by high premium I mean like $1,700 per month), or do I want a lower premium (like $1100 per month or so) and a higher deductible and a Health savings account (meaning you're still paying out about $1500 to $1700 per month depending on how much you dump into the HSA.Tero wrote: Obamacare is not like Medicare. They hook you into buying year after year. My state has essentially only Aetna.
I mean, Tero, please. I know you love Obama, and you want to be all left wing "kinder than thou" and you care about the poor and the health of the people and all that, while other folks are heartless scumbags who only want to see people dying in the streets, but, there is no shining up this turd. Even good-faith, totally nice folks like Obama, Clinton, Reid, Pelosi, etc., even they can get it wrong once in a while. Loyalty doesn't mean you just keep finding ways to put lipstick on a pig.
You have a different definition of "monopoly" than in common parlance, but before Obamacare there wasn't a monopoly. If there is now, that's a change from 8 years ago. But, if this "hospitals and doctors will charge whatever insurance is willing to pay" was obvious in 2010, why did you support Obamacare? Or, are you going the "oh, of course..." route now because you can see it's a shitstorm but you have to come up with a way to make it palatable. "Oh, pshaw, you sill goose! We all know the insurance would be much more expensive, and you wouldn't likely be able to keep your doctor or plan, and it wouldn't reduce costs or premiums... everybody knew that! Whyever would you think otherwsise...?"Tero wrote:
The healthcare monopoly isn't cheap. The hospitals and doctors will charge whatever the insurance is willing to pay.
Which calculations? Indeed, the catastrophic plans were a good buy for people who could weather a $5,000 or $10,000 storm, but just needed to make sure they could be covered for larger issues. Fuck 'em, though! Those are the ones who should have been paying more, to make the entire system more affordable across the board, right? We have to have everyone in the plan to make sure there is a broader set of premium payers, and the $50k and $75k a year single men who weren't interested in paying $1200 month for health insurance, well, they were getting off light! They needed to be paying "their fair share" so that the rest could get coverage. Worked out great! now everyone is paying out the ass!Tero wrote:
The catastrophic plans had little to do with where the rates were going. Those people never used insurance so their input to the calculations was minimal.
Obamacare caused that to skyrocket much faster than ever before. it's not even debatable.Tero wrote:
As soon as "insurance pays for it" enters into healthcare, doctors will always charge the maximum. Obamacare or not. Trend was always a bigger % of your income.
Of course insurance causes costs to go up. Once an individual is covered by insurance, his or her incentive is to use the insurance. So, instead of living with a dent in your car, you go get it fixed. When you have health insurance and your kid gets the sniffles, there is no downside to take him or her into the doctor. And, the doctor has a bigger incentive to err on the side of providing the service.
With a single payer plan, there is a similar cost incentive. the government remedies that with price controls, and creating long lines for disfavored procedures, and simply excluding certain procedures to save costs. There is no panacea.